Butler was born in Duluth, Georgia, and is the son of Kevin Butler, a former University of Georgia and NFL placekicker who began his career with the 1985 Chicago Bears.[1] He attended Peachtree Ridge High School in Suwanee, Georgia, and played high school football for the Peachtree Ridge Lions.[1] As a junior, he averaged 40 yards per punt with a longest kick of 63 yards and 13 punts inside the 20-yard line.[2] Following his senior season in 2006, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and the Georgia Sports Writers Association named him to their Class 5A all-state first-teams.[3]Scout.com rated him as the No. 9 punter recruit in the nation. He also played Peachtree Ridge Lions golf team,[1] while maintaining a 3.9 grade point average.[2]
On December 6, 2011, he was honored as a National Football Foundation (NFF) Scholar-Athlete Award recipient, named a finalist for the William V. Campbell Trophy.[15] He was also honored on that same day when he earned honorable mention All-SEC recognition by the Associated Press.[16] On December 8, he repeated in 2011 as a first-team Academic All-America selection.[17]
Professional career
Pittsburgh Steelers
On April 28, 2012, following the 2012 NFL draft, Butler was one of 12 undrafted free agent rookies signed by the Pittsburgh Steelers.[18] During the 2012 season, Butler punted 77 times, and averaged 43.8 yards.[19] For the 2013 NFL season he beat Brian Moorman in preseason to make the 53-man roster.
Chicago Bears
On December 31, 2013, Butler was signed to a future/reserve contract by the Chicago Bears.[20] On May 18, Butler was released.[21]
Detroit Lions
On July 25, 2014, Butler was signed by the Detroit Lions.[22] The Lions released Butler on August 25, 2014.[23]
Arizona Cardinals
The Cardinals signed Butler on September 8, 2014.[24] Butler made his debut for the Cardinals later that same day in their 2014 season opener against the San Diego Chargers on ESPN's Monday Night Football.[25] He was released on September 16, 2014.[26] He was re-signed by the Cardinals on September 19, 2014. On October 6, 2014, he became the starting punter after Dave Zastudil was placed on season-ending injured reserve.[27] Butler went on to lead the NFL in punts inside the 20 during the 2014 season.[28]
On October 4, 2016, Butler was released by the Cardinals.[29] He was re-signed on November 15, 2016, and released again on December 13, 2016.[30][31]
Butler runs 4th Down Consulting and hosts a pair of college football podcasts titled Punt & Pass Podcast and CampusLore Life. In March 2021, he was hired by Icon Source, a company helping college athletes receive student athlete compensation, as Executive Vice President.[34]