Draft:Seton Miracles

You can also browse Wikipedia:Featured articles and Wikipedia:Good articles to find examples of Wikipedia's best writing on topics similar to your proposed arti

Draft:Seton Miracles
  • Comment: For the record, I declined the speedy tag and removed it on procedural grounds (the hoax tag was applied to the draft talk page, not the draft). If such a tag were applied to the draft, I'd decline because IMHO this is a situation which deserves more eyes, not fewer. On one hand, a desire to right great wrongs (revealing this "miracle") is usually a flawed basis upon which build pagespace. On the other, we can see some serious sourcing already present. Using the best of such citation, I'd suggest User:Octavius1981 create an 1-2 sentence entry in the appropriate space on Weeping statues, whatever the outcome on this draft. Creating such an entry may well prove useful with culling connected material from the draft here as well. Finally, the self-created image of the old color photograph does not do the pagespace any favors. BusterD (talk) 20:35, 14 August 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment: It should be noted that we already have an article on weeping statues, and given that the claims made in relation to this one appear not to be materially different to the many others covered there, any discussion of these particular events would almost certainly be better covered there. AndyTheGrump (talk) 17:22, 14 August 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment: Future reviewers should be aware of this editors demeanor with other reviewers demonstrated here and here Sulfurboy (talk) 02:51, 14 August 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment: Rejected for a couple of reasons - first is the lack of neutral POV and encyclopedic tone. The current form of the article asserts that these are supernatural events which occurred, which fails the neutral POV test - it needs to be rewritten to describe what was reported, without taking a position on whether these were genuine miracles or not. In addition, some of the references checked do not actually link to what the references claim - the citation to the U.S. News & World Report actually links to a YouTube video for example. Other sources are too short to be of use establishing notability. Absurdum4242 (talk) 07:55, 8 August 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment: I won't call this outright a hoax, but I will say that to qualify for an encyclopaedia article, we need considerably better sources than hear-say and supposition. DoubleGrazing (talk) 13:37, 1 June 2026 (UTC)


Weeping Statue
The main weeping statue of Mary, at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church. The eyes are unusually lifelike.
The main weeping statue, at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Church in Lake Ridge, Virginia, from 1991-1993.

The Seton Miracles were unexplained, paranormal or supernatural phenomena that occurred in connection with Fr. James C. Bruse at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church in Lake Ridge, Virginia, from 1991 to 1993. They became national news, and a Catholic pilgrimage destination for people seeking to see the weeping statues and the priest's stigmata.

Background

Rev. James C. Bruse

Fr. James C. Bruse, was born Oct. 28, 1954, in Washington, D.C. He graduated from the then-college of Mary Washington in 1976, and entered formation for the Diocese of Arlington in 1979. After graduating from its Mount St. Mary’s Seminary in 1983, he was ordained a priest on May 12, 1984, by its then-bishop, John Keating.[1] He had once held three world records for marathon roller-coaster riding.[2]

Events

Claimed Miracles

Weeping Statues

Dozens[3] or Hundreds[4] of statues were witnessed to weep from their eyes, especially when placed into the presence of Fr. Bruse, usually a clear liquid, but occasionally a bloodlike liquid.[3][5][6] The statues were usually statues of the blessed Virgin Mary, or Jesus, but occasionally other saints' statues would cry.[7][8] Statues also wept at other parishes, in the priest's presence.[9][10][11] Many statues also changed colors.[12][7][4][13]

Stigmata

Fr. Bruse received the stigmata, which appeared as painful, red, dime-size dots on his wrists, feet, and side.[14][3] They would occasionally bleed.[7][15] Even when not visible they caused a "stabbing, jamming" pain in Fr. Bruse, which "No medicine will help - Advil, aspirin."[7] Bruse was reportedly examined by a doctor, and verifiedly examined by a Psychiatrist, who wrote a lengthy report, and "the priest came out of his lengthy interview with an excellent bill of health".[7]

Other Phenomena

There were also reports of the facial expressions of the statues changing, statues changing colour, rosaries changing colour, the fragrance of roses filling the Church, and many other supposedly supernatural occurrences.[4][16]

Media Frenzy

Local and national news outlets covered the story, including famous journalists A.B. Stoddard[6][17], Morris Jones at WTTG Fox5[18], and Ralph Wenge at CNN.[19] The Washington Post covered it repeatedly[20][7][21][22][10][23][24][25][26][27]; People Magazine[28][21] and The Straight Dope[29] covered it; and U.S. News & World Report made it its March 29th 1993 cover-story.[30][31][32] The diocese offered only a single press-conference, which took place on March 12th, 1992,[7] and in which no new information was given.[33]

Pilgrimage destination

The Washington Post described it as a "Lourdes-Like Pilgrimage."[34] Thousands of people came weekly to see the phenomena,[35][25][36][37] from all over the nation[22], and world.[38][39] Police officers were regularly needed to direct traffic[35], as even tour-busses tried to fit into the residential neighborhood.[36][27][25] Fr. Bruse would often bless statues and other items, brought by curiosity-seeking pilgrims.[7][40][34]

Aftermath

The Diocese of Arlington never made any decision as to the events' authenticity. However, concerned at the circus-like atmosphere, Bishop Keating eventually suppressed the events, notwithstanding that the statues went on crying, for some time.[37] Fr. Bruse and the Parish's lives returned to normal, and the reputation of the events was discarded, as if trivial or inconsequential. In 1995 he was transferred to a different parish.[25][26] Fr. Bruse went on to a long and successful career, in the Diocese of Arlington, at numerous other parishes.[1][41]

Explanation

Reputed Miraculous Character

Skeptics sometimes described the events as mere paranormal "phenomena"[31][20][42][43], but news stories vacilated over the obvious question of whether they were more, were actual "supernatural" "miracles,"[44] as believers frequently claimed.[45][46] Paradoxical headlines appeared, such as,

  • For Many, a Firm Belief in Miracles; Those Stirred by Pr. William Phenomena...[22]
  • ...Is It Faith or a Hoax?[7]
  • Treading Softly Into the Matter Of Miracles; Purported Phenomena...[24]
  • Real or Not, the Tears Whet Their Faith[23]

Consequently, the name "Seton Miracles" has become the common name for the event.[47][48][49] Rarely, an alternate name, "Our Lady of the Potomac," is used.[50]

Antonin Scalia

Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia weighed in on the question of their miraculousness, in a speech to the Thomas More Society, entitled "Not to the Wise: The Christian as Cretin:"

"Anyway, The Washington Post sent out a team of reporters, who produced a strange story about the phenomenon of these weeping statues: they obviously did not want to appear so unsophisticated as to believe this nonsense, but neither could they find any explanation for it. As far as they could tell, the young priest was not a charlatan and puddles of water did indeed appear at the feet of the statues. . . . But the thought occurred to me: Why wasn't that church absolutely packed with non-believers, seeking to determine whether there might be something to this Catholic religion? Or why weren't The Washington Post reporters enthusiastic converts? Well, of course, the wisdom of the world does not operate that way: The wise do not investigate such silliness—and even if the miracle were performed under their nose, they would disbelieve. You may recall the parable of Dives, the rich man, and Lazarus the beggar . . . [in which] Abraham rejoins, "If they hear not Moses and prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one [miraculously] rose from the dead."[51]

Unknown Causes

Fr. Bruse himself professed more ignorance than knowledge of the explanation or reasons behind the phenomena, acknowledging that "I would be just as cynical. I would be questioning this."[3] Once he said, "I think what's happening is, Christ is saying, `Hey, I'm here. This is real.'"[7] Another time he elaborated,

"Look," he says, "I would never believe this kind of thing, normally. I've heard stuff like this. Maybe it's plaster sweating, maybe it's hysterical reaction on the part of the observers. For skeptics, I know how they feel. That's what I'm trying to say. It's not me. It's Christ. It's Christ working through me. It's all His work. It's Mary's work. Mary is a big factor. She's interceding here somehow."[7]

The fact that no purportedly supernatural message accompanied the phenomena, to explain them, figured into Bishop Keating's decision to ignore,[37] and ultimately suppress the event.[52][27]

References

  1. ^ a b "Who's your new pastor?". The Arlington Catholic Herald. Catholic Diocese of Arlington. 13 June 2012. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  2. ^ Schneider, Greg (13 March 1992). "Stigmata priest once was Champ of the Roller Coasters". The Roanoke Times. p. B3. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  3. ^ a b c d "Miracles reported at Virginia church". United Press International (UPI) Archives. 9 March 1992. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  4. ^ a b c Carney, James L. "The Seton Miracles". The Marian Foundation. Retrieved 31 May 2026. ...hundreds of statues of the Blessed Virgin Mary were reported weeping before thousands of astonished witnesses. Some statues added or rotated colors. Numerous rosaries changed color. Some people reported seeing the "miracle of the sun" while others noticed a powerful scent of roses when there were no flowers or other reasons for such a fragrance.
  5. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. The tears looked like blood.
  6. ^ a b Stoddard, A.B. (16 January 1994). "Writer bears witness to wonders". Potomac News. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Hendrickson, Paul (13 March 1992). "The Mystery of The Weeping Statues; Father Jim's Plaster Blessed Virgin Cries. His Wrists Bleed. Is It Faith or a Hoax?". Washington Post. Retrieved 12 August 2026.
  8. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
  9. ^ "2nd Church Reports Weeping Statue". The Roanoke Times. 19 March 1992. p. B2. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  10. ^ a b Thomas-Lester, Avis (30 March 1992). "More Icons said to Weep in Va. Priest's Presence". The Washington Post. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  11. ^ "Weeping Icons are Seen Again". The Roanoke Times. The Washington Post. 31 March 1992. p. B3. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  12. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 20:52. Retrieved 31 May 2026. Event occurs again, at 25:38
  13. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 14:34. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  14. ^ "A Miraculous Time for Talk of Miracles". Virginian-Pilot. 4 April 1992. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  15. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 16:09. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  16. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. Before long, parishioners began whispering of other inexplicable events -- spinning suns, rays of vibrant colors, statues and rosaries changing colors and amazing healings.
  17. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 13:11. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  18. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 2:12. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  19. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 2:55. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  20. ^ a b Thomas, Pierre (8 March 1992). "Phenomena Pack Va. Church". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
  21. ^ a b Pressley, Sue Anne; Masters, Brooke A. (16 March 1992). "In Northern Virginia, a Lourdes-Like Pilgrimage; As Visitors Swarm to Site of Weeping Statues, Lake Ridge Church Endures Growing Pains". The Washington Post. p. D3. Retrieved 12 August 2026. . . . reporters with the Star tabloid and People magazine clamored in vain for an interview with the Rev. James Bruse . . .
  22. ^ a b c Stepp, Laura Sessions (22 March 1992). "For Many, a Firm Belief in Miracles; Those Stirred by Pr. William Phenomena Have Nationwide Company". The Washington Post. Retrieved 11 August 2026. Those Stirred by Pr. William Phenomena Have Nationwide Company
  23. ^ a b Twomey, Steve (2 April 1992). "Real or Not, the Tears Whet Their Faith". The Washington Post. Retrieved 13 August 2026.
  24. ^ a b Pressley, Sue Anne; Thomas-Lester, Avis (5 April 1992). "Treading Softly Into the Matter Of Miracles; Purported Phenomena Are Age-Old Dilemma for Church". The Washington Post. Retrieved 13 August 2026.
  25. ^ a b c d "Priest whose Claims Brought Thousands to See Crying Statues is Leaving Pr. William Church". The Washington Post. 31 May 1995. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  26. ^ a b Murphy, Caryle (17 August 1997). "Quieter Life for Priest". The Washington Post. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  27. ^ a b c Boorstein, Michelle (6 April 2012). "'The Seton Miracles': Pr. William church weeping statue reports continue to spark interest — but no official inquiry". WashingtonPost.com. Retrieved 12 August 2026.
  28. ^ Neill, Michael A. (April 27, 1992). "In the Virginia suburb of Lake Ridge, a local Catholic priest, Father James Bruse, has stirred religious fervor with his reports of stigmata and "weeping" statues". People Magazine. Vol. 37, no. 16. pp. 46–49. Retrieved 11 August 2026.
  29. ^ Adams, Cecil (19 February 1998). "The Straight Dope". The Chicago Reader. Retrieved 11 August 2026.
  30. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
  31. ^ a b Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. Hathitrust. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. Note: This source is currently protected by copyright, so only text-searches are permitted.
  32. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 1:57. Retrieved 1 June 2026. Citation included only to show a visual image of the magazine cover.
  33. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 24:42. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  34. ^ a b Pressley, Sue Anne; Masters, Brooke A. (16 March 1992). "In Northern Virginia, a Lourdes-Like Pilgrimage; As Visitors Swarm to Site of Weeping Statues, Lake Ridge Church Endures Growing Pains". The Washington Post. p. D3. Retrieved 12 August 2026.
  35. ^ a b Pressley, Sue Anne; Masters, Brooke A. (16 March 1992). "In Northern Virginia, a Lourdes-Like Pilgrimage; As Visitors Swarm to Site of Weeping Statues, Lake Ridge Church Endures Growing Pains". The Washington Post. p. D3. Retrieved 12 August 2026. At the entrance to the church parking lot, two Prince William County police officers stayed busy directing the hundreds of arriving and departing cars, and estimated that at least 3,000 people tried yesterday to attend the church
  36. ^ a b Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. But if he [the bishop] discourages the faithful from believing, he risks driving away the thousands whom the miracles have drawn to mass. . . . Even so, 3,000 people mobbed the church the following Sunday, spilling out the doors, trampling the daffodils and jamming the streets so badly that two county police officers were called in to direct traffic.
  37. ^ a b c Ryan, Stephen (19 December 2010). "Tears of the Virgin Mary Meet the Smoke of Satan". BishopAccountability.org. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  38. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. Their doubts in no way affected the faithful, who now arrived daily from as far away as Japan.
  39. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 5:45. Retrieved 31 May 2026.
  40. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 37:28. Retrieved 31 May 2026. See also 5:45, 26:30.
  41. ^ "Directory of Directors, Coordinators, & Assistants: Guide to Directors & Staff of Religious Education For Program Year 2025 – 2026" (PDF). Diocese of Arlington. p. 3. Retrieved 1 June 2026. "Rev. James Bruse" is listed as a "Pastor/DRE" at "Our Lady of the Blue Ridge" in Madison, Va.
  42. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. At the request of U.S. News, a Virginia medical laboratory recently tested a sample of one statue's 'tears' and found no evidence of the salt and proteins present in human tears. Beyond that, there is no objective physical documentation -- at least none made public -- to prove or disprove the phenomena.
  43. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 5:12. Retrieved 31 May 2026. See also 37:28.
  44. ^ Rosellini, Lynn (29 March 1993). "The Case of the Weeping Madonna". U.S. News & World Report. Vol. 114, no. 12. pp. Cover–page, 46–55. Retrieved 2 June 2026. Long before the word 'miracle,' . . . 'Is it a miracle? Is it a miracle? . . . But a few months later, a California astrophysicist named Shawn Carlson, who had heard about the 'miracles' of Lake Ridge and other American towns, reproduced a crying statue on the CBS-TV show '48 Hours.'
  45. ^ Carney, James L. (2012). The Seton Miracles - Eyewitness Testimony - miracles at St Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Lake Ridge VA (DVD Video). Youtube. The Marian Foundation. Event occurs at 5:07. Retrieved 31 May 2026. Event occurs again, at 2:09, 2:16, 17:37.
  46. ^ Ryan, Stephen (19 December 2010). "Tears of the Virgin Mary Meet the Smoke of Satan". BishopAccountability.org. Retrieved 31 May 2026. Many eye-witnesses to the events and those who have investigated the incident argue that never in the entire history of the Catholic Church, has there been a greater manifestation of the supernatural or momentous occurrence of weeping statues and other physical signs of God's presence through the Blessed Virgin Mary than what took place on the outskirts of Washington, D.C. in 1991 – 1993
  47. ^ Boorstein, Michelle (6 April 2012). "'The Seton Miracles': Pr. William church weeping statue reports continue to spark interest — but no official inquiry". WashingtonPost.com. Retrieved 12 August 2026. [Note that this story is sometimes listed on the 9th instead of 6th April 2012.] A small group in Northern Virginia and around the country has held fast to what they call The Seton Miracles and some have recently been pushing the diocese http:// www. thepetitionsite. com /1/diocese-of-arlington---investigate-the-seton-miracles/ to open an investigation [Sic: Article text contains that inline link].
  48. ^ Carney, James L. "The Seton Miracles". The Marian Foundation. Retrieved 31 May 2026. Welcome to The Marian Foundation: The Seton Miracles.
  49. ^ Thavis, John (2015). The Vatican Prophecies (1st ed.). Viking. ISBN 978-0525426899. Retrieved 11 August 2026. The events, known as the Seton Miracles . . .
  50. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  51. ^ Scalia, Antonin (2017). Scalia, Christopher J. (ed.). Scalia Speaks: Reflections on Law, Faith, and Life Well Lived (1st ed.). Forum Books. p. 113. ISBN 978-0525573326. Retrieved 11 August 2026.
  52. ^ Ryan, Steven (3 June 2025). Our Lady of the Potomac - “The Greatest Case of Weeping Statues in the History of the World” (DVD Video). Youtube. Mystic Post TV. Event occurs at 23:24. Retrieved 1 June 2026. Event occurs again at 27:24, and 28:51.

Content Disclaimer

Informasi ini disarikan dari Wikipedia dan disajikan kembali untuk tujuan edukasi. Konten tersedia di bawah lisensi CC BY-SA 3.0. Kami tidak bertanggung jawab atas ketidakakuratan data yang bersumber dari kontribusi publik tersebut.

  1. The information displayed on this website is sourced in part or in whole from Wikipedia and has been adapted for the purpose of restating it. We strive to provide accurate and relevant information, however:
  2. There is no guarantee of absolute accuracy. Wikipedia is an open, collaborative project that can be edited by anyone, so information is subject to change.
  3. It is not intended to constitute professional advice. The content displayed is for informational and educational purposes only. For important decisions (e.g., medical, legal, or financial), please consult a professional.
  4. Content copyright. Wikipedia is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License (CC BY-SA). This means that content may be reused with appropriate attribution and shared under a similar license.
  5. Responsible use. Any risk arising from the use of information from this website is entirely the responsibility of the user.