David S. Tatel

David S. Tatel
Judge Tatel during a naturalization ceremony at the National Archives in 2017
Senior Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
In office
May 16, 2022 – January 16, 2024
Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
In office
October 7, 1994 – May 16, 2022
Appointed byBill Clinton
Preceded byRuth Bader Ginsburg
Succeeded byJ. Michelle Childs
Personal details
Born
David Stephen Tatel

(1942-03-16) March 16, 1942 (age 82)
Washington, D.C., U.S.
EducationUniversity of Michigan (BA)
University of Chicago (JD)

David Stephen Tatel (born March 16, 1942) is an American lawyer who served as a United States circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

Education and career

Tatel received his Bachelor of Arts from the University of Michigan in 1963. He graduated from the University of Chicago Law School in 1966 with a Juris Doctor.[1]

After graduating from law school, he served as an instructor at the University of Michigan Law School before joining Sidley Austin in Chicago. He served as founding director of the Chicago Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, Director of the National Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, and Director of the Office for Civil Rights of the United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare during the Carter Administration.

In 1979, Tatel joined the law firm Hogan & Hartson (now Hogan Lovells), where he founded and headed the firm's education practice until his appointment to the D.C. Circuit.[2] While on sabbatical from Hogan & Hartson, Tatel spent a year as a lecturer at Stanford Law School. He also previously served as Acting General Counsel for the Legal Services Corporation.[3]

Federal judicial service

Tatel was nominated by President Bill Clinton on June 20, 1994, to a seat on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit vacated by Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg. He was confirmed by the United States Senate on October 6, 1994, by a voice vote, and received commission on October 7, 1994.[4] He announced his intent to assume senior status upon confirmation of a successor on February 12, 2021.[5] Tatel assumed senior status on May 16, 2022.[4] He announced his plans to retire from the bench in September 2023 to return to a law firm where he worked before he became a federal judge.[6][7] He retired from judicial service on January 16, 2024.[4]

Notable rulings

Environment

In 1999, Tatel dissented in American Trucking v. United States EPA, a case about the EPA's power to set emission standards under the Clean Air Act. Tatel rejected the majority's invocation of the "nondelegation doctrine," arguing that the agency's actions were permissible.[8] In a unanimous opinion written by Justice Antonin Scalia, the Supreme Court eventually reversed the majority's opinion, liberally adopting the reasoning of Tatel's dissent.[9]

In 2005, Tatel was assigned to Massachusetts v. EPA, a case that centered on whether the Clean Air Act allowed the EPA to regulate greenhouse gases. In a dissenting opinion, Tatel sided with the EPA, finding that Congress had clearly given the agency authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions.[10] The Supreme Court again agreed with Tatel, vacating the D.C. Circuit's opinion in a 5-4 decision.[11]

In April 2020, Tatel wrote for the unanimous panel when it invalidated as arbitrary and capricious a directive by EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt attempting to prohibit scientists who had received EPA research grants from serving on its advisory panels.[12][13]

Voting Rights

In 2008, Tatel authored the majority opinion in Northwest Austin Mun. Util. Dist. One v. Mukasey, which held that Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act is constitutional.[14] Less than four years later, Tatel also wrote the majority opinion in Shelby County v. Holder, again upholding the constitutionality of Section 5 of the Voting Rights. In a landmark voting rights decision, the Supreme Court eventually reversed his opinion by a 5-4 vote.[15]

Privilege

Tatel dissented in two important attorney-client privilege cases. In 1997, he wrote the dissenting opinion in Swidler & Berlin v. United States, explaining that the notes from conversations between Vincent Foster and his attorney were protected by the attorney-client privilege even after Foster’s death. The Supreme Court, in a 6-3 ruling, later sided with Tatel and ruled to protect the notes.[16] The following year, Tatel concurred in part and dissented in part in In Re: Bruce Lindsey, a case involving whether Special Counsel Ken Starr could seek grand jury testimony about Monica Lewinsky from deputy White House counsel Bruce Lindsey. Tatel argued that presidents should enjoy attorney-client privilege in their communications with White House Counsel.[17]

First Amendment

In 2005, Tatel authored a concurring opinion in In Re: Grand Jury Subpoena, Judith Miller, a case about whether the First Amendment allows reporters to refuse to disclose their sources to a grand jury. Tatel agreed with the majority that the First Amendment did not protect Judith Miller in the case, but he wrote separately to argue that federal courts should recognize a "reporter's privilege."[18]

In 2020, Tatel authored the unanimous opinion in Karem v. Trump, which upheld a judge's order restoring a White House press pass to a reporter who got into an argument with one of President Donald Trump's supporters.[19][20]

Guantanamo Bay

Tatel heard several appeals from prisoners held in the Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp. In 2017, Tatel, along with Judges Rogers and Griffith, wrote a per curiam opinion vacating a decision of a military judge against Khalid Sheikh Mohammad because of biased statements made by the judge against the defendant.[21] In 2019, Tatel also wrote a majority opinion vacating decisions against Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, finding that the military judge wrongly hid his pursuit of a job with the government while presiding over al-Nashiri's case.[22] Tatel dissented in a 2011 case involving Adnan Farhad Abd Al Latif, Al Latif v. Obama. Tatel would have upheld a district court decision ordering Al Latif's release under Boumediene v. Bush.[23]

Disability

In 2019, Tatel authored the majority opinion in D.L. v. District of Columbia, a class action lawsuit filed by the parents of D.C. children. Tatel found that the District violated the "Child Find" requirement of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act by failing to provide adequate special education services to D.C. children.[24][25]

Other Issues

In June 2017, Tatel found the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act did not prevent the survivors of a Holocaust victim from suing to recover art stolen by Nazi plunderers, over the partial dissent of Senior Judge A. Raymond Randolph.[26][27]

In October 2019, Tatel filed the majority opinion in Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP, finding that the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Oversight and Reform had the authority to compel Mazars, via subpoena, to produce documents relating to the personal financial information of President Donald Trump, including several years' worth of income tax returns.[28] That decision was vacated and remanded, 7–2, by the Supreme Court in an opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts on July 9, 2020.[29]

Personal life

Tatel serves as co-chair of the National Academy of Sciences' Committee on Science, Technology, and Law. He is a member of the American Philosophical Society[30] and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. He serves on the Trustee Board of the Foundation Fighting Blindness. He chaired the Board of The Spencer Foundation from 1990 to 1997 and the Board of The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching from 2005 to 2009.

Tatel and his wife, Edie, have four children, eight grandchildren, and one great-grandchild.[31]

Tatel has been blind since the 1970s due to retinitis pigmentosa.[32] His guide dog, Vixen, is a German Shepherd.[33]

Recognition

In 2006, Tatel received an Alumni Medal from the University of Chicago.[34] He holds honorary degrees from Macalaster College (2004) and Georgetown University (2010).[35][36] In 2019, the Chicago Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights granted its Legal Champion Award to Tatel.[37] A year later, he was awarded the 2020 Henry Allen Moe Prize from the American Philosophical Society.[38] Tatel also received the American Inns of Court Professionalism Award in 2023 and Legal Aid DC's Servant of Justice Award in 2024.[39][40]

Selected publications and speeches

  • Tatel, David S. (September 13, 1997). Alexander F. Morrison Lecture. Annual Meeting of the California State Bar, San Diego, CA
  • Tatel, David S. (June 25, 2002). Remarks of David S. Tatel on the Occasion of the Spencer Foundation's 30th Anniversary Dinner. Chicago, IL
  • Tatel, David S. (October 16, 2003). Remarks on the Occasion of the Portrait Hanging Ceremony for the Honorable Patricia Wald. Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (January 19, 2004). Macalester College Graduation Ceremony Speech. St. Paul, MN
  • Tatel, David S., "Madison Lecture: Judicial Methodology, Southern School Desegregation, and the Rule of Law, 79 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 1071 (2004).
  • Tatel, David S. (October 27, 2006). “Remarks on the Occasion of the Portrait Hanging Ceremony for the Honorable Stephen F. Williams”. Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (November 15, 2008). Remarks of David S. Tatel. The American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA
  • Tatel, David S. (January 17, 2009). Litigation and Integration Then and Now. Delivered at Passing the Torch: the Past, Present, and Future of Interdistrict School Desegregation, Harvard Law School, Cambridge, MA
  • Tatel, David S. (December 8, 2009). Remarks on the Occasion of the Portrait Hanging Ceremony for the Honorable James Robertson. Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (May 6, 2010). "Legacy of Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens". CSPAN, Washington, D.C
  • Tatel, David S. (April 23, 2012). Habeas Corpus: Remarks of Judge David S. Tatel. Cosmos Club, Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (April 5, 2013). Remarks on the Occasion of the Portrait Hanging Ceremony for the Honorable David B. Sentelle. Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (November 15, 2013). Remarks of David S. Tatel. The American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA
  • Tatel, David S. (April 28, 2018). Separation of Powers and Statutory Interpretation: A Battle Hidden in Plain Sight. The American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, PA
  • Tatel, David S. and Ruther Bader Ginsburg. (October 24, 2018). Tenth Annual Judge Thomas A. Flannery Lecture, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Flannery Lecture Series, Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (September 16, 2022). Expression of Gratitude on the Occasion of the Portrait Hanging Ceremony for the Honorable David S. Tatel. Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (March 18, 2022). "Life, Law, and Vision Loss with Judge Tatel". Hadley Helps.
  • Liptak, Adam (May 27, 2024). "Lessons from Judge David Tatel's Guide Dog on Blindness and Vision". New York Times.
  • Marimow, Ann E. (June 7, 2024). "Retired judge David Tatel issues a stark warning about the Supreme Court." The Washington Post.
  • Tatel, David S. (June 11, 2024). Vision: A Memoir of Blindness and Justice. Little, Brown and Company.
  • Tatel, David S. (June 11, 2024). "David S. Tatel Book Talk with Jane Mayer". Politics and Prose, Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (June 11, 2024). "Judge David Tatel on Becoming the Blind Role Model he Never Had." National Public Radio.
  • Tatel, David S. (June 14, 2024). "Retired offers stark warning about U.S. Supreme Court". CNN, The Lead with Jake Tapper.
  • Tatel, David S. (June 19, 2024). "Booknotes + Podcast - Judge David Tatel, 'Vision'". CSPAN, Washington, D.C.
  • Tatel, David S. (July 3, 2024). "A Former Federal Judge Fears for Democracy". Fresh Air, NPR.

See also

References

  1. ^ Pierre-Canel, Christian (29 November 2022). "A Student of Adversity". Retrieved 29 August 2023.
  2. ^ "U.S. Court of Appeals - D.C. Circuit - David S. Tatel". www.cadc.uscourts.gov. Retrieved 2022-05-16.
  3. ^ Johnson, Earl Jr. (2014). To Establish Justice for All: The Past and Future of Civil Legal Aid in the United States. Santa Barbara: Praeger. p. 456. ISBN 978-0-313-35706-0.
  4. ^ a b c David S. Tatel at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges, a publication of the Federal Judicial Center.
  5. ^ "DC Circuit Judge David Tatel to Take Senior Status, Handing Biden 2nd Vacancy". law.com. Retrieved 2022-01-09.
  6. ^ Goudsward, Andrew (June 28, 2023). "Retiring US appeals court judge returns to law firm Hogan Lovells". Reuters. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
  7. ^ "Ex-D.C. Circuit Judge David Tatel to Return to Hogan Lovells". Bloomberg Law. June 28, 2023. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
  8. ^ "Opinion - American Truck v. United States EPA". Casetext.
  9. ^ "Whitman v. American trucking Associations, Inc., 531 U.S. 457 (2001)". Justia U.S. Supreme Court.
  10. ^ "Opinion - Mass. v. E.P.A." Casetext.
  11. ^ "Massachusetts v. Environmental Protection Agency". Oyez.
  12. ^ Note, Recent Case: D.C. Circuit Finds EPA Directive Invalid, 134 Harv. L. Rev. 2283 (2021).
  13. ^ Physicians for Social Responsibility v. Wheeler, 956 F.3d 634 (D.C. Cir. 2020).
  14. ^ "Opinion" (PDF). MALDEF.
  15. ^ "Opinion - Shelby County v. Holder" (PDF). United States Court of Appeal for the District of Columbia Circuit.
  16. ^ "Appeals Court Ruling on Foster Notes". Washington Post.
  17. ^ "In Re: Bruce Lindsey, et al, No. 98-3060 (D.C. Cir. 1998)". Justia.
  18. ^ "Opinion - In re Grand Jury Subpoena, Judith Miller". Casetext.
  19. ^ "Opinion - Karem v. Trump" (PDF). United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.
  20. ^ Gerstein, Josh. "Appeals court upholds order to restore reporter's White House press pass". Politico. Retrieved 4 June 2024.
  21. ^ "In Re: Khalid Shaikh Mohammad" (PDF). United States Court of Appeals FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT.
  22. ^ Rosenberg, Carol (17 April 2019). "Court Rejects 2 Years of Judge's Decisions in Cole Tribunal". The New York Times.
  23. ^ "Opinion - Al Latif v. Obama". Casetext.
  24. ^ "Opinion - D.L. v. District of Columbia". Justia.
  25. ^ "D.L. v. District of Columbia: How Does this Ruling Impact Me and My Child?". Advocates for Justice and Education, Inc. 10 October 2019. Retrieved 4 June 2024.
  26. ^ Note, Recent Case: D.C. Circuit Interprets Expropriation Exception to Allow Genocide Victims to Sue Their Own Government, 131 Harv. L. Rev. 650 (2017).
  27. ^ de Csepel v. Republic of Hungary, 859 F.3d 1094 (D.C. Cir. 2017).
  28. ^ "Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP, No. 19-5142 (D.C. Cir. 2019)". Justia Law. Retrieved 2019-10-11.
  29. ^ Trump v. Mazars appeal, U.S. Supreme Court (decided July 9, 2020, No. 19-715), casetext.com; accessed July 19, 2020.
  30. ^ "APS Member History". search.amphilsoc.org. Retrieved 2021-05-17.
  31. ^ "U.S. Court of Appeals - D.C. Circuit - David S. Tatel". www.cadc.uscourts.gov. Retrieved 2022-02-09.
  32. ^ Slavin, Barbara (July 28, 1994). "A Judge of Character". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2014-11-27.
  33. ^ Marimow, Ann E. (8 July 2021). "Judge David Tatel's lack of eyesight never defined him, but his blindness is woven into the culture of the influential appeals court in D.C." The Washington Post. Retrieved 11 May 2022.
  34. ^ "Past Recipients: Alumni Awards". UChicago Alumni & Friends. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  35. ^ "Honorary Degree Recipients" (PDF). Macalaster College. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  36. ^ "Honorary Degree Recipients". Georgetown University. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  37. ^ Krohnke, Duane (6 November 2019). "David Tatel, David Tatel, '66 Receives Legal Champion Award". University of Chicago Law School. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  38. ^ "2020 Henry Allen Moe Prize". American Philosophical Society. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  39. ^ "Judge David S. Tatel 2023 American Inns of Court Professionalism Award for the DC Circuit". American Inns of Court. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
  40. ^ Pergament, Robert (12 January 2024). "Legal Aid DC to Honor Civil Rights Leaders Debo P. Adegbile & Judge David S. Tatel with 2024 Servant of Justice Awards". Legal Aid DC. Retrieved 29 May 2024.
Legal offices
Preceded by Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
1994–2022 		Succeeded by