Smith made his league debut for the club on July 25, 2020, coming on as a late substitute for Beni Redžić in a 2–1 home victory over Forward Madison.[3]
Smith was loaned to USL Championship side Birmingham Legion on March 10, 2023.[5] Smith was recalled from his loan by Dallas on July 4, 2023.[6] Smith was released by Dallas following the 2023 season.[7]
On March 29, 2024, Smith mutually agreed to part ways with New England Revolution II. That same day, it was announced that he signed a contract with Rhode Island FC during their debut season in the USL Championship. He was released by Rhode Island following the 2024 season.[9]