During the early 1950s, Vest decided to become a pro wrestler and made his debut in 1951 in Texas. He wrestled his first match as Chief Vest[3] against Billy Weidner at an Amarillohouse show in April 1951. This match was a time limit draw. Soon after that, he moved to the St. Louis territory of the NWA and had a series of matches with the St. Louis Wrestling Club in November 1951. Within a year, Vest was headlining shows at Brock Arena in the NWA's Toronto wrestling territory.[9][10][11] He also began appearing for Stampede Wrestling, and was Bret Hart's first favorite wrestler, according to Bret himself.[12]
During this same time Vest also won his first singles championship in January 1957 when he defeated Dr Jerry Graham for the NWA Southern Heavyweight Championship.[17] He lost the title a week later back to Graham.[18][19] In the meantime, McIntyre and Chief went on to hold the championship for two months until they dropped it to Mark Lewin and Don Lewin in February.[20][21] After this Chief had a series of matches with Jerry Graham and subsequently went back to the Texas territory in the World Class Wrestling Association operated by Southwest Sports. There he went on to form a Tag Team with Chief Little Eagle.[6] Their gimmick was of Cherokee chiefs. They went on to win the NWA Texas TagTeam Championship from the team of Andre Bollet & Frank Valois on April 7, 1959, at a show in Dallas, Texas. They lost the title a week later to Ben And Mike Sharpe.[22] During this period the team of Big Heart and Little Eagle feuded with the likes of Golden Grahams (Jerry and Eddie), the Tolos Brothers (Chris Tolos and John Tolos) and Johnny Valentine. In 1960 he teamed up with Johnny Valentine to defend the WWWF United States Tag-Team Championship when Johhny's partner Buddy Rogers left WWWF.[23] They subsequently lost the titles to the Fabulous Kangaroos.[24] During this time Chief Big Heart wrestled extensively for Capital Wrestling Corporation, NWA's Northeast territory and the precursor to WWWF and subsequently WWF/E. He faced the team of Bill Watts and Bill Miller while teaming up with the then WWE championBruno Sammartino which ended in a draw.
After this, he continued to feud with his old rival Jerry Graham and unsuccessfully challenged him and Eddie Graham for the WWWF United States Tag Team Championship along with first Chief Little Eagle and then Haystacks Calhoun. He formed a team with Red Bastien to challenge the champions Jerry Graham and Johnny Valentine but was again unsuccessful in winning the title. After failing to beat Jerry for the championship he set his eyes on Georgia and left the northeast territory in 1963.
He returned to Georgia Championship Wrestling in 1963 along with Little Eagle, where he went on to win the NWA World Tag Team Championship (Georgia version) when they defeated Tarzan Tyler and Lenny Montana for the titles at Municipal Auditorium in a November house show.[25][26] They held the championship for about a month, until January 1964. The team of Chief and Eagle lost the titles under unknown circumstances, after which the titles were next seen with The Von Brauners. After this, he returned to the WWWF. Then later for NWA Big-time Wrestling and NWA Tri-State. He also made a new tag team with another Native American gimmick wrestler, Chief Kit Fox.[7][27] He won the NWA Tri-state Tagteam Championship along with Kit Fox by defeating the team of Karl Von Stroheim & Treach Phillips in January 1969.[28] They dropped the titles back to them in February. Around this time, he and Kit fox were involved in a car accident which ultimately ended both their careers.[7]
^ abcLawson, Russell M., ed. (2013). "American Indian Athletes: Individual Contribution in the Face of Challenges". Encyclopedia of American Indian Issues Today. Vol. 2. ABC-CLIO. p. 413.
^Beneficiary Identification Records Locator Subsystem (BIRLS) Death File (Report). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. 1993.
^"Weaver Keeps Mat Crown in Contested Bout". Atlanta Constitution. December 8, 1956. p. 9. Chief Big Heart and Red McIntyre defeated Ike Eakins and Fred Atkins in a 21-minute match for the international tag team championship.
^"Wrestlers Kick Off Brigade Days". The Hope Standard. August 27, 1975. p. 3. There will be a six-man tag team elimination match between Seigfried Steinke, Professor Lewis, 260-pound Atlanta rebel, Masa Saito 245-pound Japanese hatchetman against Tiger Jeet Singh, 250-pound East Indian star, Dennis Stamp, and Chief Big Heart, 265-pound Osage veteran. The winner is determined when all members of an opposing team have been eliminated by being pinned, disqualified, given up, counted out of the ring or thrown out over the top of the ropes.
^Johnson, Weldon T. and Jim Wilson. Chokehold: Pro Wrestling's Real Mayhem Outside the Ring. Philadelphia: Xlibris Corporation, 2003. (pg. 513) ISBN1-4010-7217-8
^"News From Ringside". Wrestling Training Illustrated. Springfield Gardens, New York: Dan Lurie Publications. Winter 1982. p. 61. Rip Hawk back in action after a stint as a bouncer in Vegas for a while. Chief Big Heart continues to work in that position in Vegas and is also a referee when the boys come to town once a month