On January 18, 2018, Lindley's Homegrown rights were traded from Chicago Fire to Orlando City as Lindley signed a four-year deal with the Central Florida club.[5] He made his professional debut in the season opener, a 1–1 draw at home to DC United. After starting three of the first four games of the season, Lindley failed to make another Major League Soccer (MLS) appearance in 2018 and only made one US Open Cup appearance.
St Louis FC (Loan, 2018)
On May 24, 2018, he was loaned to Saint Louis FC and made one start before returning.[6]
Memphis 901 FC (Loan, 2019)
On April 12, 2019, he was loaned to USL Championship team Memphis 901 FC and made 26 appearances in all competitions. On November 21, 2019, it was announced Lindley had his contract option for the 2020 season declined by Orlando as part of the end-of-season roster decisions.[7]
Indy Eleven (2020)
Lindley joined USL Championship side Indy Eleven on February 18, 2020.[8] Over the course of the shortened 2020 USL Championship season, Lindley made 12 total appearances, 9 of which were starts, for the club. Lindley made his first appearance for the club in a 2–1 home victory over Sporting Kansas City II on July 18, 2020.[9]
San Antonio FC (2021)
After a season with USL Championship side Indy Eleven in 2020, it was announced Lindley would sign with San Antonio FC ahead of the 2021 USL Championship season.[10] Lindley played the majority of games for San Antonio that season, making 31 total league appearances including 23 starts.[11]
Colorado Springs Switchbacks (2022)
On December 9, 2021, it was announced that Lindley would join USL Championship side Colorado Springs Switchbacks ahead of their 2022 season.[12] Lindley played 34 games for Colorado Springs, scoring 2 goals as he assisted the team to the Western Conference final in the USL Championship Playoffs, where they lost 2–0 to San Antonio, Lindley's former club.[13] San Antonio would go on to win the Playoffs by defeating Louisville City 3–1 in the final.[14] Lindley was named to the USL Championship All-League team at the end of the 2022 season.[15]
Return to Indy Eleven (2023 – present)
On December 1, 2022, Lindley made the move back to his former club Indy Eleven ahead of the 2023 season.[16] Lindley made 36 total appearances in his return season to Indianapolis, including 33 USL Championship appearances, two US Open Cup appearances, and playing all 90 minutes of Indy Eleven's 5–0 loss to Charleston Battery in the 2023 USL Championship Playoffs.[17]
Indy Eleven announced that Lindley would remain with the team for the 2024 season on November 17, 2023.[18] He ended the season with 32 total league and cup appearances for the team, helping the Eleven reach the semifinals of the U.S. Open Cup for the first time in the club's history, defeating MLS side Atlanta United FC in the process.[19] Indy Eleven announced on November 20, 2024 that Lindley would remain with the club for a third consecutive season.[20]
International career
Lindley has represented the United States internationally at various youth levels.
^"Cam Lindley Bio". goheels.com. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Athletics. Archived from the original on February 25, 2018. Retrieved February 25, 2018.