After leaving Grove City, Gibson worked for three years as a teacher and coach in Pennsylvania. During this time, he also played professional football for the Canton Bulldogs and Reogers Jewelers teams.[2]
Gibson also played professional football in the National Football League (NFL) for the New York Giants, principally at the guard position, for five seasons from 1930 to 1934, including the 1934 team that won the NFL championship. He appeared in 67 NFL games for the Giants, 45 of them as a starter.[3] He was selected as an All-NFL player in 1931 and 1934.[1] He was remembered for his "terrific ability to block punts", having blocked as many as two or three a game.[2]
Gibson was a lifelong resident of Stark County, Ohio. After his football career ended, he worked for 26 years for the Republic Steel Corp., including 16 years as superintendent of the steel-conditioning department. He died from a heart attack in 1960 at age 59. He had recently been released from the hospital and was found dead in his bed at his home in North Canton, Ohio.[2]