He was nicknamed Baja, which was also his kit name in one season,[2] as well as Blaggy.
Serbian White Eagles
Tamindžić played in abroad in the National Soccer League in 1973 with the Serbian White Eagles where in his debut season was named the league's top goalkeeper.[4] He returned to the Serbs the following season where once more he was named the top goalkeeper.[5] Throughout the regular season, he helped the White Eagles win the regular season title.[5] He also helped the club secure the Canadian Open Cup which granted the Serbs a spot in the CONCACAF Champions' Cup.[6]
Rochester Lancers
In 1976, he joined former head coach Don Popovic south of the border to play in the North American Soccer League with Rochester Lancers.[7] In his debut season in the NASL, he finished the season with a 1.28 goals-against average placing him tenth in the overall goalkeeping stats.[8] He also helped the Lancers secure a playoff berth and played in the opening round of the competition where Rochester was eliminated to Toronto Metros-Croatia.[9] Tamindžić departed from Rochester following the conclusion of the season.[10]
Montreal Castors
In 1977, he returned to the National Soccer League to sign with Montreal Castors.[11] In late 1977, Tamindžić along with six Montreal players were traded to the Ottawa Tigers in order to assist in their playoff match against Toronto Croatia to gain promotion to the NSL First Division.[12] The transaction provided Montreal with the bargaining rights to Mick Jones.[13] He re-signed with Montreal for the 1978 NSL season.[14]