Anderson was selected by the Chicago Bears in the first round, with the sixth overall pick, of the 1953 NFL draft.[2] He officially signed with the team on April 2, 1953.[3] He played in all 12 games, starting nine, for the Bears during his rookie year in 1953, totaling three receptions for 33 yards, five kick returns for 127 yards, one punt return for seven yards, and one punt for 46 yards.[2] Anderson appeared in seven games, starting one, during the 1954 season, recording three carries for eight yards, one kick return for 15 yards, one fumble, and one fumble recovery.[2] He became a free agent after the 1954 season.[3] He was a listed as a halfback during his time with the Bears and played both offense and defense.[1] He was 6' tall, weighed 198 pounds, and wore jersey number 46.[1]