League reorganisation saw Bewdley played in Division One for the 2004–05 season and they went on to win the division, taking promotion to the Premier Division after agreeing a groundshare with Stourport Swifts.[1] In 2010–11 the club won the Worcestershire Senior Urn, beating Studley 2–1 in the final.[1] They retained the Urn the following season, beating Alvechurch 3–2 in the final.[1] In 2021 the club were promoted to the Premier Division of the Midland League based on their results in the abandoned 2019–20 and 2020–21 seasons.
In 2023–24 Bewdley finished bottom of the Midland League Premier Division and were relegated to Division One of the Hellenic League.
Ground
The club initially played at Gardeners Meadow, which had been the home ground of both Bewdley Old Boys and Woodcolliers.[1] However, after it was sold for housing, the club temporarily moved to Kidderminster before purchasing land to build the Ribbesford Meadow Ground.[1] They were forced to groundshare with Stourport Swifts for the 2005–06 season in order to take promotion to the Premier Division, but returned to Ribbesford Meadow the following season after building a 140-seat stand and erecting floodlights.[3]