The 1916 Buffalo All-Stars (or just "All-Buffalo" as they were known in local papers) played in the Buffalo Semi Pro Football division which was considered part of the New York Pro Football League and posted a 7-3-1 record.
Eugene F. Dooley played quarterback and also managed the team.[1]
^"All-Buffalo Eleven Calls First Practice.", Buffalo Evening News, Buffalo, NY - September 16, 1916.
^"All-Buffalo Wins From Frontiers 7-0." Buffalo Courier, Buffalo, NY - October 2, 1916.
^"All-Buffalo Shows Much Class in Defeat" Buffalo Evening News, Buffalo, NY - October 9, 1916.
^"Results of Semi-Pro Football Clashes" Buffalo Evening News, Buffalo, NY - October 16, 1916.
^"J.Y.M.A.'s Beaten By All-Buffalos in Great Game, 6-0." Buffalo Courier, Buffalo, NY - October 23, 1916.
^"Bleich's Plunge Nets All-Buffalo Thrilling Victory." Buffalo Courier., Buffalo, NY - October 30, 1916.
^"Lancaster Holds All-Buffalo Team to Scoreless Draw." Buffalo Courier., Buffalo, NY - November 6, 1916.
^"All-Buffalo Wins From High School Selected Eleven." Buffalo Courier., Buffalo, NY - November 13, 1916.
^"Lewis' Drop Kick Beats All-Buffalo." Buffalo Courier., Buffalo, NY - November 20, 1916.
^"Gridiron Contests by Semi-Pro Elevens." Buffalo Evening News., Buffalo, NY - November 27, 1916.
^"All-Buffalo Wins Rough Game From All-Lancaster." Buffalo Evening News., Buffalo, NY - December 1, 1916.
^"All-Buffalo Wins With On-Side Kick." Buffalo Courier., Buffalo, NY - December 4, 1916.
^"State Title Claimed By Jefferons.," Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, Rochester, NY - December 4, 1916.
Notes
^The outcome of the game was disputed as the Rochester team considered the Buffalo onside kick and subsequent score illegal. Rochester claimed a 6-0 victory over Buffalo and the state title.[13]