Tara Seetharam of Country Universe listed "You're Beginning to Get to Me" as the 302nd best country single of the 1990s and wrote, "In his catalogue of fabulous 90s hits, this understated “love” song gets overshadowed by some of the more distinct ones, but it’s nonetheless memorable."[2]
Chart performance
The song debuted at number 63 on the Hot Country Singles & Tracks chart dated August 22, 1998. It charted for 27 weeks on that chart, and peaked at number 2 on the chart dated January 2, 1999 (having been blocked from Number One by Terri Clark's "You're Easy on the Eyes", another song co-written by Tom Shapiro.) In addition, it entered the Top 40 on the Billboard Hot 100, where it peaked at number 39 on that chart.