The park overlaps the former site of the Washington National Guard Armory,[1] which was originally built around 1909 and damaged by fire in 1962 at a time when the future of the Market itself was a contentious issue.[2] It was eventually torn down in 1968.[3] Victor Steinbrueck, who was instrumental in the preservation of nearby Pike Place Market and Pioneer Square, wrote of the location in 1968: "One of the grandest downtown lookout places is at Western Avenue where it meets Pike Place and Virginia Street. It has been neglected by the city and its possibilities for enjoyment are ignored except by a few habitués and passing pedestrians."[3] Steinbrueck was strongly opposed to the demolition of the armory. "Buildings like this," he wrote, "(and there are very few) offer an irreplaceable tie with the past as well as adding variety and interest to new surroundings. Restoration is not at all impossible or difficult for sympathetic designers. Others can always find practical reasons for destruction."[3]
The city purchased the land in 1968, demolished the remnant of the armory, and transferred ownership to the parks department in 1970. The park was landscaped in 1982 as Market Park. Two cedartotem poles, designed by Marvin Oliver[4] and carved by James Bender, were added in 1984.[5] After Steinbrueck's death in 1985, the park was renamed after him.[2] His son Peter Steinbrueck, also an architect, would later serve on the Seattle City Council from 1997 to 2007. The totem poles, which do not have indigenous meaning or significance, may be removed.[6]
In December 2022, the park closed for a two-year renovation project to repair the waterproofing membrane under the park, which had deteriorated and leaked water into the parking garage below. The project will also include new furnishings, a replacement pavilion, and upgraded lighting.[7] The park is scheduled to reopen in late 2024, more than several months behind schedule. A modified plan released in December 2023 would permanently replace the totem poles with indigenous sculptures from members of the Suquamish and Muckleshoot tribes.[8] The Pike Place Market Historical Commission rejected the plan and required the restoration of the original totem poles. The renovations were completed in late 2024, but the park's reopening was delayed due to the ongoing dispute with the commission.[9]
^Victor Steinbrueck Park, official site, accessed online 28 March 2008, says simply that the park is on the site of the armory, but the Sanborn maps of Seattle (volume 2, 1950, plate 128) accessed online through Proquest 28 March 2008, shows the armory as extending as far north as Lenora Street (beyond the northern boundary of the park), and not extending quite as far south as Virginia Street (whereas the park extends considerably south of Virginia Street).
