After signing his first professional contract in November 2016,[3] Abrahams went on loan to Cambridge City, making his debut in the 0–0 draw against St Ives Town on 26 December,[4] and returning to Orient in January 2017.[5]
He made his Football League debut as a second-half substitute for Josh Koroma in Orient's 4–0 win at Newport County on 4 March 2017.[6]
Abrahams scored his first senior goal in Orient's 2–2 draw at Luton Town at Kenilworth Road on 14 April 2017.[7] He started the following game on 17 April and scored the winning goal as Orient beat Hartlepool United 2–1.[8]
Norwich City
On 31 July 2017, Abrahams made the switch to Norwich City for an undisclosed fee.[9]
Abrahams rejoined Orient on loan for the 2017–18 National League season.[10] The loan spell was terminated on 1 September 2017 without any appearances made.[11]
In July 2018, Abrahams joined League Two side Exeter City on loan until the end of the 2018–19 season.[12]
On 31 January 2019, Abrahams was recalled from his loan at Exeter City and instead joined Yeovil Town on loan until the end of the season replacing his injured Norwich team-mate Diallang Jaiyesimi.[13]
Newport County
On 25 July 2019, following his release from Norwich City, Abrahams signed for League Two side Newport County on a two-year contract.[14] On 3 August 2019, he made his debut for Newport in a 2–2 draw against Mansfield Town as a second-half substitute[15] He scored his first goal for Newport on 13 August 2019 in the EFL Cup first round win against Gillingham.[16] On 12 November 2019 he scored a hat-trick for Newport in the 7–4 EFL Trophy win against Cheltenham Town.[17] In July 2020 Abrahams was selected as Newport County's Young Player of the Year for the 2019–20 season.[18] On 5 September 2020 Abrahams scored both goals in Newport's 2–0 EFL Cup first round win against Championship club Swansea City.[19] On 22 September 2020 Abrahams scored the first goal, a penalty, in Newport's 3–1 EFL Cup second round win against Championship club Watford.[20] On 30 September 2020 Abrahams scored Newport's goal in the 1–1 EFL Cup third round match against Premier League club Newcastle United, with Newcastle eventually winning on penalties.[21] On 1 February 2021 Abrahams rejoined Leyton Orient on loan for the remainder of the 2020–21 season.[22]
Carlisle United
In June 2021, at the end of his Newport contract, Abrahams joined Carlisle United on a two-year deal.[23]
On 20 January 2022, Abrahams signed for Grimsby Town on loan for the remainder of the 2021–22 season.[24]
^The goal scored on 29 March 2024, originally attributed to Remy Clerima and still listed as such by some sources, was actually scored by Abrahams.[38]
^Two appearances and two goals in National League Cup, one appearance in FA Trophy