Thinking, Fast and Slow is a 2011 popular science book by psychologist Daniel Kahneman.
The book's main thesis is a differentiation between two modes of thought: "System 1" is fast, instinctive and emotional; "System 2" is slower, more deliberative, and more logical.
The book delineates rational and non-rational motivations or triggers associated with each type of thinking process, and how they complement each other, starting with Kahneman's own research on loss aversion. From framing choices to people's tendency to replace a difficult question with one which is easy to answer, the book summarizes several decades of research to suggest that people have too much confidence in human judgment.[1] Kahneman performed his own research, often in collaboration with Amos Tversky, which enriched his experience to write the book.[2][3] It covers different phases of his career: his early work concerning cognitive biases, his work on prospect theory and happiness, and with the Israel Defense Forces.
In the book's first section, Kahneman describes two different ways the brain forms thoughts:
System 1: Fast, automatic, frequent, emotional, stereotypic, unconscious. Examples (in order of complexity) of things system 1 can do:
determine that an object is at a greater distance than another
localize the source of a specific sound
complete the phrase "war and ..."
display disgust when seeing a gruesome image
solve 2+2=?
read text on a billboard
drive a car on an empty road
think of a good chess move (if you're a chess master)
understand simple sentences
System 2: Slow, effortful, infrequent, logical, calculating, conscious. Examples of things system 2 can do:
prepare yourself for the start of a sprint
direct your attention towards the clowns at the circus
direct your attention towards someone at a loud party
look for the woman with the grey hair
try to recognize a sound
sustain a faster-than-normal walking rate
determine the appropriateness of a particular behavior in a social setting
count the number of A's in a certain text
give someone your telephone number
park into a tight parking space
determine the price/quality ratio of two washing machines
determine the validity of a complex logical reasoning
solve 17 × 24
Kahneman describes a number of experiments which purport to examine the differences between these two thought systems and how they arrive at different results even given the same inputs. Terms and concepts include coherence, attention, laziness, association, jumping to conclusions, WYSIATI (What you see is all there is), and how one forms judgments. The System 1 vs. System 2 debate includes the reasoning or lack thereof for human decision making, with big implications for many areas including law and market research.[7]
The second section offers explanations for why humans struggle to think statistically. It begins by documenting a variety of situations in which we either arrive at binary decisions or fail to associate precisely reasonable probabilities with outcomes. Kahneman explains this phenomenon using the theory of heuristics. Kahneman and Tversky originally discussed this topic in their 1974 article titled Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases.[8]
Kahneman uses heuristics to assert that System 1 thinking involves associating new information with existing patterns, or thoughts, rather than creating new patterns for each new experience. For example, a child who has only seen shapes with straight edges might perceive an octagon when first viewing a circle. As a legal metaphor, a judge limited to heuristic thinking would only be able to think of similar historical cases when presented with a new dispute, rather than considering the unique aspects of that case. In addition to offering an explanation for the statistical problem, the theory also offers an explanation for human biases.
The "anchoring effect" names a tendency to be influenced by irrelevant numbers. Shown greater/lesser numbers, experimental subjects gave greater/lesser responses.[2] As an example, most people, when asked whether Gandhi was more than 114 years old when he died, will provide a much greater estimate of his age at death than others who were asked whether Gandhi was more or less than 35 years old. Experiments show that people's behavior is influenced, much more than they are aware, by irrelevant information.
The availability heuristic is a mental shortcut that occurs when people make judgments about the probability of events on the basis of how easy it is to think of examples. The availability heuristic operates on the notion that, "if you can think of it, it must be important". The availability of consequences associated with an action is related positively to perceptions of the magnitude of the consequences of that action. In other words, the easier it is to recall the consequences of something, the greater we perceive these consequences to be. Sometimes, this heuristic is beneficial, but the frequencies at which events come to mind are usually not accurate representations of the probabilities of such events in real life.[9][10]
Conjunction fallacy
System 1 is prone to substituting a simpler question for a difficult one. In what Kahneman terms their "best-known and most controversial" experiment, "the Linda problem," subjects were told about an imaginary Linda, young, single, outspoken, and intelligent, who, as a student, was very concerned with discrimination and social justice. They asked whether it was more probable that Linda is a bank teller or that she is a bank teller and an active feminist. The overwhelming response was that "feminist bank teller" was more likely than "bank teller," violating the laws of probability. (All feminist bank tellers are bank tellers, so the former can't be more likely). In this case System 1 substituted the easier question, "Is Linda a feminist?", neglecting the occupation qualifier. An alternative interpretation is that the subjects added an unstated cultural implicature to the effect that the other answer implied an exclusive or, that Linda was not a feminist.[2]
Optimism and loss aversion
Kahneman writes of a "pervasive optimistic bias", which "may well be the most significant of the cognitive biases." This bias generates the illusion of control: the illusion that we have substantial control of our lives.
A natural experiment reveals the prevalence of one kind of unwarranted optimism. The planning fallacy is the tendency to overestimate benefits and underestimate costs, impelling people to begin risky projects. In 2002, American kitchen remodeling was expected on average to cost $18,658, but actually cost $38,769.[2]
To explain overconfidence, Kahneman introduces the concept he terms What You See Is All There Is (WYSIATI). This theory states that when the mind makes decisions, it deals primarily with Known Knowns, phenomena it has observed already. It rarely considers Known Unknowns, phenomena that it knows to be relevant but about which it does not have information. Finally it appears oblivious to the possibility of Unknown Unknowns, unknown phenomena of unknown relevance.
He explains that humans fail to take into account complexity and that their understanding of the world consists of a small and necessarily un-representative set of observations. Furthermore, the mind generally does not account for the role of chance and therefore falsely assumes that a future event will be similar to a past event.
Framing is the context in which choices are presented. Experiment: subjects were asked whether they would opt for surgery if the "survival" rate is 90 percent, while others were told that the mortality rate is 10 percent. The first framing increased acceptance, even though the situation was no different.[11]
Rather than consider the odds that an incremental investment would produce a positive return, people tend to "throw good money after bad" and continue investing in projects with poor prospects that have already consumed significant resources. In part this is to avoid feelings of regret.[11]
This part (part III, sections 19–24) of the book is dedicated to the undue confidence in what the mind believes it knows. It suggests that people often overestimate how much they understand about the world and underestimate the role of chance in particular. This is related to the excessive certainty of hindsight, when an event seems to be understood after it has occurred or developed. Kahneman's opinions concerning overconfidence are influenced by Nassim Nicholas Taleb.[12]
Choices
In this section Kahneman returns to economics and expands his seminal work on Prospect Theory. He discusses the tendency for problems to be addressed in isolation and how, when other reference points are considered, the choice of that reference point (called a frame) has a disproportionate effect on the outcome. This section also offers advice on how some of the shortcomings of System 1 thinking can be avoided.
Kahneman developed prospect theory, the basis for his Nobel prize, to account for experimental errors he noticed in Daniel Bernoulli's traditional utility theory.[13] According to Kahneman, Utility Theory makes logical assumptions of economic rationality that do not represent people's actual choices, and does not take into account cognitive biases.
One example is that people are loss-averse: they are more likely to act to avert a loss than to achieve a gain. Another example is that the value people place on a change in probability (e.g., of winning something) depends on the reference point: people seem to place greater value on a change from 0% to 10% (going from impossibility to possibility) than from, say, 45% to 55%, and they place the greatest value of all on a change from 90% to 100% (going from possibility to certainty). This occurs despite the fact that by traditional utility theory all three changes give the same increase in utility. Consistent with loss-aversion, the order of the first and third of those is reversed when the event is presented as losing rather than winning something: there, the greatest value is placed on eliminating the probability of a loss to 0.
After the book's publication, the Journal of Economic Literature published a discussion of its parts concerning prospect theory,[14] as well as an analysis of the four fundamental factors on which it is based.[15]
Two selves
The fifth part of the book describes recent evidence which introduces a distinction between two selves, the 'experiencing self' and 'remembering self'.[16] Kahneman proposed an alternative measure that assessed pleasure or pain sampled from moment to moment, and then summed over time. Kahneman termed this "experienced" well-being and attached it to a separate "self." He distinguished this from the "remembered" well-being that the polls had attempted to measure. He found that these two measures of happiness diverged.[17]
Life as a story
The author's significant discovery was that the remembering self does not care about the duration of a pleasant or unpleasant experience. Instead, it retrospectively rates an experience by the maximum or minimum of the experience, and by the way it ends. The remembering self dominated the patient's ultimate conclusion.
"Odd as it may seem," Kahneman writes, "I am my remembering self, and the experiencing self, who does my living, is like a stranger to me."[3]
Experienced well-being
Kahneman first began the study of well-being in the 1990s. At the time most happiness research relied on polls about life satisfaction. Having previously studied unreliable memories, the author was doubtful that life satisfaction was a good indicator of happiness. He designed a question that emphasized instead the well-being of the experiencing self. The author proposed that "Helen was happy in the month of March" if she spent most of her time engaged in activities that she would rather continue than stop, little time in situations that she wished to escape, and not too much time in a neutral state that wouldn't prefer continuing or stopping the activity either way.
Kahneman suggests that emphasizing a life event such as a marriage or a new car can provide a distorted illusion of its true value. This "focusing illusion" revisits earlier ideas of substituting difficult questions and WYSIATI.
The book has achieved a large following among baseball scouts and baseball executives. The ways of thinking described in the book are believed to help scouts, who have to make major judgements off little information and can easily fall into prescriptive yet inaccurate patterns of analysis.[47]
The last chapter of Paul Bloom's Against Empathy discusses concepts also touched in Daniel Kahneman's book, Thinking, Fast and Slow, that suggest people make a series of rational and irrational decisions.[48][48]: 214 He criticizes the argument that "regardless of reason's virtues, we just aren't any good at it." His point is that people are not as "stupid as scholars think they are."[48]: 216 He explains that people are rational because they make thoughtful decisions in their everyday lives. For example, when someone has to make a big life decision they critically assess the outcomes, consequences, and alternative options.[48]: 230
Part of the book has been swept up in the replication crisis facing psychology and the social sciences. It was discovered many prominent research findings were difficult or impossible for others to replicate, and thus the original findings were called into question. An analysis[50] of the studies cited in chapter 4, "The Associative Machine", found that their replicability index (R-index)[51] is 14, indicating essentially low to no reliability. Kahneman himself responded to the study in blog comments and acknowledged the chapter's shortcomings: "I placed too much faith in underpowered studies."[52] Others have noted the irony in the fact that Kahneman made a mistake in judgment similar to the ones he studied.[53]
A later analysis[54] made a bolder claim that, despite Kahneman's previous contributions to the field of decision making, most of the book's ideas are based on 'scientific literature with shaky foundations'. A general lack of replication in the empirical studies cited in the book was given as a justification.
^Tversky, Amos; Kahneman, Daniel (September 1973). "Availability: A heuristic for judging frequency and probability". Cognitive Psychology. 5 (2): 207–232. doi:10.1016/0010-0285(73)90033-9.(subscription required)
^Durr, Tony (February 1, 2014). "Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman". American Journal of Education. 120 (2): 287–291. doi:10.1086/674372. ISSN0195-6744.
^Akst, Daniel (2011). "Rushing to Judgment". The Wilson Quarterly. 35 (4): 97–98. JSTOR41484407.
^Harrison, Kelly A. (2012). "Review of Thinking, Fast and Slow". Technical Communication. 59 (4): 342–343. JSTOR43093040.
^Richardson, Megan Lloyd (2012). "Review of Thinking, Fast and Slow [sic, included in a set of reviews]". The University of Toronto Law Journal. 62 (3): 453–457. doi:10.1353/tlj.2012.0013. JSTOR23263811. S2CID144044453.
^Vassallo, Philip (2012). "Review of Thinking, Fast and Slow". ETC: A Review of General Semantics. 69 (4): 480. JSTOR42579224.
2016 American filmContemporary ColorDirected by Turner Ross Bill Ross IV Produced by David Byrne Michael Gottwald Dan Janvey Josh Penn StarringDavid ByrneCinematography Turner Ross Bill Ross IV Jarred Alterman Release date April 14, 2016 (2016-04-14) Running time97 minutesCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglish Contemporary Color is a 2016 documentary film directed by Turner Ross and Bill Ross IV. The film was produced as a collaboration between David Byrne, Michael Gottwald, Dan J...
Ranuccio Farnese, O.S.Io.Hieros.cardinale di Santa Romana ChiesaRitratto di Ranuccio Farnese in abito di Cavaliere di Malta di Tiziano, 1542. Oggi questo dipinto è conservato nella National Gallery of Art, Washington Incarichi ricoperti Amministratore apostolico di Napoli (1544-1549) Cardinale diacono di Santa Lucia in Silice (1546) Legato apostolico della Marca Anconitana (1546-1547) Patriarca titolare di Costantinopoli (1546-1550) (1554-1565) Cardinale diacono di Sant'Angelo in Pesch...
Perbandingan RNA (kiri) dengan DNA (kanan). Hipotesis dunia RNA merupakan hipotesis yang mengusulkan bahwa kehidupan yang didasari asam ribonukleat (RNA) mendahului kehidupan yang berdasarkan asam deoksiribonukleat (DNA), RNA, dan protein. RNA dapat menyimpan informasi genetik (seperti DNA) dan juga mengatalis reaksi kimia (seperti protein enzim). RNA telah mendukung kehidupan pra-seluler dan merupakan salah satu tahap utama dalam evolusi kehidupan seluler. Pranala luar The RNA world (2001) D...
Tercera República de Vietnam Bandera Himno: Tiếng gọi công dân ¿Problemas al reproducir este archivo? Capital Saigón (de jure)Little Saigon (de facto)Idioma oficial vietnamitaForma de gobierno Gobierno en el exilioFundaciónParcialmente Oficialmente 21 de octubre de 1990 16 de febrero de 1991[editar datos en Wikidata] La Tercera República de Vietnam (en vietnamita: Đệ Tam Việt Nam Cộng Hòa) abreviado a la República de Vietnam, también conocido como el Gobierno Na...
Grande Prêmio do Alabama Mapa do Barber Motorsports Park. Informações gerais Local Barber Motorsports Park, Birmingham, Alabama Primeira corrida 2010 Última corrida 2015 Distância 3,7 km Número de voltas 90 Maior vencedor (pilotos) Will Power Ryan Hunter-Reay Maior vencedor (equipes) Penske Grande Prêmio do Alabama (em inglês: Grand Prix of Alabama) é um evento automobilístico que faz parte da IndyCar Series. A corrida acontecerá em no circuito Barber Motorsports Park, localizado n...
Pemandangan Pesisir dengan Balaam dan Keledainya (lukisan tahun 1636 karya Bartholomeus Breenbergh) Balak (בָּלָק — Ibrani untuk Balak, sebuah nama, kata kedua dan kata distinsif pertama dalam parsyah tersebut) adalah Bacaan Taurat Mingguan (פָּרָשָׁה, parashah) ke-40 dalam siklus bacaan Taurat Yahudi tahunan dan ketujuh dalam Kitab Bilangan. Dalam parsyah tersebut, Balak putra Zippor, raja Moab, berniat untuk mengundang Balaam untuk mengutuk Israel,[1] keledai Balaam...
1982 video game This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: The Amazing Adventures of Mr. F. Lea – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (July 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 1982 video gameMr. F. LeaDeveloper(s)Pacific NoveltyPublisher(s)Pacific NoveltyPlatform(s)ArcadeR...
KertosariKelurahanPeta lokasi Kelurahan KertosariNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TimurKabupatenBanyuwangiKecamatanBanyuwangiKodepos68418Kode Kemendagri35.10.16.1006 Kode BPS3510180006 Luas... km2Jumlah penduduk... jiwaKepadatan... jiwa/km2 Untuk tempat lain yang bernama sama, lihat Kertosari. Makam Datuk Daeng Ruyung Kelurahan Kertosari merupakan salah satu kelurahan yang terletak di bagian timur kecamatan Banyuwangi, Kabupaten Banyuwangi, Provinsi Jawa Timur, Indonesia. Pembagian Wilayah K...
1998 novel by Orson Scott Card HeartFire Front coverAuthorOrson Scott CardCover artistDennis NolanCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglishSeriesThe Tales of Alvin MakerGenreFantasy, alternate historyPublisherTor BooksPublication date1998Media typePrint (Hardcover & Paperback)Pages336ISBN0-8125-0924-2OCLC41344560Preceded byAlvin Journeyman Followed byThe Crystal City Heartfire (1998) is an alternate history/fantasy novel by American writer Orson Scott Card. It is ...
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. Please help improve it by removing promotional content and inappropriate external links, and by adding encyclopedic content written from a neutral point of view. (March 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) This article needs additional citations for ve...
Style of furniture Selection of Danish Modern works Danish modern is a style of minimalist furniture and housewares from Denmark associated with the Danish design movement. In the 1920s, Kaare Klint embraced the principles of Bauhaus modernism in furniture design, creating clean, pure lines based on an understanding of classical furniture craftsmanship coupled with careful research into materials, proportions, and the requirements of the human body. Designers such as Arne Jacobsen and Hans We...
Historic house in South Carolina, United States United States historic placeThomas E. Hart HouseU.S. National Register of Historic PlacesU.S. Historic district Show map of South CarolinaShow map of the United StatesLocation624 W. Carolina Ave., Hartsville, South CarolinaCoordinates34°22′1″N 80°6′57″W / 34.36694°N 80.11583°W / 34.36694; -80.11583Area30 acres (12 ha)Built1817ArchitectCoker, May Roper; Harbison, Thomas G.Architectural styleEarly Repu...
American businessman (1927–1992) For the historian, see Steven J. Ross (historian). This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article's lead section may be too short to adequately summarize the key points. Please consider expanding the lead to provide an accessible overview of all important aspects of the article. (September 2021) This article contains content that is written...
Farmer Phil's FestivalGenreRock, ska, reggae, cover bandsDatesAugustLocation(s)Near Gatten Farm, Ratlinghope, Shropshire, EnglandYears active1998–presentWebsitehttp://www.farmerphilsfestival.com Farmer Phil's Festival is a music festival that takes place in early August at Near Gatten Farm, near Ratlinghope, Shropshire. The festival was founded by, and is managed by the eponymous Philip Harding and was first held in 1998. History Main Stage in 2017 - Ferocious Dog on stage Early festivals w...
Canadian religious organization Not to be confused with United Church of Canada. This article may rely excessively on sources too closely associated with the subject, potentially preventing the article from being verifiable and neutral. Please help improve it by replacing them with more appropriate citations to reliable, independent, third-party sources. (June 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Canadian Unitarian Council Conseil unitarien du CanadaThe official logo of ...
2021 Tokyo prefectural election ← 2017 4 July 2021 2025 → All 127 seats in the Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly64 seats needed for a majorityTurnout42.39% (8.89%)[1] First party Second party Third party Leader Ichirō Kamoshita Chiharu Araki Yōsuke Takagi Party Liberal Democratic Tomin First Komeito Last election 23 seats, 22.53% 49 seats, 33.68% 23 seats, 13.13% Seats before 25 46 23 Seats won 33 31 23 Seat change 8 15 Popular&...
Basketball team The Salem Trailblazers were an American professional basketball team located in Salem, Oregon who played in the Pacific Coast Professional Basketball League (PCPBL) during the 1946–47 season. The Trailblazers used the Salem Armory as their home court. On December 22, 1946, the Bellingham Fircrests sold guard Don Stitt to Salem.[1] In January 1947, the Trailblazers only played one game in Salem and by February they abandoned the city as their home and became a traveli...
Dapur yang menyatu dengan anbang. Anbang (안방) atau Anchae (안채) yang berarti kamar bagian dalam adalah suatu ruangan yang terdapat pada rumah tradisional Korea (hanok) yang digunakan oleh istri dari seorang pemilik rumah.[1][2] Istri menggunakan anbang untuk beraktivitas sehari-hari.[1] Orang lain, terutama laki-laki selain suami dan kerabat dekat dilarang memasuki anbang tanpa meminta izin terlebih dahulu.[1] Karena tidak sembarang orang yang bisa memas...
Larry SangerSanger pada Juli 2006LahirLawrence Mark Sanger16 Juli 1968 (umur 55)Bellevue, Washington, Amerika SerikatAlmamaterReed CollegeOhio State UniversityPekerjaanEditor-in-Chief of CitizendiumSitus webwww.larrysanger.org Lawrence Mark Sanger (lahir 16 Juli 1968) adalah pengelola dan perintis proyek-proyek ensiklopedia online. Pada awalnya Sanger adalah sosok penting dalam pendekatan penulisan oleh pakar (ahli) dan mengedit Ensiklopedia Bumi. Pada 15 September 2006 ia mengusulkan ca...