The album was partly recorded in a barn close to Vig's Smart Studios.[6]
Critical reception
Trouser Press wrote: "A bit more bite would not have gone amiss; much of Fleming’s lyric irony sounds more weary than wired. Still, Super Tasty is a buzzin’ good time, if only for its wonderfully retro sonic glitz."[7] The Chicago Tribune called the album "overproduced," writing that the songs sounded better in concert.[8]New York Magazine called it "full of rollicking, loose-limbed road songs."[6]The New York Times wrote: " In songs that are well-made but never break free of their genres, the band seems content to be a throwback, while a listener is left waiting for the twist."[9]Spin wrote that Super Tasty "has a nice, loose, rockin' vibe."[10]