An Udinese youth product, Scuffet made his first team debut on 1 February 2014 at the age of 17 in a Serie A match against Bologna, as a replacement for injured Željko Brkić.[2] After a string of impressive performances, he was subsequently promoted as first choice keeper, relegating Brkić on the bench.[3]
On 9 June 2014, following a successful debut season, Scuffet signed a new five-year deal with the club.[4] He failed to get the same level of game time during the 2014–15 season with Orestis Karnezis preferred as the first-choice goalkeeper at Udinese.[5] On 8 December 2014, he Scuffet was named at the #1 spot in the goalkeepers category as part of Outside of the Boot's 100 Best Young Players to Watch in 2015 feature.[6] On 16 December 2014, he was named at the #1 spot as FutbolSapiens's 10 Best Young Goalkeepers of the Year feature.[7]
Various loans
On 6 August 2015, Scuffet was sent out on loan to Serie B side Como.[8] Although he was able to obtain more playing time at Como, he endured a negative season with the club, as he conceded 52 goals, while Como finished in last place in the league and were relegated to Lega Pro at the end of the 2015–16 Serie B season.[5][9]
On 16 January 2019, Scuffet joined Turkish side Kasımpaşa on loan until 30 June.[10]
On 19 August 2019, Scuffet joined Serie B club Spezia on loan until 30 June 2020 with an option to buy.[11] He was the starting goalkeeper throughout the season, which ended with the club achieving promotion to Serie A.[12]
Return to Udinese
In July 2020, Scuffet returned to Udinese. On 28 October, he returned between the sticks for the club, playing as a starter in the Italian Cup match against Vicenza, which finished in a 3–1 win. On 2 May 2021, due to a suspension of starting goalkeeper Juan Musso, he returned to Serie A action for the 2–1 defeat against Juventus in which he conceded two goals to Cristiano Ronaldo.[13]
Scuffet has earned praise in the media for his reflexes, confidence, consistency, calm composure, leadership qualities, and precocious performances as a youngster, which have earned him comparisons with former Italy national football team goalkeeper and 2006 World Cup winner Gianluigi Buffon, who also made his Serie A debut as a teenager.[20][23][24][25] In 2014 Don Balón listed him as one of the top 100 young players in the world.[26] His ability to come out off his line and his confidence when handling crosses and high balls have been cited as areas for improvement by pundits, however.[5]