Shudder to Think

Shudder to Think
Shudder to Think, 1996. L-R: Craig Wedren, Nathan Larson, Kevin March, and Stuart Hill.
Background information
Origin	Washington, D.C., United States
Genres	Post-hardcore alternative rock[1] power pop math rock noise rock
Years active	1986–1998 2007–2009 2013
Labels	Sammitch Hoss Dischord Your Choice Sub Pop Epic Team Love
Past members	Craig Wedren Stuart Hill Chris Matthews Mike Russell Nathan Larson Adam Wade Kevin March Mark Watrous Jesse Krakow

Shudder to Think was an American alternative rock band. Formed in 1986, they released three albums on the Washington, D.C.–based label Dischord Records, and two on Epic Records. Their early work was largely influenced by post-hardcore although they gradually drew upon a wide range of stylistic influences, including power pop and glam rock.

Craig Wedren performing with Shudder to Think in the early 1990s.

History

In 1984, bassist Stuart Hill formed the hardcore punk band Stüge, recruiting drummer Mike Russell, alongside guitarist Sam Fleming and vocalist Bobby Jones. By 1986, Fleming and Jones left for college, with Hill inviting guitarist Chris Matthews, who had been playing in new wave group 3-2-1, to join the band. Matthews in turn suggested vocalist Craig Wedren, a high school acquaintance, after seeing him perform at a school play and being impressed by his singing. Shortly after, the band changed its name to Shudder to Think, after Russell said that he “shuddered to think that we would be just another hardcore band” during a drive to practice. It was this lineup and name change that drove the band to abandon its previous hardcore influenced sound to something more akin to post-hardcore.^[2]

In this incarnation, the band released one song on the Fetal Records compilation F-R-5 in 1987 ("Too little, too late"), two singles and one album (Curse, Spells, Voodoo, Mooses, 1989) before being signed by the Dischord label. Three albums were then released (Ten-Spot, 1990, Funeral at the Movies, 1991, and Get Your Goat, 1992), before the band gained greater exposure by touring with Fugazi and Smashing Pumpkins; with their May 7, 1992, show in Albig, Germany being released by Tobby Holzinger as Your Choice Live Series Vol.21.^[3]

Swiz ex-bassist Nathan Larson and ex-Jawbox drummer Adam Wade replaced Matthews and Russell in 1992 on guitar and drums respectively. Matthews and Russell last performed live with the band on January 1, 1992,^[4] and June 28, 1992,^[5] respectively, as announced by Wedren to the crowd during those concerts.

The band subsequently signed to Epic, with whom Pony Express Record was released in September 1994. The album's angular, mathematical post-hardcore earned it a devoted cult following – especially after the video for the track "X-French Tee Shirt" became a buzz clip on MTV and was regularly aired on the channel, as well as an article in Rolling Stone. The track also peaked at #36 on the Radio and Records Alternative chart.^[6] The album had sold 30,000 copies in the United States by the end of October 1994,^[7] and by February 1997 had sold 60,000 copies.^[8]

Over the next few years, Wedren successfully battled Hodgkin's Disease, Larson recorded an album with side project band Mind Science of the Mind, and Wade left the group. He was replaced by Kevin March, formerly drummer with Dambuilders.

They released another album, 50,000 B.C. in 1997, touring in support of it with March on drums, and touring member Chuck Scott on keyboards and percussion.^[9] The album was released to mixed reviews and was a commercial flop.^[10] It was after this that the band pivoted to writing soundtracks for films, composing the soundtracks to First Love, Last Rites, High Art, and providing two songs for the film Velvet Goldmine in 1998.

However, 1998 marked Larson's departure and the end of the group. Wedren has pursued a solo career, including an appearance on the Down to You soundtrack with "Didn't Mean to Do You Harm", and contributed backing vocals to Verve Pipe's 1999 eponymous album.

Both Larson and Wedren have gone on to create highly regarded music for films. David Wain, founder of comedy troupe The State, was a high-school friend of Wedren's, and Wedren's music has appeared in many television series and films stemming from the troupe and its alumni, such as Reno 911! and Wet Hot American Summer. Wedren also makes solo music, and released his debut album, Lapland, in 2005. Larson has formed a new band called Hot One.

Reunions

Wedren, Larson, and March performed a brief set together on September 17, 2007, at The Mercury Lounge in New York City, which also featured guitarist Mark Watrous and Time of Orchids bassist Jesse Krakow playing in the lineup.^[11] The band continued to perform shows with Watrous and Krakow throughout 2008, with March playing the eastern dates and Wade on the western dates and New Orleans. The band released a live album entitled Live from Home in 2009. Without Larson, the band played what was billed as a "final" show on September 2, 2009, at the Bowery Ballroom in New York City.^[12] This show also featured founding guitarist Chris Matthews, who played during the show's encore.^[13]

Shudder to Think reunited again in 2013 for the 20th anniversary of the Black Cat venue. In addition to a full set by the Pony Express Record lineup of Wedren, Larson, Wade and Hill, founding members Chris Matthews and Mike Russell performed on the encore.

Legacy

Shudder to Think has been listed as an influence by other bands – Incubus went as far as covering part of "X-French Tee Shirt" in their song "Nowhere Fast" during Lollapalooza in 2003.^[14] Jeff Buckley also listed Shudder to Think as a favorite band of his.^[15] In 1998 Pearl Jam invited Shudder to Think to open for them on a tour of Australia and even played a snippet of the Shudder song "Pebbles" during their set.^[16] Deftones have cited Shudder to Think as an influence^[17] and have even covered bits of "X-French Tee Shirt"^[18] and "So Into You" at live shows. Cursive mentions the band in their song "Sink to the Beat" off their EP, Burst and Bloom. Sunny Day Real Estate and Braid have also cited the band as an influence.^[19][20]

OK Go frontman Damian Kulash has expressed admiration for Shudder to Think, stating "I worshipped them. There was one year I saw them twelve times."^[21] Kulash has specifically noted the band's impact on his music:

"Shudder To Think: They taught me a certain sense of intentional rock. Their music was decidedly counter-intuitive. It was weird, especially Get Your Goat and Pony Express Record. It was music that refused to resolve something you already knew and was really beautiful and melodic and emotional. (...) Shudder made music unlike anything else you ever heard and was still poppy and beautiful and accessible. I think it convinced me that there’s space for music to be interesting and challenging while still beautiful."^[22]

Musical style

The band, which has been classified as post-hardcore,^[23] embraced "pop influences and a skewed sense of songwriting"^[24] while coming from a hardcore punk background "courtesy of their affiliation" with Dischord.^[24] Reviewer Charles Spano characterized some of the band's work as the result of the group skewing "their pop brilliance with Ric Ocasek grooves, a [David] Bowie and [...] Roxy Music glam bent [...], and the theatrics of Queen."^[25]

In the 2018 book Long Live Queen, when DJ/VJ Matt Pinfield was asked if Queen was an influence on 1990s alt-rock, he replied:

"Look at a band like Shudder to Think and a song like 'X-French Tee Shirt,' which was such a great song, because [the middle part] was one note, and he was singing two octaves over that."^[26]

In an interview from 1995, James Iha of The Smashing Pumpkins praised the band's originality, saying:

"Shudder to Think, I think, is a wholly original, amazing rock band. They're a rock band but they're totally different than what you've heard before in the guitar playing, the drumming, the bass, singing, it's all amazing. If you listen to a Shudder to Think record, you might be able to point to a few references but there's no way you could tag that band. And they're good, they write good songs. They're totally original."^[27]

Band members

• Craig Wedren - lead vocals (1986–1998, 2007–2009, 2013); guitar (1991–1998, 2007–2009, 2013); keyboards (1996–1998)
• Chris Matthews - guitar (1986–1992, 2009, 2013)
• Nathan Larson - guitar (1992–1998, 2007–2008, 2013); keyboards (1996–1998)
• Mark Watrous - guitar (2007–2009)
• Stuart Hill - bass (1986–1998, 2013)
• Jesse Krakow - bass (2007–2009)
• Mike Russell - drums (1986–1992, 2013)
• Adam Wade - drums (1992–1996, 2008, 2013)
• Kevin March - drums (1996–1998, 2007–2009)

Timeline

Discography

Albums

• Curses, Spells, Voodoo, Mooses (1988, Sammich Records)
• Ten Spot (1990, Dischord Records)
• Funeral at the Movies (1991, Dischord Records)
• Get Your Goat (1992, Dischord Records)
• Pony Express Record (1994, Epic)
• 50,000 B.C. (1997, Epic)

Live albums

• Your Choice Live Series (1992, Your Choice Records)
• Live from Home (2009, Team Love)

Demo EP

• Shudder To Think (1994, Epic ESK5691)

Singles

• It Was Arson (1988, Sammich)
• Medusa Seven (1989, Hoss)
• Catch of the Day (1990, Trout, split w/ Unrest)
• Hit Liquor / No Room 9, Kentucky 7" (1992, Dischord)
• Hit Liquor (1994, Epic)
• X - French T-Shirt / Shake Your Halo Down 7" (1994, Sub Pop)
• S/T (Live) (1994, Epic)
• So Into You (1995, Epic)
• Red House (1997, Epic)

Soundtracks

• First Love, Last Rites soundtrack (et al.) 1998
• High Art soundtrack (et al.) 1999
• Velvet Goldmine soundtrack 1998

Compilations

• F-R-5 (A compilation album)* - 1987 Fetal Records #005
• State of the Union: D.C. Benefit Compilation* – 1989 Dischord Records
• Funeral at the Movies/Ten Spot
• O Come All Ye Faithful (Rock for Choice) – 1996
• 1987 - (2024, L.G. Records)

References

1. Howe, Brian (January 7, 2014). "Shudder To Think made the most head-fucking non-hit of the '90s". The A.V. Club. Retrieved October 4, 2022.
2. "Hold Back the Road That Goes... The Story of Shudder to Think - Part Two". January 8, 2015. Retrieved January 18, 2024.
3. "Shudder to Think : Your Choice Live Series". AllMusic. Retrieved July 9, 2015.
4. "Shudder to Think LIVE Speak & Lies About the Sky 1-1-92 9:30". YouTube. April 4, 2007.
5. "Shudder to Think LIVE 'Red House'". YouTube. October 14, 2006.
6. "Radio and Records" (PDF). Americanradiohistory.com. June 9, 1995. Retrieved March 27, 2022.
7. Jenkins, Mark (October 30, 1994). "THINKING BIG". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved April 11, 2023.
8. Foege, Alec (February 6, 1997). "Michael Goldstone: The Fan". Rolling Stone. Retrieved April 11, 2023.
9. "Shudder to Think - (TLA) Philadelphia,Pa 3.19.97". YouTube. November 16, 2015.
10. Sherman, Heidi (July 30, 1998). "Shudder Settle the Score". Rolling Stone.
11. "Shudder to Think Reunite in NYC, Sort Of". Spin Magazine. September 18, 2007.
12. "Shudder to Think (sort of), Pattern is Movement & Blame the Patient @ Bowery Ballroom in NYC - pics & setlist". Brooklyn Vegan. September 3, 2009.
13. "Shudder to Think - Red House 9/2/09". YouTube. September 3, 2009.
14. "Incubus - Nowhere Fast / X-French Tee Shirt (Lollapalooza)". YouTube. July 2, 2012.
15. "Kingdom For A Kiss - Jeff Buckley ...in Words: The Sony Chat, Fall '95". Jeffbuckley.com. Archived from the original on February 24, 2012. Retrieved July 9, 2015.
16. "Pearl Jam Setlists". Theporch.org. Archived from the original on March 4, 2016. Retrieved July 9, 2015.
17. "Listen: Five Bands Inspired by Shudder to Think". Spin.com. Archived from the original on August 25, 2014.
18. "[PRO AUDIO] Deftones - Around the Fur live @ Glastonbury Festival - June 27th, 1998". Archived from the original on December 21, 2021. Retrieved July 9, 2015 – via YouTube.
19. Estey, Chris (October 15, 2009). "Another Sunny Day". The Stranger. Archived from the original on November 5, 2023. Retrieved November 5, 2023.
20. "BRAID - Reggies Chicago". Reggies Chicago. July 25, 2013. Archived from the original on May 18, 2023. Retrieved November 4, 2023.
21. Macomber, Shawn (March 25, 2015). "Q&A: OK Go On 10 Years Of Making Viral Videos". Stereogum. Archived from the original on October 1, 2023. Retrieved June 18, 2024.
22. "Chalkboard Confessional: Damian Kulash of OK Go". Alternative Press. January 11, 2010. Archived from the original on November 26, 2023. Retrieved September 22, 2024.
23. "Explore: Post-Hardcore (Top Artists)". Allmusic. Archived from the original on December 9, 2010. Retrieved March 18, 2011.
24. Bush, John. "Shudder to Think - Biography". AllMusic. Retrieved April 5, 2011.
25. Spano, Charles. "Curse, Spells, Voodoo, Moses - Shudder to Think - Review". AllMusic. Retrieved March 20, 2011.
26. Prato, Greg (2018). Long Live Queen: Rock Royalty Discuss Freddie, Brian, John & Roger. p. 154
27. Michael Goldberg. "Smashing Pumpkin James Iha Speaks His Mind, December 1995". Starla.org. Retrieved February 5, 2020.