Shinarump Conglomerate

Shinarump Conglomerate
Stratigraphic range: early Late Triassic 230–225 Ma PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N ↓
Shinarump Conglomerate at the Shinarump Cliffs, its type area
Type	Geological formation
Unit of	Chinle Formation
Underlies	Petrified Forest Member and other sub-units, Chinle Formation
Overlies	Moenkopi Formation units-(250-225 Ma), after erosion unconformity Temple Mountain Member-(lowest Chinle Formation), Moenkopi Formation-(Monument Valley, Arizona-Utah), De Chelly Sandstone-(50 ma erosion unconformity-Canyon De Chelly National Monument)
Thickness	200 feet (61 m) maximum variable
Lithology
Primary	conglomerate, sandstone, siltstone
Location
Coordinates	37.012°N 112.358°W / 37.012; -112.358
Region	Colorado Plateau
Extent	NNW-southeast perimeter Black Mesa (Arizona) NE & E-Defiance Plateau-(Uplift) S-north perimeter foothills White Mountains W & NW-Painted Desert
Type section
Named for	Shinarump Cliffs
Named by	Gilbert
Year defined	1875
Shinarump Conglomerate (the United States) Show map of the United States Shinarump Conglomerate (Utah) Show map of Utah

Massive, fallen Shinarump Conglomerate block (erosion-resistant) at start of trail (viewed up-trail) down to White House Ruin, Canyon De Chelly National Monument
(Note: pictured beside smooth-sided cliffs of the underlying De Chelly Sandstone)

The Shinarump Conglomerate is a geologic formation found in the Four Corners region of the United States. It was deposited in the early part of the Late Triassic period.

Description

The Shinarump Conglomerate is a highly resistant coarse-grained sandstone and pebble conglomerate^[1] (minor or major conglomerates are a typical base layer after unconformities or disconformities; the Shinarump is a major conglomerate) with rare lenses of mudstone, sometimes forming a caprock because of its hardness, cementation, and erosion resistance.^[2] The Shinarump is found throughout the Colorado Plateau with significant exposures as the canyon rimrock in the vicinity of Canyon De Chelly National Monument, at the north-northeast of the Defiance Plateau/Defiance Uplift. At Canyon De Chelly the Shinarump Conglomerate was laid down upon De Chelly Sandstone-(280 Ma, an erosion unconformity of 50 my), in a region at the west foothill region of the mostly north–south trending Chuska Mountains of northeast Arizona – northwest New Mexico.

Just northwest of Canyon De Chelly, the Shinarump also forms a caprock in Monument Valley across the border region of northern Arizona – and southern Utah. The Shinarump Conglomerate there is laid upon units of the Moenkopi Formation and remain as resistant caprocks preserving the vertical cliffs of De Chelly Sandstone and other units of the Monument Upwarp/Monument Uplift.^[2] The associated Black Mesa (Arizona)-Defiance Uplift extends southeast from Monument Valley into the western border region of New Mexico. The relatively steep east dip of geology units results in increasingly younger geologic units eastwards into New Mexico.

In west-central New Mexico, the Shinarump is thin and spotty, transitioning to laterally equivalent beds of the Zuni Mountains Formation. The latter is variegated sandstone and siltstone with abundant rhizoliths.^[3]

The Shinarump Conglomerate is again well-exposed along the Nacimiento Uplift in north-central New Mexico. In this area, it acts as a caprock for Red Mesa, Joaquin Mesa, Blue Bird Mesa, and Eureka Mesa, among other locations. Here it was long known as the Agua Zarca Sandstone Member of the Chinle Formation.^[4] However, that name was abandoned in favor of Shinarump in 2003.^[5][6]

Monument Valley and Canyon De Chelly caprock

5)-(horizontal)-Shinarump Conglomerate,
4)-(horizontal)-Moenkopi Formation,
3)-vertical cliffs of De Chelly Sandstone, and
2)-skirts/erosion slopes of Organ Rock Formation-(horizontally bedded)
The angular unconformity below is upon the
1)-low angle dipping Cedar Mesa Sandstone, commonly of southeast Utah

In Monument Valley, of Arizona and south Utah, only larger landforms still contain the protective caprock of the Shinarump Conglomerate. The vertical cliffs of highly resistant De Chelly Sandstone protect the highly erodable Organ Rock Formation that forms 'erosion skirts' at the base of the vertical monuments in Monument Valley. For larger mesas, or larger connected land forms, where the more erodable overlying Moenkopi Formation, has not been lost, (with the caprock Shinarump also being undermined), larger sections of Shinarump are thus preserved. Perimeter mesas in the Monument Valley region have the caprock protecting the upper surface, plants, and alluvium from easy erosion of the landform surface.

At Canyon de Chelly, the trail to White House Ruin,^[7] descends through the Shinarump Conglomerate, but also has a tributary slot canyon landform with large accumulations of the Shinarump erosional debris on the slot-canyon floor. The trail then descends through the cross–bedded cliffs (fossil sand dunes) of the De Chelly Sandstone.

Geologic history

Monument Valley mesa, with cliffs of De Chelly Sandstone

The Shinarump was deposited by a system of braided streams on a relatively flat erosional surface. Though generally uniform in thickness, its lower contact is one of the most prominent unconformities in the Colorado Plateau, occasionally filling deep channels eroded into the underlying beds. The largest of these, on the west side of Monument Valley, is 3,000 feet (910 meters) wide and 275 feet (84 meters) deep. The form of the channels suggests that the Moenkopi was not yet consolidated, but the de Chelly Sandstone was already well cemented, by the time Shinarump deposition began. Where the Shinarump lies on Moenkopi Formation, the upper Moenkopi beds tend to be bleached.^[2]

The upper contact of the Shinarump with younger Chinle beds tends to be gradational.^[2]

The partial geologic sequence is as follows, up to the latest Petrified Forest Member:^[8]

Petrified Forest Member, Late Triassic, 215 Ma

Shinarump Conglomerate, 225 Ma

Holbrook Member, Moenkopi, Middle Triassic, 240 Ma

Virgin Limestone Member, Moenkopi, (245-240 Ma)

Timpoweap and Sinbad members of the Moenkopi Formation, Early Triassic, 245 Ma

By the end of the Early and Middle Triassic the 'Triassic Seas' of the western ocean edge of the North American continent were retreating northwest with deposition of the Shinarump (225 Ma) and Petrified Forest Member (215 Ma). Highlands existed in southern Arizona and New Mexico, and in central and eastern regions of Nevada. These source areas provided the volcanic units of the Petrified Forest Member. The varied composition and oxidation of the included volcanic material provide the colorful units of the Chinle Formation of the Painted Desert, and specifically the units in Petrified Forest National Park at the southeast of the Painted Desert. The desert extends in an arc-shape, paralleling the northwest–by–southeast lineage of the Mogollon Rim, but turns due-north, east of Flagstaff, Arizona, on the east border of the San Francisco volcanic field region, as the Little Colorado River turns north, then northwest to enter the Grand Canyon region.

This arc-shaped Painted Desert region surrounds the south and west border of Black Mesa, the Monument Valley to the north, and the Defiance Plateau to the southeast. The southeast also has a perimeter of the Puerco River which flows southwestwards out of New Mexico and merges into the Little Colorado River. The caprock remainders of the Shinarump Conglomerate lie to north-northeast of the Defiance Uplift-Monument Upwarp.

Fossils

J.S. Newberry visited the abandoned copper mines of the Cañon del Cobre (36.300°N 106.352°W / 36.300; -106.352) in 1859 and discovered thousands of leaf impressions in a shale bed exposed in the roofs of the mine adits. Ash revisited the mines and confirmed in 1974 that the fossils included the conifers Brachyphyllum sp., Pagiophyllum newberryi Ward ex. Daugherty, and Araucarioxylon arizonicum Knowlton, and the cycads Otozamites macombii Newberry, 0. powelli (Fontaine) Berry, and Zamites occidentalis Newberry. Ferns were conspicuously absent. The flora are characteristic of the earliest late Triassic (Carnian age).^[9]

Economic geology

Mining of stratiform copper deposits in the Shinarump Conglomerate began at Cañon del Cobre in the 1600s but seems to have been abandoned by 1859.^[9][10] Copper was mined as chalcocite and other replacement minerals in petrified wood.^[9] Similar ore beds were mined at the Nacimiento Mine from the late 1880s to 1975, with production peaking at 4000 tons a day.^[11][12] A subsequent attempt at in-situ leaching of the ore was unsuccessful, requiring a massive clean-up effort. This has treated 67 million gallons since 2011.^[12]

The Shinarump has also yielded uranium, primarily from locally deep channels cut into the underlying beds and subsequently filled with Shinarump sediments.^[2]

History of investigation

The Shinarump Conglomerate was first defined by G.K. Gilbert in 1875 and named for exposures in the Shinarump Cliffs, which straddle the Utah-Arizona border.^[13] Stewart reduced the unit to a member of the Chinle Formation in 1957.^[14] The unit is given formation rank in New Mexico, where the Chinle is promoted to a group.^[6]

Footnotes

1. Blakey & Ranney 2008.
2. Evensen 1958.
3. Lucas, Spencer G. (2021). "Triassic stratigraphy of the southeastern Colorado Plateau, west-central New Mexico" (PDF). New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Series. 72: 229–240. Retrieved 24 August 2021.
4. Wood & Northrop 1946.
5. Zeigler, Heckert & Lucas 2003.
6. Lucas et al. 2005.
7. Lucchitta 2001.
8. Blakey & Ranney 2008, pp. 56–86.
9. Ash 1974.
10. Lucas, Spielmann & Krainer 2010.
11. Talbott 1974.
12. Bryan 2017.
13. Gilbert 1875.
14. Stewart 1957.

References

• Ash, Sydney R. (1974). "Upper Triassic plants of Canon del Cobre, New Mexico" (PDF). New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Series. 25: 179–184. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
• Blakey, Ron; Ranney, Wayne (2008). Ancient Landscapes of the Colorado Plateau. Grand Canyon Association. ISBN 978-1934656037.
• Bryan, Susan Montoya (December 26, 2017). "Old copper mine is one of many sites in West needing cleanup". The Seattle Times. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
• Chronic, Halka, 1983. Roadside Geology of Arizona, c. 1983, 23rd printing, Mountain Press Publishing Co. 322 pages. Hike 10, White House Ruin Trail, pp. 111–113. (softcover, ISBN 978-0-87842-147-3)
• Evensen, Charles G. (1958). "The Shinarump Member of the Chinle Formation" (PDF). New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Series. 9: 95–97. Retrieved 29 May 2020.
• Gilbert, G.K. (1875), "Report upon the geology of portions of Nevada, Utah, California, and Arizona, examined in the years 1871 and 1872", Report on the geographical and geological explorations and surveys west of the One Hundredth Meridian (Wheeler), U.S. Geological and Geographical Survey, Publication of the Wheeler Survey, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 17–187
• Lucas, Spencer G.; Zeigler, Kate E.; Heckert, Andrew B.; Hunt, Adrian P. (2005). "Review of Upper Triassic stratigraphy and biostratigraphy in the Chama Basin, northern New Mexico" (PDF). New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Series. 56: 170–181. Retrieved 29 April 2020.
• Lucas, Spencer; Spielmann, Justin; Krainer, Karl (2010). "Summary of geology of Canon del Cobre, Rio Arriba Couknty, New Mexico". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 49: 15–24. Retrieved 28 May 2020.
• Lucchitta (2001). "Hike 10, White House Ruin Trail". Hiking Arizona's Geology. The Mountaineers Books. pp. 111–113. ISBN 9781594853067.
• Stewart, John H. (1957). "Proposed Nomenclature of Part of Upper Triassic Strata in Southeastern Utah". AAPG Bulletin. 41 (3): 441–465. doi:10.1306/0BDA582E-16BD-11D7-8645000102C1865D.
• Talbott, Lyle W. (1974). "Nacimiento pit, a Triassic strata-bound copper deposit" (PDF). New Mexico Geological Society Field Conference Series. 25: 301–304. Retrieved 29 April 2020.
• Wood, G.H.; Northrop, S.A. (1946). "Geology of the Nacimiento Mountains, San Pedro Mountain, and adjacent plateaus in parts of Sandoval and Rio Arriba Counties, New Mexico". USGS Oil and Gas Investigations. OM-57. doi:10.3133/om57. Retrieved 29 April 2020.
• Zeigler, Kate E.; Heckert, Andrew B.; Lucas, Spencer G. (2003). "Paleontology and Geology of the Upper Triassic (Revueltian) Snyder Quarry, New Mexico". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 24: 15–16. Retrieved 29 April 2020.