Ross v. Blake

Ross v. Blake
Argued March 29, 2016
Decided June 6, 2016
Full case nameMichael Ross, Petitioner v. Shaidon Blake
Docket no.15-339
Citations578 U.S. ___ (more)
136 S. Ct. 1850; 195 L. Ed. 2d 117
ArgumentOral argument
Opinion announcementOpinion announcement
Case history
PriorBlake v. Ross, 787 F.3d 693 (4th Cir. 2015); cert. granted, 136 S. Ct. 614 (2015).
Holding
The Prison Litigation Reform Act’s requirement to exhaust administrative remedies does not have a “special circumstances” exception, but inmates are only required to exhaust administrative remedies that are genuinely available to them.
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Roberts
Associate Justices
Anthony Kennedy · Clarence Thomas
Ruth Bader Ginsburg · Stephen Breyer
Samuel Alito · Sonia Sotomayor
Elena Kagan
Case opinions
MajorityKagan, joined by Roberts, Kennedy, Ginsburg, Alito, Sotomayor
ConcurrenceThomas (in part)
ConcurrenceBreyer (in part)
Laws applied
Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1995

Ross v. Blake, 578 U.S. ___ (2016), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that "special circumstances" cannot excuse an inmate's failure to exhaust administrative remedies before filing a lawsuit under the Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1995,[1] but clarified that inmates are required to exhaust only administrative remedies that are genuinely available.[2] In so doing, it vacated and remanded the decision of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.[3][4]

Facts and Procedural History

In 2007, Shaidon Blake, an inmate in a Maryland prison, was assaulted by guards James Madigan and Michael Ross while being moved from his regular cell to the segregation unit.[5] Blake reported the incident to a senior corrections officer who referred it to the Maryland prison system's Internal Investigative Unit (IIU), which investigates employee misconduct.[5] The IIU investigated for a year, and then issued a report that condemned Madigan but made no findings regarding Ross.[5] Madigan then resigned.[5]

After the IIU issued its report, Blake sued Madigan and Ross under 42 U.S.C. § 1983; he claimed that Madigan used excessive force and Ross failed to take protective action.[5] A jury awarded Blake $50,000 as to his claim against Madigan.[5]

Ross presented an affirmative defense: Blake had sued without first exhausting the prison's Administrative Remedy Procedure (ARP) process, and thus was barred from court under the PLRA.[5] The PLRA, 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(a) provides that “No action shall be brought with respect to prison conditions under section 1983 of this title, or any other Federal law, by a prisoner confined in any jail, prison, or other correctional facility until such administrative remedies as are available are exhausted.”[6] Blake conceded that he had not submitted a formal grievance through the ARP, "because, he thought, the IIU investigation served as a substitute for that otherwise standard process."[5]

District Court Decision

Judge Alexander Williams, Jr. of the United States District Court for the District of Maryland dismissed the case, reasoning that "the commencement of an internal investigation does not relieve prisoners from the [PLRA's] exhaustion requirement."[7]

Court of Appeals Decision

The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed.[4] It explained that the PLRA's "exhaustion requirement is not absolute."[8] Rather, there are certain "special circumstances" that can justify an inmate's failure to exhaust available administrative remedies.[8] One such circumstance, the Fourth Circuit panel held, was when an inmate failed to exhaust because he reasonably believed that he had already exhausted and no additional remedies were available.[8] And here, the court held that Blake was entitled to the "special circumstances" exception because he thought the IIU investigation precluded him from pursuing remedies through the regular ARP process.[9] Judge G. Steven Agee dissented, holding that judge-made exceptions to the PLRA's Congressionally-mandated exhaustion requirement were impermissible.[10]

Decision of the Court

Associate Justice Elena Kagan authored the majority opinion.[1] The Supreme Court vacated the judgment of the Fourth Circuit and remanded for the lower court to determine whether the ARP process was, in fact, “available” to Blake.[3]

The Court criticized the Fourth Circuit for making “no attempt to ground its analysis in the PLRA’s language.”[11] It agreed with Blake's characterization of the Fourth Circuit's rule as an “extra-textual exception to the PLRA’s exhaustion requirement.”[11] The PLRA's text, it held, “suggests no limits on an inmate’s obligation to exhaust – irrespective of any ‘special circumstances.’”[11] While the Court acknowledged that judges can craft exceptions to judge-made exhaustion requirements, it emphasized that statutory exhaustion requirements are different, and only Congress can create exceptions.[12] In this case, it explained, both Supreme Court precedent and the broader history of the PLRA supported the conclusion that Congress intended the exhaustion requirement to be mandatory.[13]

The Court noted, however, that its rejection of the “special circumstances” exception did not decide the case, because “the PLRA contains its own, textual exception to mandatory exhaustion.”[13] Inmates are required to exhaust only “such administrative remedies as are available.”[6] In other words, inmates must only exhaust remedies that are capable of use to obtain some relief.[14] The Court then outlined three situations in which an administrative remedy may be official policy, but yet is “not capable of use to obtain relief.” First, a remedy is unavailable when officers are consistently unable or unwilling to give inmates any sort of relief.[14] Second, a remedy is unavailable if it is “so opaque” that “no ordinary prisoner can discern or navigate it.”[14] Third, a remedy is unavailable if administrators “thwart inmates from taking advantage of a grievance process through machination, misrepresentation, or intimidation.”[15]

In this case, the Court noted, the facts suggested it was possible (but not certain) that the ARP was not “available” for Blake to exhaust.[16] While Maryland's Inmate Handbook provided that prisoners could use the ARP for all kinds of grievances, Blake maintained that “once the IIU commences such an inquiry, a prisoner cannot obtain relief through the standard ARP process – whatever the Handbook may say to the contrary.”[15] Because the materials the Court had seen concerning the operation of the IIU and ARP processes were “not conclusive,” it remanded for the lower courts to “perform a thorough review of such materials, and then address the legal issues [the Court] has highlighted concerning the availability of administrative remedies.”[17]

Concurrence of Justice Thomas

Justice Thomas concurred in part and in the judgment. He joined the Court's opinion, except for its discussion of the interaction of the ARP and IIU systems, which involved consideration of documents lodged with the Supreme Court, but never previously raised in the lower courts.[18] Justice Thomas opined that “[t]aking notice of the documents encourages gamesmanship and frustrates our review.”[18]

Concurrence of Justice Breyer

Justice Breyer concurred in part. Echoing his concurrence in Woodford v. Ngo, he wrote that the PLRA exhaustion requirement is subject to administrative law's “well-established exceptions” to exhaustion. While these do not include a “special circumstances” exception, other non-textual exceptions may apply.[19]

Implications

Ross v. Blake has been cited in nearly 2,000 cases as of March 2019.[20] While it is sometimes described as limiting access to courts for prisoners by abrogating the “special circumstances” exception, it is also often characterized as expanding prisoner recourse by clarifying that, in certain circumstances, administrative remedies may be on the books but yet practically “unavailable.” Though Ross has been discussed extensively by courts, it has received limited attention from scholars and news outlets.

Selected Supreme Court and Federal Courts of Appeals Cases

  • Fry v. Napoleon Cmty. Sch., 137 S. Ct. 743, 753 (2017) (citing Ross for the proposition that administrative relief is only available when it is "accessible or may be obtained," and applying this principle in the context of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act).
  • Williams v. Corr. Officer Priatno, 829 F.3d 118, 121 (2d Cir. 2016) (finding a prison grievance process unavailable in light of Ross, which "clarified the framework under which courts should assess whether a prisoner has complied with the PLRA exhaustion requirement").
  • Rinaldi v. United States, 904 F.3d 257, 267-70 (3d Cir. 2018) (applying Ross and holding that intimidation by prison officials thwarted appellant from using the grievance process, rendering it unavailable to him).
  • Ramirez v. Young, 906 F.3d 530, 538 (7th Cir. 2018) (holding that Ross’s three examples of when administrative remedies are unavailable were “not a closed list” and finding unavailability where the prison did not take reasonable steps to inform the inmate about his remedies).
  • Townsend v. Murphy, 898 F.3d 780, 783-84 (8th Cir. 2018) (applying Ross and finding a formal grievance procedure unavailable where an inmate was denied access to the prison library that contained the only copy of the administrative directive).
  • Fuqua v. Ryan, 890 F.3d 838, 849-50 (9th Cir. 2018) (concluding that a particular prison administrative remedy was so opaque as to be functionally unavailable based on the reasoning in Ross).

Selected Scholarship

  • Jacqueline Hayley Summs, Comment, Grappling with Inmates' Access to Justice: The Narrowing of the Exhaustion Requirement in Ross v. Blake, 69 ADMIN. L. REV. 467 (2017) (arguing that while “the immediate effect” of Ross may be “to create more obstacles” for inmates, “the larger significance of the case lies in the Court's decision to provide specific language to the PLRA's textual exception).
  • Nicola A. Cohen, Note, Why Ross v. Blake Opens a Door to Federal Courts for Incarcerated Adolescents, 51 COLUM. J.L. & SOC. PROBS. 177 (2017) (arguing that adolescents incarcerated in adult facilities face increased difficulty comprehending grievance processes, which should excuse their failure to exhaust in light of Ross).

Selected Treatises and Manuals

  • 4 ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND PRACTICE § 12:21 (3d ed., February 2019)
  • 15 AMERICAN JURISPRUDENCE CIVIL RIGHTS § 124 (2d ed., February 2019)
  • Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA): Procedural Basics, PRACTICAL LAW PRACTICE NOTE w-015-8501
  • 14A CORPUS JURIS SECUNDUM CIVIL RIGHTS § 350 (March 2019 update)

Selected News Articles and Blog Posts

See also

References

  1. ^ a b Ross v. Blake, No. 15-339, 578 U.S. ___, 136 S. Ct. 1850, 1857-58 (2016).
  2. ^ Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1859-60.
  3. ^ a b Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1862.
  4. ^ a b Blake v. Ross, 787 F.3d 693 (4th Cir. 2015).
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1855.
  6. ^ a b 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(a).
  7. ^ Blake v. Maynard, No. 8:2009cv02367, Doc. 110 (D. Md. Nov. 14, 2012), at 9.
  8. ^ a b c Blake, 787 F.3d at 698.
  9. ^ Blake, 787 F.3d at 700.
  10. ^ Blake, 787 F.3d at 703 (Agee, J., dissenting).
  11. ^ a b c Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1856.
  12. ^ Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1857.
  13. ^ a b Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1858.
  14. ^ a b c Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1859.
  15. ^ a b Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1860.
  16. ^ Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1860-61.
  17. ^ Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1861.
  18. ^ a b Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1862 (Thomas, J., concurring in part and concurring in the judgment).
  19. ^ Ross, 136 S. Ct. at 1862-63 (Breyer, J., concurring in part).
  20. ^ https://1.next.westlaw.com (citing references for Ross v. Blake).

Read other articles:

Armada NanyangPanji Angkatan Laut Kekaisaran TiongkokAktif1870s–1909Negara Dinasti QingAliansi Kaisar TiongkokCabangAngkatan Laut Kekaisaran TiongkokTipe unitAngkatan LautMarkasShanghaiPertempuranPerang Tiongkok-PerancisPerang Tiongkok-Jepang Pertama Armada Nanyang (Hanzi: 南洋水師; harfiah: 'divisi kelautan Nanyang') adalah salah satu dari empat armada Angkatan Laut Kekaisaran Tiongkok yang dimodernisasi pada akhir Dinasti Qing. Didirikan pada tahun 1870-an, armada ini men...

 

Ruta N.º 54 Uruguay Uruguay Ruta 54 km 7, acceso a Juan Lacaze. Datos de la rutaTipo Ruta nacionalLongitud 62.5 kmOtros datosDepartamentos ColoniaIntersecciones Ruta 1, Ruta 50, Ruta 106, Ruta 12.Orientación • sur Juan Lacaze(34°25′36.4″S 57°26′41.9″O / -34.426778, -57.444972) • norte Ruta 12 km 78.500(33°56′19.2″S 57°40′09.1″O / -33.938667, -57.669194)[editar datos en Wikidata] La ruta N.º 54 es una de las rutas n...

 

株式会社鮮ど市場Sendo Ichiba Co.,Ltd.種類 株式会社市場情報 非上場本社所在地 日本〒862-0913熊本県熊本市東区尾ノ上2丁目22番15号設立 1976年3月業種 小売業法人番号 5330001005027 代表者 田中弘文(代表取締役社長)資本金 4800万円売上高 126億円従業員数 693人主要子会社 関連会社の項目を参照関係する人物 田中敏弘(熊本ゴールデンラークス監督)外部リンク sendo.jpテンプレー

Gloria Estela La Riva Candidata a Presidente de los Estados Unidos en 2008 y 2016 Información personalNombre en inglés Gloria La Riva Nacimiento 13 de agosto de 1954 (69 años)Albuquerque, Nacionalidad EstadounidenseEducaciónEducada en Universidad Brandeis Información profesionalOcupación Política Partido político Partido Socialismo y LiberaciónPartido Paz y Libertad[editar datos en Wikidata] Gloria Estela La Riva (Albuquerque, Nuevo México, Estados Unidos, 13 de agost...

 

Private chiropractic college in Davenport, Iowa, United States Palmer College of ChiropracticFormer namesThe Palmer School and CureTypePrivateEstablished1897; 126 years ago (1897)[1]Endowment$58.8 million (2019)[2]ChancellorDennis M. Marchiori[3]LocationDavenport, Iowa, San Jose, California, Port Orange, Florida, United StatesWebsitewww.palmer.edu The first chiropractic school in the world in Davenport, Iowa Palmer College of Chiropractic is a pr...

 

The Relugas Compact was the plot hatched in 1905 by British Liberal Party politicians H. H. Asquith, Sir Edward Grey, and R. B. Haldane to force the prospective prime minister, Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman, to give up the leadership of the party in the House of Commons. The Compact is significant because it represents a new way of doing party political business at the highest level. In an era when aristocratic power was still taken for granted, the manoeuvring for the highest office in the la...

Momina KlisuraМомина клисураMesta River at Momina KlisuraMomina KlisuraLocation within BulgariaFloor elevation642 m (2,106 ft)Length25 kilometres (82,000 ft) north to southGeologyTypeGorgeGeographyLocationPirin and Rhodope Mountains, BulgariaCoordinates41°43′29″N 23°41′31″E / 41.72472°N 23.69194°E / 41.72472; 23.69194  Momina Klisura (Bulgarian: Момина клисура, meaning Maiden's Gorge) is a steep valley alon...

 

Overview of the geography of Sweden Geography of SwedenContinentEuropeRegionScandinaviaCoordinates62°00′N 15°00′E / 62.000°N 15.000°E / 62.000; 15.000AreaRanked 55th • Total450,295 km2 (173,860 sq mi) • Land91.31% • Water8.69%Coastline3,218 km (2,000 mi)BordersNorway 1,666 km (1,035 mi) = Finland 545 km (339 mi) = Denmark 118 km (73 mi) = Latvia 100 km (62 mi) =...

 

Magyar NemzetTipeKoran harianFormatBroadsheetPendiriSándor PethőDidirikan1938; 84 tahun lalu (1938)Pandangan politikKonservatifBahasaBahasa HungariaBerhenti publikasi2018Situs webwww.mno.hu Magyar Nemzet (dalam bahasa Hungaria berarti bangsa Hungaria) adalah koran harian yang diterbitkan di Hungaria. Koran berhaluan konservatif moderat ini didirikan pada tahun 1938 oleh Sándor Pethő.[1] Koran ini digabung dengan koran konservatif harian lainnya, Napi Magyarország, pada April...

الدبلوماسية العامة في إسرائيل أو هَسْبَرَة أو هاسبارا[1] ((بالعبرية: הַסְבָּרָה) «الشرح والتفسير») يشير إلى جهود العلاقات العامة لنشر المعلومات الإيجابية في الخارج أو الدعاية عن دولة إسرائيل وأفعالها.[2][3] هاسبارا هي كلمة عبرية تعني «الشرح» أو «التوضيح» وفي الح...

 

American comedy film This article's plot summary may be too long or excessively detailed. Please help improve it by removing unnecessary details and making it more concise. (June 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Half BrothersTheatrical release posterDirected byLuke GreenfieldScreenplay by Eduardo Cisneros Jason Shuman Story by Ali LeRoi Eduardo Cisneros Produced by Jason Shuman Eduardo Cisneros Luke Greenfield Jason Benoit Starring Luis Gerardo Méndez Connor Del Rio...

 

American model and media personality (born 1995) Kendall JennerJenner at the 2021 Met GalaBornKendall Nicole Jenner (1995-11-03) November 3, 1995 (age 28)Los Angeles, California, U.S.Occupations Model media personality socialite Years active2007–presentTelevision Keeping Up with the Kardashians The Kardashians Parents Caitlyn Jenner[a] Kris Jenner RelativesKardashian familyModeling informationHeight5 ft 11 in (1.80 m)[1]Hair colorBrown[2]Eye ...

2013 fantasy film directed by Peter Jackson The Hobbit:The Desolation of SmaugTheatrical release posterDirected byPeter JacksonScreenplay by Fran Walsh Philippa Boyens Peter Jackson Guillermo del Toro Based onThe Hobbitby J. R. R. TolkienProduced by Carolynne Cunningham Zane Weiner Fran Walsh Peter Jackson Starring Ian McKellen Martin Freeman Richard Armitage Benedict Cumberbatch Evangeline Lilly Lee Pace Luke Evans Ken Stott James Nesbitt Orlando Bloom CinematographyAndrew LesnieEdited byJab...

 

First constitution of the Federal People's Republic of Yugoslavia Act of promulgation of the Constitution of the Federal People's Republic of Yugoslavia (1946) The 1946 Yugoslav Constitution, officially titled as the Constitution of the Federal People's Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbian: Устав Федеративне Народне Републике Југославије; Croatian: Ustav Federativne Narodne Republike Jugoslavije), was the first constitution of the Federal People's Republi...

 

В статье не хватает ссылок на источники (см. рекомендации по поиску). Информация должна быть проверяема, иначе она может быть удалена. Вы можете отредактировать статью, добавив ссылки на авторитетные источники в виде сносок. (12 мая 2011) Апатито-нефелиновая руда (сахарный ап...

أهل الطرب النوع برنامج حواري فني إخراج علي الغول تقديم لارا طماش لغة العمل العربية عدد المواسم 2 الإنتاج منتج راديو وتلفزيون العرب القناة art الموسيقى بث لأول مرة في 1998 بث لآخر مرة في 2000 برامج متعلقة به رحلة حياة الفنان وصلات خارجية الموقع الرسمي http://www.artonline.tv تعديل مصدري - تع...

 

Jarvis Christian UniversityFormer namesJarvis Christian Institute[1] (1912–1929)Jarvis Christian College[2] (1929–2022)TypePrivate historically black collegeEstablished1912; 111 years ago (1912)Religious affiliationChristian Church (Disciples of Christ)PresidentGlenell M. Lee-PruittStudents800LocationHawkins, Texas, United States32°35′21″N 95°10′47″W / 32.589192°N 95.179823°W / 32.589192; -95.179823Campus1,000 acresColo...

 

1939 film by Jules White Three Sappy PeopleDirected byJules WhiteWritten byClyde BruckmanProduced byJules WhiteStarringMoe HowardLarry FineCurly HowardLorna GrayDon BeddoeBud JamisonAnn DoranRichard FiskeCinematographyGeorge MeehanEdited byCharles NelsonDistributed byColumbia PicturesRelease date December 1, 1939 (1939-12-01) (U.S.) Running time17:19[1]CountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglish Three Sappy People is a 1939 short subject directed by Jules White starring Ame...

Untuk perang oleh Pangeran Diponegoro, lihat Perang Jawa. Perang JawaLukisan Jawa abad ke-19 menggambarkan salah satu episode Perang Tionghoa, perang yang meletus di Jawa tahun 1741-1743Tanggalca.1 Februari 1741 hingga awal 1743LokasiJawa Tengah & Jawa TimurHasil Kemenangan BelandaPihak terlibat Pasukan gabungan Tionghoa dan Jawa Kesultanan Mataram (hingga 1741) Persekutuan Dagang Hindia Timur Kesultanan Mataram (sejak 1742) Tokoh dan pemimpin Singseh  (POW) Khe Pandjang Pakubuwono I...

 

1922 film Who Are My Parents?Still of the scene in Who Are My Parents? with L. Rogers Lytton and Peggy ShawDirected byJ. Searle DawleyWritten byPaul SloaneStory byJulien JosephsonStarringL. Rogers LyttonPeggy ShawFlorence BillingsErnest HilliardRobert AgnewCinematographyJoseph RuttenbergProductioncompanyFox Film CorporationDistributed byFox Film CorporationRelease date November 26, 1922 (1922-11-26) Running time9 reelsCountryUnited StatesLanguagesSilent film(English intertitles...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!