In 2019, while playing for the Western Lions, Teitzel represented Queensland Country at the Women's National Championships.[3]
In March 2020, Teitzel joined the North Queensland Gold Stars for their inaugural season, playing in their first game before the season was cancelled.[4] She later played for the Wests Panthers in the Holcim Cup.
In September 2021, Teitzel was named the BHP Premiership Player of the Year.[6]
On 3 December 2021, Teitzel signed with the Newcastle Knights to be a part of their inaugural NRLW squad.[7] In February 2022, she was announced as the on-field captain.[8]