Ohio v. EPA

Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency
Kinder Morgan, Inc. v. EPA
American Forest & Paper Association v. EPA
United States Steel Corporation v. EPA
Argued February 21, 2024
Decided June 27, 2024
Full case name
  • Ohio, et al. v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.
  • Kinder Morgan Inc., et al. v. EPA
  • American Forest & Paper Association, et al. v. EPA
  • United States Steel Corporation v. EPA, et al.
Docket nos.23A349
23A350
23A351
23A384
Citations603 U.S. 279 (more)
ArgumentOral argument
Questions presented
(1) Whether the court should stay the Environmental Protection Agency’s federal emission reductions rule, the Good Neighbor Plan; and (2) whether the emissions controls imposed by the rule are reasonable regardless of the number of states subject to the rule.
Holding
The applications for a stay are granted; enforcement of EPA’s rule against the applicants shall be stayed pending the disposition of the applicants’ petition for review in the D. C. Circuit and any petition for writ of certiorari, timely sought
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Roberts
Associate Justices
Clarence Thomas · Samuel Alito
Sonia Sotomayor · Elena Kagan
Neil Gorsuch · Brett Kavanaugh
Amy Coney Barrett · Ketanji Brown Jackson
Case opinions
MajorityGorsuch, joined by Roberts, Alito, Thomas, Kavanaugh
DissentBarrett, joined by Sotomayor, Kagan, Jackson
Laws applied
Clean Air Act

Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency, 603 U.S. 279 (2024), is a United States Supreme Court case regarding the Clean Air Act.

Background

The United States Clean Air Act is a law intended to reduce the impacts of air pollution. In the Clean Air Act, there is a section called the "Good Neighbor" provision, which mandates states to implement policies to reduce the impact of air pollution on other states, such as asthma or bronchitis.[1] In October 2015, the Environmental Protection Agency set new standard for reduction of ozone pollution.[1] This required states to submit State Implementation Plans (SIPs).[2] In 2022, the EPA announced that it would be denying 23 states' SIPs.[2] In response, the EPA proposed a Federal Implementation Plan that amended the National Ambient Air Quality Standards.[3] The EPA had a right to do this under the Clean Air Act. Three plaintiffs, collectively referred to as "Ohio," filed an emergency appeal to the Supreme Court.

Supreme Court

Ohio claimed that the EPA's federal implementation plan would put undue pressure on the U.S. electrical grid. The EPA argued that the plan contained important public benefits that if halted would cause delays in improving air quality that could be harmful. The EPA also argued that Ohio did not demonstrate any harm that would arise if the plan remained in effect while the legal proceedings continued. The Supreme Court did not put the EPA plan on hold while legal proceedings were underway. In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court decided that the EPA plan would be stayed pending petition for review and writ of certiorari.

Majority opinion

Neil Gorsuch delivered the opinion of the court, which John Roberts, Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas, and Brett Kavanaugh joined. They claimed that the EPA's methodology in their report was misreported and incorrect. They applied the Clean Air Act's section that allows a court to reverse a federal implementation plan if it is "arbitrary or capricious" and found in favor of Ohio.[4][5]

Dissent

Amy Coney Barrett delivered the dissent, joined by Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson. The dissent argued that the petition did not meet the criteria for emergency relief and that the case should be re-evaluated on its merits.[5]

References

  1. ^ a b "Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency." Oyez, www.oyez.org/cases/2023/23A349. Accessed 29 June 2024.
  2. ^ a b Jones, Bruce; Weymiller, Marcus (June 27, 2024). "Supreme Court Decides Ohio, et al. v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al". faegre drinker. Retrieved June 29, 2024.
  3. ^ Blum, Garry; Perrault, Griffin (June 29, 2024). "Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency". Cornell Law. Retrieved June 29, 2024.
  4. ^ "Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency". Ballotpedia. Retrieved 2024-06-29.
  5. ^ a b United States, U.S. Supreme Court (U.S.). Ohio v. Environmental Protection Agency. United States Reports, vol. 603, 27 June 2024. Supreme Court, www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23a349_0813.pdf. Accessed 29 June 2024.

Read other articles:

Jonas Bager[1]​ Bager en 2020Datos personalesNacimiento Hadsten, Dinamarca18 de julio de 1996 (27 años)Nacionalidad(es) DanesaAltura 1,82 m (6′ 0″)Carrera deportivaDeporte FútbolClub profesionalDebut deportivo 2015(Randers FC)Club Royal Charleroi S. C.Liga Primera División de BélgicaPosición DefensaGoles en clubes 4Trayectoria Randers FC (2015-2019) Royale Union Saint-Gilloise (2019-2022) Royal Charleroi S. C. (2022-presente)[editar datos en Wikidata] Jonas Valen...

 

Gereja Ortodoks Tritunggal Kudus, Pyongyang. Eparki Korea (bahasa Rusia: Корейская епархия, bahasa Korea: 대한교구) adalah sebuah eparki dari Eksarkat Patriarkat Asia Tenggara dari Gereja Ortodoks Rusia. Eparki tersebut melingkupi wilayah Korea Utara dan Korea Selatan.[1] Eparki tersebut didirikan oleh Sinode Kudus pada 26 Februari 2019. Ordinaris administatifnya mula-mula dijabat oleh Sergius (Chashin) dari 26 Februari 2019 sampai 4 April 2019. Pada 4 Apri...

 

Wade RobsonLahirWade Jeremy William Robson17 September 1982 (umur 41) Brisbane, AustraliaPekerjaanPenyanyi, Koreografer, sutradara, penulis laguSuami/istriAmanda Rodriguez (2005-sekarang)[1]Situs webhttp://www.waderobson.com Wade Jeremy William Robson (lahir 17 September 1982) adalah seorang koreografer pop, dan produser muda asal Australia. Ia bertinggi badan 188 cm yang sukses dalam acara MTV Wade Robson Project. Referensi ^ Aussies bolster Jackson's defence case. The Age....

Zona waktu di Afrika:  -01:00  Waktu Tanjung Verde[a]  ±00:00  Waktu Greenwich  +01:00  Waktu Eropa TengahWaktu Afrika Barat  +02:00  Waktu Afrika TengahWaktu Eropa TimurWaktu Standar MesirWaktu Standar Afrika Selatan  +03:00  Waktu Afrika Timur  +04:00  Waktu Mauritius[b]Waktu Seychelles[b] a Kepulauan Tanjung Verde terletak di sebelah barat daratan Afrika.b Mauritius dan Seychelles terletak masing-masing di sebelah timur dan timur...

 

Aceh SumatraUtara SumatraBarat Riau KepRiau Bengkulu Sumatera Selatan Lampung Kep. BangkaBelitung Jambi Banten Jakarta JawaBarat JawaTengah Yogyakarta JawaTimur KalimantanBarat KalimantanTengah KalimantanUtara KalimantanTimur KalimantanSelatan SulawesiBarat SulawesiTengah Gorontalo SulawesiUtara SulawesiSelatan SulawesiTenggara Bali Nusa TenggaraBarat Nusa TenggaraTimur MalukuUtara Maluku Papua PapuaBarat PapuaSelatan PapuaTengah PapuaPeg. Klik nama provinsi untuk langsung menuju ke bagian te...

 

Джорджо К'єлліні Джорджо К'єлліні Особисті дані Народження 14 серпня 1984(1984-08-14) (39 років)   Піза, Італія Зріст 187 см Вага 83 кг Громадянство  Італія Позиція правий захисник Інформація про клуб Поточний клуб «Лос-Анджелес» Номер 14 Юнацькі клуби «Ліворно» Професіональні...

City in Missouri, United StatesMilan, MissouriCityEast 2nd Street on the town square with the water tower beyondLocation of Milan, MissouriCoordinates: 40°12′12″N 93°07′28″W / 40.20333°N 93.12444°W / 40.20333; -93.12444[1]CountryUnited StatesStateMissouriCountySullivanArea[2] • Total1.78 sq mi (4.62 km2) • Land1.77 sq mi (4.59 km2) • Water0.01 sq mi (0.02 km2)El...

 

Hindu Magic Kapala used by mantrik A Mantrik or mantric is someone who specializes in practicing mantra.[1] In the Indian subcontinent, the word mantrik & similar names are synonymous with magician in different languages. Generally, a mantrik is supposed to derive his powers from the use of charms, mantras, spells and other methods. A Hindu mantrik is known to worship Kali and is often mentioned in the same breath as tantric, though there are subtle differences. A mantrik is one w...

 

1980 single by PrinceSexy DancerJapanese 7 singleSingle by Princefrom the album Prince B-side Bambi (UK) Why You Wanna Treat Me So Bad? (Japan) ReleasedApril 1980 (UK)May 1980 (Japan)RecordedApril 1979[1]StudioAlpha Studios, Burbank, CaliforniaGenreDiscoLength 7 album: 4:18 12: 8:50 LabelWarner Bros.Songwriter(s)PrinceProducer(s)PrincePrince singles chronology Why You Wanna Treat Me So Bad? (1980) Sexy Dancer (1980) Uptown (1980) Sexy Dancer is a song by Prince, released in the UK as ...

Charles Evans WhittakerHakim Mahkamah Agung Amerika SerikatMasa jabatan25 Maret 1957 – 31 Maret 1962 Informasi pribadiKebangsaanAmerika SerikatProfesiHakimSunting kotak info • L • B Charles Evans Whittaker adalah hakim Mahkamah Agung Amerika Serikat. Ia mulai menjabat sebagai hakim pada mahkamah tersebut pada tanggal 25 Maret 1957. Masa baktinya sebagai hakim berakhir pada tanggal 31 Maret 1962.[1] Referensi ^ Justices 1789 to Present. Washington, D.C.: Mahkam...

 

2015 remix album by Ariana GrandeThe RemixRemix album by Ariana GrandeReleasedMay 25, 2015Length57:48LabelRepublicAriana Grande chronology My Everything(2014) The Remix(2015) Christmas & Chill(2015) The Remix (stylized in all caps) is the debut remix album by American singer Ariana Grande. It features fifteen remixes of her singles from her first two studio albums: Yours Truly (2013) and My Everything (2014).[1] It was released exclusively in Japan on May 25, 2015 and peak...

 

Newspaper in Castlebar, Ireland The Connaught TelegraphTypeWeekly newspaperFormatCompactOwner(s)Celtic Media GroupEditorTom KellyFounded1828Political alignmentCentralHeadquartersCastlebarWebsiteConnaught Telegraph website The Connaught Telegraph is a weekly local newspaper published in Castlebar, County Mayo in Ireland. The paper is in compact format (six columns), and published every Tuesday. History Frederick Cavendish founded The Connaught Telegraph or Mayo Telegraph as it was originally n...

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Music for The Native Americans – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (September 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 1994 soundtrack album by Robbie RobertsonMusic for The Native AmericansSoundtrack album by Robbie Robertso...

 

Village in Inverclyde, Scotland Human settlement in ScotlandKilmacolmKilmacolm centre from the CrossKilmacolmLocation within InverclydePopulation3,930 (mid-2020 est.)[1]OS grid referenceNS365695• Edinburgh56 mi (90 km)• London355 mi (571 km)Community councilKilmacolm[2]Council areaInverclydeLieutenancy areaRenfrewshireCountryScotlandSovereign stateUnited KingdomPost townKILMACOLMPostcode districtPA13Dial...

 

Province of Thailand Province in ThailandChumphon ชุมพรProvinceMu Ko Chumphon National Park FlagSealMotto(s): ประตูภาคใต้ ไหว้เสด็จในกรมฯ ชมไร่กาแฟ แลหาดทรายรี ดีกล้วยเล็บมือ ขึ้นชื่อรังนก (Southern door, Worshiping in (Chumphon Khet Udomsak),See coffee plantations, See Sairee beach, Banana fingernail and Famous for bird's nest)Map of...

Fantasy tabletop wargame War of WizardsThe Game Of Fantastic Magical CombatBox coverDesignersM. A. R. BarkerPublishersTSR 1975Tita's House of Games 1999Publication1975; 48 years ago (1975)GenresFantasy board wargame War of Wizards is a board game published by TSR in 1975. It was TSR's first publication for M. A. R. Barker's world of Tékumel. Development David M. Ewalt, in his book Of Dice and Men, described how University of Minnesota professor M. A. R. Barker made his game...

 

An-148 / An-158 Antonov An-148 di bandara Le Bourget, Paris Air Show 2007 Jenis Pesawat Penumpang Regional Pembuat Kyiv “Aviant” State Aircraft Plant[1] (Ukraina), Voronezh Aircraft Production Association (Russia)[2] Perancang ASTC Antonov, Ukraina Penerbangan perdana 17 Desember 2004 Diperkenalkan 2 Juni 2009 Status masih diproduksi Pengguna utama Cubana de AviaciónSaratov Airlines Ukraine Air Enterprise Air Koryo Jumlah 42[3][4] Harga satuan US$ 20-...

 

Capital and largest city of Saudi Arabia Not to be confused with Arabic name Riyad or traditional Moroccan house, riad. For other uses, see Riyadh (disambiguation). City in Saudi ArabiaRiyadh الرياضCityTop to bottom, left to right: view of Al Olaya District; Deera Square; Masmak Fort; King Abdulaziz Historical Center; and King Abdullah Financial District SealLocation of Riyadh within Saudi ArabiaShow map of Saudi ArabiaRiyadh (Asia)Show map of AsiaRiyadh (Earth)Show map of EarthCoordina...

English comedian, producer, TV presenter and writer (born 1970) Richard OsmanOsman in June 2022BornRichard Thomas Osman (1970-11-28) 28 November 1970 (age 53)Billericay, Essex, EnglandEducationWarden Park SchoolAlma materTrinity College, CambridgeOccupationComedian • producer • television presenter • novelistYears active1993–presentKnown for Pointless Two Tribes Insert Name Here The Fake News Show Richard Osman's House of Games Height6 ft 7 in (2.01 ...

 

Parthenope University of NaplesUniversità degli Studi di Napoli ParthenopeTypePublicEstablished1930RectorAlberto CarotenutoStudents15,000LocationNaples, ItalySports teamsCUS NapoliWebsitewww.uniparthenope.it The Parthenope University of Naples (Italian: Università degli Studi di Napoli Parthenope) is one of the universities located in Naples, Italy. Historical notes Now one of the fully accredited universities of Naples, the “Parthenope” University was founded in 1920 as the Regio Istit...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!