Hugh McCulloch

This article is about the American statesman. For the American poet, see Hugh McCulloch (poet). For other meanings, see Hugh McCulloch (disambiguation).

Hugh McCulloch
27th and 36th United States Secretary of the Treasury
In office October 31, 1884 – March 7, 1885
President	Chester A. Arthur
Preceded by	Walter Q. Gresham
Succeeded by	Daniel Manning
In office March 9, 1865 – March 3, 1869
President	Abraham Lincoln Andrew Johnson
Preceded by	William P. Fessenden
Succeeded by	George S. Boutwell
Comptroller of the Currency
In office February 25, 1863 – March 9, 1865
President	Abraham Lincoln
Preceded by	Position established
Succeeded by	Freeman Clarke
Personal details
Born	(1808-12-07)December 7, 1808 Kennebunk, Maine, U.S.
Died	May 24, 1895(1895-05-24) (aged 86) Prince George's County, Maryland, U.S.
Political party	Republican
Residence	Hugh McCulloch House
Education	Bowdoin College
Signature

Hugh McCulloch (December 7, 1808 – May 24, 1895) was an American financier who played a central role in financing the American Civil War. He served two non-consecutive terms as U.S. Treasury Secretary under three presidents. He was originally opposed to the creation of a system of national banks, but his reputation as head of the Bank of Indiana from 1857 to 1863 persuaded the Treasury to bring him in to supervise the new system as Comptroller of the Currency 1863–1865. As Secretary of the Treasury 1865–1869 he reduced and funded the gigantic Civil War debt of the union, and reestablished the federal taxation system across the former Confederate States of America. He tried but failed to make a rapid return to the gold standard.

He was the last surviving member of the Lincoln Cabinet.

Biography

Early life

Born in Kennebunk, Maine, he was the son of Hugh McCulloch Sr., one of the largest shipbuilders in New England, and Abial Perkins. He was educated at Thornton Academy in Saco, Maine, and attended Bowdoin College for two years, leaving due to ill health.^[1] He taught school, then studied law in Boston, and in 1833 began practicing law at Fort Wayne, Indiana. He was cashier and manager of the Fort Wayne branch of the state chartered Bank of Indiana and president of the larger organization from 1835 to 1857, and president of its successor, the privately owned Bank of Indiana, from 1857 to 1863. Despite his early opposition to the National Banking Act of 1862, he was selected by Salmon P. Chase to be the first Comptroller of the Currency in 1863.^[2] During McCulloch's 22 months in office, 868 national banks were chartered and no failures occurred. As the first Comptroller, McCulloch recommended major changes in the banking law and the resulting National Banking Act of 1864 remains the foundation of the national banking system.^[3]

Bank of Indiana

McCulloch began his banking career as the President of the Bank of Indiana. In 1833 the bank was established in response to the closure of the Second Bank of the United States. Indiana was still a wilderness and no eastern bank was willing to take charge of the fledgling state bank. McCulloch was one of the few prominent businessmen in the young state, and although he had no banking experience, he was appointed because he was the most qualified person willing to take the position.

He ran the bank with great efficiency making it one of the most stable in the nation. He remained president until the bank was closed in 1859 and the bank's notes were exchanged for federal notes from the new national bank. He then went on to become president of the Second Bank of Indiana, where he remained until 1865.

Government career

Bureau of Engraving and Printing portrait of McCulloch as Secretary of the Treasury

A day or two after Lincoln's second inauguration, Abraham Lincoln convoked him in his office at the White House to have a talk with him, and was offered the position of Treasury Secretary, which he didn't expect and didn't want at first.^[4] On March 9, 1865, he was appointed as the 27th Secretary of the Treasury by President Abraham Lincoln.^[2] His appointment was largely due to his influence with existing state banks. McCulloch later remarked that on the morning of Lincoln's assassination, "I never saw Mr. Lincoln so cheerful and happy...The burden which had been weighing upon him for four long years, and which he had borne with heroic fortitude, had been lifted; the war had been practically ended; the Union was safe."^[2]

McCulloch was also with him on his death bed until his last moments.^[5] As he was about to leave the White House, Abraham Lincoln took him by the hand and said : "We must look to you, Mr. Secretary, for the money to pay off the soldiers", to which he replied: "I shall look to the people... they have not failed us thus far, and I don't think they will now".^[5] A few hours later, he saw the president becoming unconscious and saw him dying.^[5] The death bed scene was immortalized in number of paintings afterwards. He continued where it had been left by Mr. Lincoln, and served in the Presidential Cabinet of Andrew Johnson until the close of his administration in 1869.^[6]

Immediately confronted with inflation caused by the government's wartime issue of greenbacks, he recommended their retirement and a return to the gold standard.^[3] In McCulloch's first annual report, issued on December 4, 1865, he strongly urged the retirement of the legal tenders or greenbacks as a preliminary to the resumption of specie payments.^[7] However this would have reduced the supply of currency and was unpopular during the period of postwar reconstruction and westward expansion.

Hugh McCulloch

In accordance with this suggestion an act was passed, on March 12, 1866, authorizing the retirement of not more than $10,000,000 in six months and not more than $4,000,000 per month thereafter. This act met with strong opposition and was repealed on the February 4, 1868, after only $48,000,000 had been retired. The battle over its revival raged for the next fifty years. McCulloch was also disappointed by the decision of the United States Supreme Court upholding the constitutionality of the legal tenders.^[7]

During his tenure, McCulloch maintained a policy of reducing the federal war debt and the careful reintroduction of federal taxation in the South.

Soon after the close of his term of office McCulloch went to England, and spent six years (1870–1876) as a partner and member of the banking firm of Jay Cooke, McCulloch & Co.^[7] Their firm received from the Secretary of the Navy, George M. Robeson, the contract for the deposits made in London for the payment of naval officers abroad, with most partners being close friends of General Grant.^[8] His partner, Jay Cooke, was the chief financier of Lincoln's Union Army, and was the proprietor of America's premier banking house before his fall.^[9]

From October 1884 until the close of President Chester A. Arthur's term of office in March 1885, McCulloch again served as Secretary of the Treasury.^[7] During his six months in office at that time, he continued his fight for currency backed by gold, warning that the coinage of silver, used by then as backing for currency, should be halted.^[10]

After his death, McCulloch's portrait was used on several issues of $20 U.S. national bank notes (specifically the 1902 series).^[11]

$20 banknote with McCulloch's portrait on it, Friedberg #639

Reconstruction finance

Main article: Presidency of Andrew Johnson

The Civil War had been financed primarily by issuing short-term and long-term bonds and loans, plus inflation caused by printing paper money, plus new taxes. Wholesale prices had more than doubled, and reduction of inflation was a priority for Secretary McCulloch.^[12] A high priority, and by far the most controversial, was the currency question. The old paper currency issued by state banks had been withdrawn, and Confederate currency was worthless. The national banks had issued $207 million in currency, which was backed by gold and silver. The federal treasury had issued $428 million in greenbacks, which was legal tender but not backed by gold or silver. In addition about $275 million of coin was in circulation.

The new administration policy announced in October would be to make all the paper convertible into specie, if Congress so voted. The House of Representatives passed the Alley Resolution on December 18, 1865, by vote of 144 to 6. In the Senate it was a different matter, for the key player was Senator John Sherman, who said that inflation contraction was not nearly as important as refunding the short-term and long-term national debt. the war had been largely financed by national debt, in addition to taxation and inflation. The national debt stood at $2.8 billion. By October 1865, most of it in short term and temporary loans.^[13] Wall Street bankers typified by Jay Cooke believe that the economy was about to grow rapidly, thanks to the development of agriculture through the Homestead Act, the expansion of railroads, especially rebuilding the devastated Southern railroads and n opening the transcontinental line to the West Coast, and especially the flourishing of manufacturing during the war.

The goal premium over greenbacks was hundred and $145 in greenbacks to $100 in gold, and the optimists thought that they heavy demand for currency in an era of prosperity would return the ratio to 100.^[14] A compromise was reached in April 1866, that limited the treasury to a currency contraction of only $10 million over six months. Meanwhile, the Senate refunded the entire national debt, but the House failed to act. By early 1867, postwar prosperity was a reality, and the optimists wanted an end to contraction, which Congress ordered in January 1868. Meanwhile, the Treasury issued new bonds at a lower interest rate to refinance the redemption of short-term debt. while the old state bank notes were disappearing from circulation, new national bank notes, backed by species, were expanding. By 1868 inflation was minimal.^{[15][16][17][18]}

Personal

Death bed of Abraham Lincoln, April 15, 1865, Hugh McCulloch is at the end of the bed on the left, with Mary Todd Lincoln, Capt. Robert Todd Lincoln, Salmon P. Chase, surgeon Charles Leale, and others

McCulloch's first marriage, to Eunice Hardy, ended when she died young. His second marriage was to Susan Man, a schoolteacher, whom he met in Fort Wayne in 1836 when he was a young widower. Susan was the aunt of Albon P. Man, cofounder with William E. Sawyer of the Electro-Dynamic Light Company, competitors of Thomas Edison.^[19] Hugh McCulloch was an early investor in the company with James Powell Kernochan. The couple had six children. One of his daughters, Marie Louise, married to John B. Yale, son of Linus Yale Jr., and brother of Julian L. Yale, members of the Yale family.^[20]

He died at his home, Holly Hill in Prince George's County, Maryland, near Washington, D.C., in 1895 and is buried in Rock Creek Cemetery in D.C.^[1] His wife, Susan McCulloch, died at the residence of her son-in-law, John B. Yale, in 1898.^[21] Her great uncle was Naphtali Daggett, President of Yale College, and her family members included Gen. Moores, Gen. Melanchton Woolsey, Congressman and Senator Jonas Platt, and Alida Livingston, member of the Schuyler and Livingston family.^[22]

McCulloch was also a millionaire of 1892, and was featured in the book of American Millionaires of that year.^[23]

Legacy

Portraits of Hugh McCulloch, Cornelius Vanderbilt, John Adams Dix, Jay Cooke, Charles Francis Adams Sr., William H. Seward and Reverdy Johnson

According to economic historian Allan Peskin, McCulloch's career exemplifies the Western pioneer as banker, and also the banker as a Christian moralist. He was well-educated but had no business or banking experience. His honesty proved an essential asset in the age of rascality and dubious paper money. His greatest challenges came in building the brand-new national banking system during the war, and afterwards refinancing the enormous Union debt. The Confederate debt was repudiated and never repaid.

The biggest puzzle was dealing with $428 million in greenbacks, in an age where McCulloch like all orthodox economists, rejected paper money. His remedy was a rapid return to specie payment using gold and silver and retiring the greenbacks. This contraction policy removed money from circulation, lowered prices, wages and profits, and put heavy pressures on debtors. The Republican Party, however, backed McCulloch's program, and his years at Treasury were highly prosperous. He left the government in 1869 to become a very rich international financier.^[24]

McCulloch Hall, a residence hall at Harvard Business School, was named in his honor.

The U.S. Revenue Cutter Service and its successor, the U.S. Coast Guard, each named cutters after McCulloch. The Revenue Cutter USS McCulloch served under George Dewey in the Battle of Manila during the Spanish–American War, and Coast Guard Cutter McCulloch served in World War II and the Vietnam War.

The chief authority for the life of McCulloch is his own book, Men and Measures of Half a Century (New York, 1888).^[7] McCulloch was the last surviving member of the Lincoln Cabinet.

His house at Fort Wayne, the Hugh McCulloch House, was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980.^[25]

References

1. "Hugh M'Culloch Dead". The Sun. May 25, 1895. p. 3. Retrieved May 11, 2022 – via Newspapers.com.
2. "Hugh McCulloch (1808–1895)". Mr. Lincolns White House. Archived from the original on November 14, 2011. Retrieved May 18, 2012.
3. "Hugh McCulloch". Museum of American Finance. Retrieved May 18, 2012.
4. McCulloch, Hugh (1889). Men and measures of half a century; sketches and commments, New York, C. Scribner's son, Americana, p. 193
5. McCulloch, Hugh (1889). Men and measures of half a century; sketches and commments, New York, C. Scribner's son, Americana, p. 222
6. McCulloch, Hugh (1889). Men and measures of half a century; sketches and commments, New York, C. Scribner's son, Americana, p. 377
7. Chisholm 1911.
8. Adam Badeau, Grant in peace: from Appomattox to Mount McGregor, a personal memoir, Chapter XIII, Grant in the Cabinet.
9. 1873: Off The Rails, Harvard Business School, Historical Collections.
10. "Hugh McCulloch (1865–1865): Secretary of the Treasury". Miller Center Organization. Archived from the original on May 17, 2012. Retrieved May 18, 2012.
11. "Search: Fr. 639 [0 793 794 791 792 1893 1577 2088]".
12. Herbert S. Schell, "Hugh McCulloch and the Treasury Department, 1865–1869." Mississippi Valley Historical Review 17.3 (1930): 404–421. online
13. For an econometric approach see Lee E. Ohanian, The Macroeconomic Effects of War Finance in the United States: Taxes, Inflation, and Deficit Finance (Routledge, 2018).
14. Schell, 1930.
15. Margaret G. Myers, A financial history of the United States (Columbia UP, 1970), pp 174–96.
16. Paul Studenski, and Herman E. Kroos, Financial History of the United States (2nd ed. 1963).
17. Irwin Unger, The Greenback Era: A Social and Political History of American Finance 1865–1879 (Princeton UP, 1964).
18. Robert P. Sharkey, Money, Class, and Party: An Economic Study of Civil War and Reconstruction (Johns Hopkins Press, 1967).
19. Annual Reports and Charter, Constitution, Association of the Bar of the City of New York, Bar Association Building, New York, 1892.
20. "Yale genealogy and history of Wales. The British kings and princes. Life of Owen Glyndwr. Biographies of Governor Elihu Yale". Archive.org. Milburn and Scott company. 1908. p. 554.
21. Susan Maria McCulloch (born Man) in The Times - July 28, 1898, Chronicling America: Historic American Newspapers, 1791-1963
22. Memories-Recollections of Susan Man McCulloch 1818-1898
23. Tribune Associationn (1892). "American Millionaires: The Tribune's List of Persons Reputed to Worth a Million Or More. Lines of Business in which the Fortunes Were Made". p. 11.
24. Allan Peskin, "McCulloch, Hugh" in John A. Garraty, ed., Encyclopedia of American Biography (1974) pp 710–711.
25. "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. July 9, 2010.

Further reading

•  This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "McCulloch, Hugh". Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 17 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 207.
• Grable, Theodore Eli. Financial Policy of Hugh McCulloch (Indiana University, 1910) online.
• Reece, Raymond J. "Hugh McCulloch Moves West" Indiana Magazine of History, 32#2 (1936), pp. 95–105 online
• Schell, Herbert S. "Hugh McCulloch and the Treasury Department, 1865–1869" Mississippi Valley Historical Review (1930) 17#3: 404–421 DOI: 10.2307/1893078 online

External links

• Hugh McCulloch Biography
• The McCulloch mss

Political offices
Preceded by William P. Fessenden	U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Served under: Abraham Lincoln, Andrew Johnson 1865–1869	Succeeded by George S. Boutwell
Preceded by Walter Q. Gresham	U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Served under: Chester A. Arthur 1884–1885	Succeeded by Daniel Manning
Preceded by New office	Comptroller of the Currency 1863–1865	Succeeded by Freeman Clarke