As described in a film magazine review,[3] Henry Baxter is bashful and fails to get ahead in the world because people do not understand him. That is, all but Beulah Dyer, whom he loves blindly. His hard luck increases when a widowed sister-in-law and her two children descend upon his household. He works days at the office and nights doing clerical work for a druggist until his health fails him. Walter Higgins, his office boss, has stolen Henry's idea of boosting newspaper circulation by giving valor banquets to heroes. When Henry recovers from his illness, he is invited to one and finds that his struggles are appreciated as real heroism. When his home catches fire, and spurred on by the desire to be the other sort of hero, Henry thrusts aside the firemen and rescues the children himself.
^"New Pictures: How Baxter Butted In", Exhibitors Herald, 22 (4), Chicago, Illinois: Exhibitors Herald Company: 55, July 18, 1925, retrieved June 14, 2022 This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.