Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar

Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar
Argued March 25, 1975
Decided June 16, 1975
Full case nameGoldfarb et ux. v. Virginia State Bar et al
Citations421 U.S. 773 (more)
95 S. Ct. 2004; 44 L. Ed. 2d 572; 1975 U.S. LEXIS 13
Case history
PriorState bar held exempt from antitrust action, 355 F. Supp. 491 (E.D. Va. 1973), judgment reversed on appeal, 497 F.2d 1 (4th Cir. 1974); cert. granted, 419 U.S. 963 (1974).
Holding
The legal profession is subject to the Sherman Antitrust Act. A minimum-fee schedule for basic legal services is in restraint of trade and is illegal.
Court membership
Chief Justice
Warren E. Burger
Associate Justices
William O. Douglas · William J. Brennan Jr.
Potter Stewart · Byron White
Thurgood Marshall · Harry Blackmun
Lewis F. Powell Jr. · William Rehnquist
Case opinion
MajorityBurger, joined by Douglas, Brennan, Stewart, White, Marshall, Blackmun, Rehnquist
Powell took no part in the consideration or decision of the case.
Laws applied
Section I of the Sherman Act

Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar, 421 U.S. 773 (1975), was a U.S. Supreme Court decision. It stated that lawyers engage in "trade or commerce" and hence ended the legal profession's exemption from antitrust laws.[1]

Facts

In 1971, Ruth and Lewis Goldfarb decided to buy a house in Fairfax County, Virginia. To get a mortgage, they needed to perform a title search on the house, which can only be performed by a lawyer i.e. a member of the Virginia State Bar. Goldfarb contacted a lawyer, who quoted him a price suggested in a minimum-fee schedule published by the Fairfax County Bar Association, which was 1% of the property's value. Goldfarb attempted to find a cheaper quote. He sent 36 letters to other lawyers and received 19 responses, all declining to quote a fee lower than the minimum-fee schedule suggests. Some said that they did not know of any attorney who would do so. Unable to find a lower price, Goldfarb agreed to the 1% quote and subsequently sued both the State Bar and the County Bar alleging that the fee schedule amounted to price-fixing and a violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, seeking both injunctive relief and damages.[2]

The minimum-fee schedule was a list of prices, suggested by the county bar for various basic legal services, such as wills, marriage contracts, and title searches. The enforcement power lay in the hands of the State Bar, which was the administrative agency used by the Supreme Court of Virginia to regulate the legal profession. Without a license from the State Bar, no one can practice law in Virginia. The State Bar did not compel adherence to this fee schedule, but it had published several reports condoning the practice and had opined that habitual violation of the minimum-fee schedule suggests misconduct on the part of the lawyer.

Petitioners' arguments

The plaintiffs argued that the minimum-fee schedule created an artificial price floor for title searches in Fairfax County and that, in the absence of this fee schedule, they would have been able to procure a quote lower than the one listed in the schedule. They pointed to the history of Section 1, Sherman Act enforcement. In Addyston Pipe and Steel Company v. United States,[3] Judge Taft created the distinction between naked and ancillary restraints of trade, and the Virginia State Bar's restraints are naked. In United States v. Trenton Potteries,[4] the Supreme Court first established per se illegality of price-fixing because a reasonable price today may become unreasonable tomorrow and the courts cannot be expected to re-confirm every price. The reasonableness of the fees on the minimum-fee schedule is, then, immaterial. And finally, in United States v. Socony-Vacuum Oil Co, Inc.,[5] the Court proclaimed, in a famous footnote, that price-fixing need be neither intentional or feasible to be found per se illegal. Hence, the fact that the State Bar's power of compulsion was not absolute does not mean the fee schedule is legal.

Respondents' arguments

The defendants posed four separate arguments.

  1. The minimum-fee schedule is purely advisory and is only intended to provide information to members. No attorney is compelled to follow it. Furthermore, while membership in the State Bar is a prerequisite to practice law in Virginia, membership in the County Bar is voluntary, and hence, any guidelines, such as the fee schedule, adopted by a local bar association, are also voluntary.
  2. This was to be a transaction between a resident of Virginia and a lawyer residing in Virginia, influenced by his County Bar and the Virginia State Bar. Since interstate commerce is not affected, federal law in general and the Sherman Act in particular do not apply.
  3. Law is a "learned profession." Lawyers do not engage in trade and commerce and hence any restrictions on the pricing schemes they use are not restraints of trade, prohibited under the Sherman Act.
  4. Because the Virginia State Bar is licensed by the Virginia Supreme Court to regulate the profession in the state, policies promulgated by it and its subsidiaries are "state action" and are thus subject to the Parker v. Brown[6] state action exemption from federal antitrust law.

Judgment

The Supreme Court held that since prices were fixed, since price-fixing is per se illegal under the Sherman Act, and since no valid exemption from the Sherman Act could be shown, the minimum-fee schedule violates Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The Circuit Court judgment was reversed, and the case was remanded to District court to determine the proper remedy. The court rejected each defense attempted by the respondents as follows.

  1. It found the fee schedule to be effectively compulsory. The prospect of disciplinary action from the State Bar, regardless of whether the County Bar was a voluntary organization or had enforcement capabilities, was sufficient to dissuade all attorneys from quoting a price below the one listed on the schedule. The attorneys were furthermore assured that their competitors would not undercut them because they would face the same disciplinary action. This effectively created a price floor.
  2. The source of financing for the house, which was what originally required Goldfarb to seek a title search, would come from across state lines, making this a matter of interstate commerce.
  3. Lawyers provide services in exchange for money, and thus engage in commerce. There is nothing to suggest that the Sherman Act was meant to provide a sweeping exemption to an entire profession regardless of what other not-for-profit purposes the profession may have.
  4. While the operation of the Virginia State Bar was prescribed by state action i.e. authority granted by statute to the Virginia Supreme Court, the specific anticompetitive behavior in question—the minimum-fee schedule—was not directly authorized by the State acting as a sovereign. "It is not enough that, as the County Bar puts it, anticompetitive conduct is "prompted" by state action; rather, anticompetitive activities must be compelled by direction of the State acting as a sovereign."[7]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar, 421 U.S. 773 (1975).
  2. ^ "The Virginia Couple That Gave Birth to the Billable Hour". September 30, 2015.
  3. ^ Addyston Pipe and Steel Company v. United States, 85 F. 271 (6th Cir. 1898).
  4. ^ United States v. Trenton Potteries, 273 U.S. 392 (1927).
  5. ^ United States v. Socony-Vacuum Oil Co, Inc., 310 U.S. 150 (1940).
  6. ^ Parker v. Brown, 317 U.S. 341 (1943).
  7. ^ Breit, W; Elzinga, K. The Antitrust Casebook: Milestones in Antitrust Regulation, page 49. The Dryden Press, 1996.

References

  • Breit, W; Elzinga, K. The Antitrust Casebook: Milestones in Antitrust Regulation

Read other articles:

يانيك غيرهاردت (بالألمانية: Yannick Gerhardt)‏    معلومات شخصية الميلاد 13 مارس 1994 (العمر 29 سنة)فورسلن  الطول 1.84 م (6 قدم 1⁄2 بوصة) مركز اللعب وسط الجنسية ألمانيا  أخوة وأخوات آنا غيرهارد[1]  معلومات النادي النادي الحالي فولفسبورغ الرقم 31 مسيرة الشباب سنوات ف...

 

この記事の主題はウィキペディアにおける独立記事作成の目安を満たしていないおそれがあります。目安に適合することを証明するために、記事の主題についての信頼できる二次資料を求めています。なお、適合することが証明できない場合には、記事は統合されるか、リダイレクトに置き換えられるか、さもなくば削除される可能性があります。出典検索?: モンゴ...

 

Artikel ini adalah bagian dari seri:Politik Uni Soviet   Kepemimpinan Pemimpin Kepala Negara PresidenWakil Presiden Kepemimpinan bersama Dewan Negara Dewan Presidensial Partai Komunis Kongres Komite Pusat Sejarah Sekretaris Jenderal Politbiro Sekretariat Orgbiro Perwakilan Kongres Soviet(Komite Eksekutif Pusat) Majelis Agung Dewan Kesatuan Dewan Kebangsaan Presidium Kongres Perwakilan Rakyat Ketua Pemilu legislatif 1989 Pemerintahan Konstitusi Nama resmi 1924 1936 1977 Pemerintah Kemente...

2014 studio album by Wild BeastsPresent TenseStudio album by Wild BeastsReleased24 February 2014 (2014-02-24)RecordedKonk Studios in London and at The Distillery in Bath, SomersetGenreIndie rock, dream pop, synthpopLength40:55LabelDominoProducerLexxx, Leo Abrahams, Wild BeastsWild Beasts chronology Smother(2011) Present Tense(2014) Boy King(2016) Singles from Present Tense WanderlustReleased: 24 February 2014 A Simple Beautiful TruthReleased: 19 May 2014 MeccaReleased: ...

 

Die häufigste Form der Systemkamera ist die digitale Spiegelreflexkamera, im Bild links oben eine Nikon. Die vier Wechselobjektive rechts übereinander sind Zoom-Teleobjektive, das kleine Objektiv rechts unter der Kamera ist ein 35-mm-Weitwinkelobjektiv. Ein Blitzgerät (oben mittig) desselben Herstellers stammt ebenfalls aus dem System. Eine Systemkamera ist ein Fotoapparat mit austauschbaren Komponenten innerhalb eines voll kompatiblen Kamerasystems. Die wichtigsten Komponenten eines solch...

 

Hệ tọa độ chân trời sử dụng một thiên cầu lấy tâm là người quan sát. Góc phương vị được đo từ điểm bắc (nhưng đôi khi từ điểm nam) và thuận theo hướng đông ở trên đường chân trời; góc cao là góc thẳng đứng so với đường chân trời Hệ tọa độ chân trời là một hệ tọa độ thiên thể sử dụng mặt phẳng chân trời địa phương của người quan sát làm mặt phẳng cơ bản (m...

Avenida 16 de Septiembre Centro Histórico de la Ciudad de México México Vista de la calle 16 de septiembre desde el Antiguo Palacio del AyuntamientoDatos de la rutaNombre anterior TlapalerosColiseo ViejoDel RefugioAvenida IndependenciaTipo AvenidaInauguración 1846 (como Avenida Independencia)Ancho 7.5 m (aprox.)Longitud 701 m (aprox.)OrientaciónInicio Plaza de la ConstituciónFin Eje Central Lázaro CárdenasCruces PalmaIsabel La CatólicaMotoliníaBolívarGante[editar datos en Wiki...

 

Duta Besar Amerika Serikat untuk GabonSegel Kementerian Dalam Negeri Amerika SerikatDicalonkan olehPresiden Amerika SerikatDitunjuk olehPresidendengan nasehat Senat Berikut ini adalah daftar Duta Besar Amerika Serikat untuk Gabon Daftar W. Wendell Blancke Charles F. Darlington David M. Bane Richard Funkhouser John A. McKesson, III Andrew L. Steigman Arthur T. Tienken Francis Terry McNamara Larry C. Williamson Warren Clark, Jr. Keith Leveret Wauchope Joseph Charles Wilson IV Elizabeth Raspolic...

 

يفتقر محتوى هذه المقالة إلى الاستشهاد بمصادر. فضلاً، ساهم في تطوير هذه المقالة من خلال إضافة مصادر موثوق بها. أي معلومات غير موثقة يمكن التشكيك بها وإزالتها. (نوفمبر 2019) دوري كرة القدم الإسكتلندي الدرجة الثانية 1968–69 تفاصيل الموسم دوري كرة القدم الاسكتلندي الدرجة الثانية...

Innernzell Pemandangan Innernzell Lambang kebesaranLetak Innernzell NegaraJermanNegara bagianBayernWilayahNiederbayernKreisFreyung-GrafenauMunicipal assoc.SchönbergPemerintahan • MayorJosef Kern (CSU)Luas • Total22,13 km2 (854 sq mi)Ketinggian636 m (2,087 ft)Populasi (2013-12-31)[1] • Total1.573 • Kepadatan0,71/km2 (1,8/sq mi)Zona waktuWET/WMPET (UTC+1/+2)Kode pos94548Kode area telepon08554Pelat kendar...

 

Resolusi 1643Dewan Keamanan PBBPantai di Dagbego, Pantai GadingTanggal15 Desember 2005Sidang no.5.327KodeS/RES/1643 (Dokumen)TopikSituasi di Pantai GadingRingkasan hasil15 mendukungTidak ada menentangTidak ada abstainHasilDiadopsiKomposisi Dewan KeamananAnggota tetap Tiongkok Prancis Rusia Britania Raya Amerika SerikatAnggota tidak tetap Aljazair Argentina Benin Brasil Denmark Filipina Jepang Rumania Tanzania ...

 

Страница из «Летописецул цэрий Молдовей…» Летопись Земли Молдавской (Летописи Земли Молдавской отколь образовалось государство, о течении годов и о жизни господарей, повествующей от Драгоша-воеводы до Арона-воеводы[1]; молд. Летописецул Цэрый Молдовей, де кынд с-ау ...

Limburgish language dialect Not to be confused with Maastrichtian Dutch or a Maastrichtian accent, the accent/regional variety of Standard Dutch spoken in Maastricht. For other uses, see Maastrichtian (disambiguation). MaastrichtianMestreechs (sometimes Mestreechs-Limbörgs or colloquially Dialek, Plat)Pronunciation[məˈstʀeːxs]Native tothe NetherlandsRegionCity of MaastrichtNative speakers(undated figure of 60,000[citation needed])Language familyIndo-European Germanic...

 

Gates of the Grove (Shaarey Pardes), the sanctuary of the Jewish Center of the Hamptons, is a synagogue designed by noted architect Norman Jaffe and built in East Hampton, New York in 1989.[1] It has been called a masterpiece.[2] The cedar shingled synagogue won the Interfaith Forum on Religion, Art, and Architecture excellence in design award.[citation needed] Jaffe called on Kabbalistic symbolism, the famed light of the Hamptons, and local vernacular traditions to cr...

 

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (يونيو 2019) ديك كوغان معلومات شخصية الميلاد 5 ديسمبر 1871  باترسون  الوفاة 2 مايو 1948 (76 سنة)   باترسون  مكان الدفن نيوجيرسي  مواطنة الولايات المتحدة  الحياة ال...

Aspect of history West coast of North America The human history of the west coast of North America[1] is believed to stretch back to the arrival of the earliest people over the Bering Strait, or alternately along a now-submerged coastal plain, through the development of significant pre-Columbian cultures and population densities, to the arrival of the European explorers and colonizers. The west coast of North America today is home to some of the largest and most important companies in...

 

Zie Hoogte (doorverwijspagina) voor andere betekenissen van Hoogte. Waterhoogtebepaling in Woerden Hoogte is de verticale positie ten opzichte van een referentiepunt of horizontaal referentievlak. Een andere betekenis is de verticale afmeting van een object. Hoogtebepaling De hoogte van een voorwerp kan in veel gevallen bepaald worden met een meetlint. De hoogte van een groter object, bijvoorbeeld van een kerktoren, kan bepaald worden met behulp van een driehoeksmeting. De hoogte van de bodem...

 

Svenska cupenSport(er)fotbollLand SverigeTidpunkthöst–vår (över årsskiftet)År1981– (damer)Tidigare namnFolksam CupGeografisk omfattningSverigeArrangörSvenska FotbollförbundetRegerande mästareHammarby IF (2022/2023)Flest titlarÖxabäcks IFFC Rosengård(6 titlar vardera)WebbplatsSvenska cupen Svenska cupen 2023/2024 Svenska cupen i fotboll för damer (marknadsfört som Svenska Cupen damer[1]) är en årlig cupturnering i fotboll. Den är öppen för klubblag inom damfotboll i ...

Spanish breed of horse You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Spanish. (September 2015) Click [show] for important translation instructions. View a machine-translated version of the Spanish article. Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as necessary and confirm that the translation is accurate, rather than simply copy-pasting machine-translated t...

 

Stockholms Konserthus 2017 Das Konserthuset ist ein am Hötorget gelegenes Stockholmer Konzerthaus. Es wurde zwischen 1924 und 1926 nach den Plänen von Ivar Tengbom gebaut und zählt zu den wichtigsten Gebäuden des Klassizismus in Schweden. Die für das Bauwerk charakteristischen grauen Granitsäulen stammen aus Steinbrüchen bei Vånevik. Die Säulen sind in Richtung Hötorget ausgerichtet anstatt zum heutigen Sveavägen, da diese Straße zum Zeitpunkt der Erbauung an der Kungsgatan abschl...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!