Everson v. Board of Education

Everson v. Board of Education
Argued November 20, 1946
Decided February 10, 1947
Full case nameArch R. Everson v Board of Education of the Township of Ewing, et al.
Citations330 U.S. 1 (more)
67 S. Ct. 504; 91 L. Ed. 711; 1947 U.S. LEXIS 2959; 168 A.L.R. 1392
Case history
PriorEverson sued as a school district taxpayer, judgment for plaintiff, 132 N.J.L. 98, 39 A.2d 75; New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals reversed, 133 N.J.L. 350, 44 A.2d 333, cert. granted.
SubsequentRehearing denied, 330 U.S. 855 (1947).
Holding
(1) The Establishment Clause of the First Amendment is incorporated against the states through the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. (2) New Jersey law providing public payment of the costs of transportation to and from parochial Catholic schools is not in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Court membership
Chief Justice
Fred M. Vinson
Associate Justices
Hugo Black · Stanley F. Reed
Felix Frankfurter · William O. Douglas
Frank Murphy · Robert H. Jackson
Wiley B. Rutledge · Harold H. Burton
Case opinions
MajorityBlack, joined by Vinson, Reed, Douglas, Murphy
DissentJackson, joined by Frankfurter
DissentRutledge, joined by Frankfurter, Jackson, Burton
Laws applied
U.S. Const. amends. I, XIV

Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1 (1947), was a landmark decision of the United States Supreme Court that applied the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to state law.[1] Before this decision, the clause, which states, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion",[2] restricted only the federal government, while many states continued to grant certain religious denominations legislative or effective privileges.[3]

It was the first Supreme Court case incorporating the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment as binding upon the states through the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

A New Jersey taxpayer brought the case against a tax-funded school district that provided reimbursement to parents of both public and private school students who took public transportation to school. The taxpayer contended that reimbursement for children attending private religious schools violated the constitutional prohibition against state support of religion, and the use of taxpayer funds to do so violated the Due Process Clause. The Justices were split over the question whether the New Jersey policy constituted support of religion, with the majority concluding that the reimbursements were "separate and so indisputably marked off from the religious function" that they did not violate the constitution. Both affirming and dissenting Justices, however, agreed that the Constitution required a sharp separation between government and religion, and their strongly-worded opinions paved the way to a series of later court decisions that collectively brought about profound changes in legislation, public education, and other policies involving matters of religion.[3] Both Justice Hugo Black's majority opinion and Justice Wiley Rutledge's dissenting opinion defined the First Amendment religious clause in terms of a "wall of separation between church and state."

Background

After repealing a former ban, a 1941 New Jersey law authorized payment by local school boards of the costs of transportation to and from schools, including private schools, most of which were parochial Catholic schools.[4]

Arch R. Everson, a taxpayer in Ewing Township, filed a lawsuit on state constitutional grounds.[5] The Establishment Clause was not yet incorporated when the lawsuit was filed.

The New Jersey Supreme Court held that the provision violated the state constitution's purpose restriction on the legislative power to authorize spending for private and parochial schools.[6][a] After this decision was reversed by the New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals, then the state's highest court, Everson appealed to the US Supreme Court which decided the case on federal grounds only.[7][b]

Supreme Court

The Supreme Court handed down its 5–4 decision upholding the state law on February 10, 1947. The decision was the first to hold that the Establishment Clause was applicable against the states. It is also remembered as the first Supreme Court case to attempt an explanation of the Establishment Clause.[4] They held that the New Jersey law providing reimbursement to transportation to all students was not a violation of the establishment clause.[8]

Majority opinion

In a majority opinion by Justice Hugo Black, the Supreme Court ruled that the state bill was constitutionally permissible because the law had a "public purpose" to provide safe transportation to parochial school students.[9]

The Court's interpretation of the Establishment Clause was broad and would guide the Court's jurisprudence for decades to come. Arthur E. Sutherland Jr. called it "the most influential single announcement of the American law of church and state".[10] Black's language was sweeping:

The 'establishment of religion' clause of the First Amendment means at least this: Neither a state nor the Federal Government can set up a church. Neither can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions or prefer one religion over another. Neither can force nor influence a person to go to or to remain away from church against his will or force him to profess a belief or disbelief in any religion. No person can be punished for entertaining or professing religious beliefs or disbeliefs, for church attendance or non-attendance. No tax in any amount, large or small, can be levied to support any religious activities or institutions, whatever they may be called, or whatever form they may adopt to teach or practice religion. Neither a state nor the Federal Government can, openly or secretly, participate in the affairs of any religious organizations or groups and vice versa. In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect "'a wall of separation between Church and State."

This highly influential dictum was supported only by a historical analysis based on James Madison's Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments and Thomas Jefferson's Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom.[11]

Dissents

Justice Jackson wrote a dissenting opinion which Justice Frankfurter joined. Justice Rutledge wrote another dissenting opinion which Justices Frankfurter, Jackson, and Burton joined. The four dissenters agreed with Justice Black's definition of the Establishment Clause but protested that the principles that he laid down would logically lead to the invalidation of the challenged law:[12]

The great condition of religious liberty is that it be maintained free from sustenance, as also from other interferences, by the state. For when it comes to rest upon that secular foundation it vanishes with the resting.

"Wall of separation": No aid to religion

Everson confirmed that the Supreme Court would interpret the Establishment Clause to protect against more than the establishment of a state church. The "wall of separation" was a principle of the founding age that prohibited any government aid to religion. The Establishment Clause would not allow any public spending "to support any religious activities, or institutions whatever they may be called, or whatever form they may adopt to teach or practice religion".[13]

"Public purpose": Indirect benefit

Everson upheld the constitutionality of reimbursing the students transportation costs because the program had a public welfare purpose. The Court said that public funds could not be used "to teach or practice religion."[14] Citing Cochran v. Louisiana State Board of Education, Justice Black wrote that it was "too late to argue that legislation intended to facilitate the opportunity of children to get a secular education serves no public purpose".[8]

An "indirect benefit" to parochial schools did not make a statute with a legitimate secular purpose unconstitutional.[11][15] The divided opinion laid the groundwork for the Lemon test which would add the primary effect and excessive entanglement criteria. [16]

Legacy

Everson's holding incorporating the Establishment Clause was controversial and more cases followed.[17] A few months later the Court reaffirmed this holding in the first released time case McCollum v. Board of Education.[11][18] The court continued to hear cases about religion in public schools in cases like Abington v. Schempp which banned daily bible readings in public school. The American public was divided and some viewed the cases as heralding the secularization of public life in the United States.[19]

Having invoked Jefferson's metaphor of the wall of separation in the Everson decision, lawmakers and courts have struggled how to balance governments' dual duty to satisfy the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses of the First Amendment. The majority and dissenting Justices in Everson split over the question, with Rutledge in the minority by insisting that the Constitution forbids "every form of public aid or support for religion."[20]

Writing for the majority in McCollum, Justice Black defended the Everson holding and the "wall of separation" dictum. The four Justices who dissented in Everson—Justices Harold H. Burton, Felix Frankfurter, Robert H. Jackson, Wiley Rutledge— were reluctant to endorse the McCollum ruling. The Court's historical argument was reaffirmed in subsequent cases including Abington School District v. Schempp, Engel v. Vitale and McGowan v. Maryland.[11]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ The NJ Supreme Court held the spending authorization for transportation reimbursement to parents violated Article 4 §7 ¶6 of the state constitution, which reads: "The fund for the support of free schools[...]shall be annually appropriated to the support of public free schools, for the equal benefit of all the people of the state; and it shall not be competent for the legislature to borrow, appropriate or use the said fund, or any part thereof, for any other purpose, under any pretense whatever."132 N.J.L. 98. 39 A.2d 75
  2. ^ Since there has been no attack on the statute on the ground that a part of its language excludes children attending private schools operated for profit from enjoying state payment for their transportation[...]we put to one side the question as to the validity of the statute against the claim that it does not authorize payment for the transportation generally of school children in New Jersey. The only contention here is that the State statute and the resolution, insofar as they authorized reimbursement to parents of children attending parochial schools, violate the Federal Constition 330 US 1, 4, 5

References

  1. ^ Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1 (1947). Public domain This article incorporates public domain material from this U.S government document.
  2. ^ in the United States Bill of Rights
  3. ^ a b Schultz 1999, p. 78
  4. ^ a b Finkelman 2013, p. 255
  5. ^ Ivers 1995, p. 18
  6. ^ Ivers 1995, p. 19
  7. ^ "Everson v. Board of Education of the Township of Ewing". Oyez. Retrieved March 18, 2024.
  8. ^ a b Ivers 1995, p. 23
  9. ^ Kauper 1968, p. 270
  10. ^ Arthur E. Sutherland Jr. "Establishment According to Engel," 76 Harvard Law Review 25 (November 1962): 25-52
  11. ^ a b c d Alito, Samuel A. (1974). "The Released Time Cases Revisited: A Study of Group Decisionmaking by the Supreme Court". The Yale Law Journal. 83. Retrieved March 12, 2024.
  12. ^ Pollak, Louis. "W.B.R.: Some Reflections" (PDF). The Yale Law Journal: 1456.
  13. ^ Kauper 1968, p. 270
  14. ^ Kauper 1968, p. 270-71
  15. ^ Ivers 1995, p. 23
  16. ^ Maltz 2000, p. 169
  17. ^ Larson, Edward John (2003). Trial and error: the American controversy over creation and evolution (3, revised ed.). Oxford University Press US. ISBN 9780195154702.
  18. ^ Wiecek, William M. (January 23, 2006). The History of the Supreme Court of the United States. Cambridge University Press. pp. 258–263. ISBN 9780521848206.
  19. ^ Tushnet, Mark V.; Graber, Mark Aaron; Levinson, Sanford (2015). The Oxford handbook of the U.S. Constitution. Oxford university press. ISBN 978-0-19-024575-7.
  20. ^ McWhirter 1994, p. 37

Sources

Read other articles:

American architect Chloethiel Woodard SmithChloethiel Woodard Smith discussing her Harbour Square project, c. 1960Born1910Peoria, Illinois, U.S.Died(1992-12-30)December 30, 1992Washington, D.C., U.S.NationalityAmericanAlma materUniversity of OregonOccupationArchitectProjectsReston, Virginia Chloethiel Woodard Smith, FAIA (February 2, 1910 – December 30, 1992) was an American modernist architect and urban planner whose career was centered in Washington, D.C. She was the sixth woman ...

 

Overview of railways in Plymouth, Devon, England 153380 in Devon and Cornwall Rail Partnership livery pulls away from Dockyard railway station vteRailways in the Plymouth area Legend Reading–Plymouth line Plympton (GWR) South Devon and Tavistock Railway Plymouth and Dartmoor Railway  A38  Laira Junction Laira TMDLaira  LSWR Turnchapel Branch and GWR Plymouth to Yealmpton Branch  Cattewater and Sutton Harbour Plymouth Friary (LSWR) Mutley (...

 

German football coach and former player (born 1965) Michael Oenning Oenning with Vasas in 2017Personal informationDate of birth (1965-09-27) 27 September 1965 (age 58)Place of birth Coesfeld, West GermanyPosition(s) MidfielderYouth career Eintracht CoesfeldSenior career*Years Team Apps (Gls) Eintracht Coesfeld SV Wilmsberg Preußen Münster 1990–1991 Hammer SpVg 1991–1994 TSG Dülmen SC Pfullendorf Managerial career2008–2009 1. FC Nürnberg2011 Hamburger SV2016–2018 Vasas SC2018...

Egino IV. Graf von Urach, genannt „Der Bärtige“ Egino IV. (* um 1160 in Urach; † 12. Januar 1230 in Tennenbach), Graf von Urach, genannt „Der Bärtige“, erbte nach dem Aussterben der Zähringer deren rechtsrheinische Besitzungen. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben 2 Ehe und Nachkommen 3 Literatur 4 Einzelnachweise Leben Egino IV. heiratete die Tochter Herzog Bertolds IV. Agnes von Zähringen. Mit dem Tode Bertolds V. am 18. Februar 1218 fiel das rechtsrheinische Hausgut der Zähringer im B...

 

Isaac de Moucheron Portret van Isaac de Moucheron (linksonder) in Jan van Gool's Nieuw Schouburg der Nederlandsche Konst Schilders en Schilderessen, 1750 Persoonsgegevens Bijnaam Ordenantie Geboren Amsterdam, 23 november 1667 Overleden Amsterdam, 20 juli 1744 Geboorteland Nederland Beroep(en) kunstschilder Oriënterende gegevens Leermeester Frederik de Moucheron RKD-profiel Portaal    Kunst & Cultuur Rugged river landscape with a nymph surprised by a satyr Isaac de Moucheron (Am...

 

Рамон Пуерта ісп. Ramón Puerta Рамон ПуертаПрезидент Аргентини (тимчасовий) 20 — 23 грудня 2001Попередник Фернандо де ла РуаНаступник Адольфо Родрігес СааСенатор 10 грудня 2001 — 10 грудня 2005Губернатор провінції Місьйонес 10 грудня 1991 — 10 грудня 1999Попередник Хуліо С...

1987 live album by Henry RollinsBig Ugly MouthLive album by Henry RollinsReleased1987Recorded1987 in Madison, WI, Chicago, IL, Minneapolis, MN, Denver, CO, Los Angeles, CA and New Brunswick, NJGenreSpoken WordComedyLength70:38Label2.13.61 (Reissue)Quarterstick RecordsHenry Rollins chronology Short Walk On A Long Pier(1985) Big Ugly Mouth(1987) Sweatbox(1989) Professional ratingsReview scoresSourceRatingAllmusic link Big Ugly Mouth is the second live spoken word album by Henry Rollins,...

 

European Union treaty on internal border controls For the current rules, policy and list of member countries, see Schengen Area. This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (January 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Swedish. (August 2021) C...

 

2022 in music By location Africa Asia Canada China United Kingdom Japan Philippines South Korea United States By genre classical country heavy metal hip hop jazz Latin rock By topic List of albums released Overview of the events of 2022 in Philippine music List of years in Philippine music … 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 … Art Archaeology Architecture Literature Music Philosophy Science +... The following is a list...

3rd edition of the Pan American Games III Pan American GamesPoster of the 1959 Pan American Games.HostChicago, United StatesNations25Athletes2,263Events166 in 18 sportsOpeningAugust 27ClosingSeptember 7Opened byMilton S. Eisenhower[1]Main venueSoldier Field← 1955 Mexico City1963 São Paulo → The 1959 Pan American Games were held in Chicago, Illinois, United States between August 28 and September 7, 1959. Host city selection Main article: Bids for the 1959 Pan Ame...

 

2001 single by Björk This article's lead section may be too short to adequately summarize the key points. Please consider expanding the lead to provide an accessible overview of all important aspects of the article. (September 2020) Hidden PlaceSingle by Björkfrom the album Vespertine B-side Verandi Mother Heroic Generous Palmstroke Foot Soldier Released30 July 2001 (2001-07-30)Recorded2000Genre Ambient glitch pop trip hop electronica[1] Length 4:28 (video version) 5:...

 

American politician William J. FoleyDistrict Attorney of Suffolk County, MassachusettsIn office1927–1952Preceded byThomas C. O'BrienSucceeded byGarrett H. Byrne Personal detailsBornMarch 2, 1887South BostonDiedDecember 1, 1952 (aged 65)BostonNationalityAmericanPolitical partyDemocraticRelationsWilliam J. Foley Jr. (son)Alma materBoston University School of Law William J. Foley (March 2, 1887 – December 1, 1952) was an American attorney and politician who served as District Attorney of Suf...

Стандартна клавіатура «Мультимедійна» клавіатура Фрагмент фортепіанної клавіатури Клавіату́ра (англ. keyboard) — сукупність розміщених у певному порядку клавіш пристрою, що використовується для введення і редагування даних, а також керування виконанням окремих операц...

 

Cet article est une ébauche concernant une église ou une cathédrale. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Cette cathédrale n’est pas la seule cathédrale Saint-Sauveur. Cathédrale Saint-Sauveur La cathédrale vue depuis le beffroi de Bruges. Présentation Nom local Sint Salvatorskathedraal Culte catholique Type Église Cathédrale Rattachement Diocèse de Bruges Début de la construction Xe ...

 

Russian artist (born 1979) Anna ParkinaBorn1979MoscowNationalityRussianEducationUniversity of Paris VIIIÉcole nationale supérieure des Beaux-Arts Anna Parkina (born 1979) is a Russian artist who lives and works in Moscow. She uses collage as her key artistic method but also works in a variety of media, including performance, sculpture and video. Education Parkina graduated from the University of Paris VIII in 2002 and was an intern at the Art Center College of Design in Pasadena, California...

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for music. Please help to demonstrate the notability of the topic by citing reliable secondary sources that are independent of the topic and provide significant coverage of it beyond a mere trivial mention. If notability cannot be shown, the article is likely to be merge...

 

Chilean football manager In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is Núñez and the second or maternal family name is Rojas. Sebastián Núñez Personal informationFull name Sebastián Emilio Núñez RojasDate of birth (1982-03-13) 13 March 1982 (age 41)Place of birth Concón, ChileManagerial careerYears Team2008–2013 Santiago Wanderers (youth)2014 Huehueteco [es] (assistant)2015 Deportivo Xinabajul (assistant)2016 Santiago Wanderers (youth)2018 FATIC20...

 

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Always Outnumbered – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (April 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) American TV series or program Always OutnumberedAlso known asAlways Outnumbered, Always OutgunnedGenreDramaBased onAlways Out...

2002 filmHeavenTheatrical release posterDirected byTom TykwerWritten by Krzysztof Kieślowski Krzysztof Piesiewicz Produced by Stefan Arndt Frédérique Dumas William Horberg Maria Kopf Anthony Minghella Starring Cate Blanchett Giovanni Ribisi CinematographyFrank GriebeEdited byMathilde BonnefoyDistributed by Miramax Films (United States) Miramax International (through Buena Vista International, United Kingdom) TFM Distribution (France) X Verleih AG (Germany) Release dates 6 February...

 

2008 RBD compilation album Best OfGreatest hits album by RBDReleasedSeptember 23, 2008 (2008-09-23)Recorded2004–2007StudioVariousGenreLatin popteen poppop rockdance-popLength54:48LanguageSpanish • EnglishLabelEMIProducerPedro DamiánRBD chronology Empezar Desde Cero(2007) Best Of(2008) Para Olvidarte De Mí(2009) Best Of is the second compilation album by Mexican pop band RBD, released in September 2008 in Mexico and October in South America and the United States. The a...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!