Ernest McFarland

"Senator McFarland" redirects here. For other uses, see Senator McFarland (disambiguation).

Ernest McFarland
McFarland c. 1955
Chief Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court
In office January 1, 1968 – December 31, 1968
Preceded by	Charles C. Bernstein
Succeeded by	Jesse Addison Udall
Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court
In office January 4, 1965 – January 4, 1971
Preceded by	Edward W. Scruggs
Succeeded by	James Duke Cameron
10th Governor of Arizona
In office January 3, 1955 – January 5, 1959
Preceded by	John Howard Pyle
Succeeded by	Paul Fannin
Senate Majority Leader
In office January 3, 1951 – January 3, 1953
Deputy	Lyndon B. Johnson
Preceded by	Scott W. Lucas
Succeeded by	Robert A. Taft
Chairman of the Senate Democratic Caucus
In office January 3, 1951 – January 3, 1953
Preceded by	Scott W. Lucas
Succeeded by	Lyndon B. Johnson
United States Senator from Arizona
In office January 3, 1941 – January 3, 1953
Preceded by	Henry F. Ashurst
Succeeded by	Barry Goldwater
Personal details
Born	Ernest William McFarland (1894-10-09)October 9, 1894 Earlsboro, Oklahoma, U.S.
Died	June 8, 1984(1984-06-08) (aged 89) Phoenix, Arizona, U.S.
Resting place	Greenwood/Memory Lawn Mortuary & Cemetery Phoenix, Arizona
Political party	Democratic
Spouses	Clare Collins ​ ​ (m. 1926; died 1930)​ Eveland Smith ​ (m. 1939)​
Education	East Central University University of Oklahoma (BA) Stanford University (JD, MA)
Military service
Allegiance	United States
Branch/service	United States Navy
Years of service	1917–1919
Battles/wars	World War I

Ernest William McFarland (October 9, 1894 – June 8, 1984) was an American politician, jurist and, with Warren Atherton, one of the "Fathers of the G.I. Bill". He served in all three branches of government, two at the state level, one at the federal level. He was a Democratic U.S. senator from Arizona from 1941 to 1953 (Majority Leader from 1951 to 1953) before becoming the tenth governor of Arizona from 1955 to 1959. Finally, McFarland sat as chief justice on the Arizona Supreme Court in 1968.

Early life

McFarland was born to William Thomas and Keziah (Smith) McFarland on October 9, 1894, in a log cabin on his family's farm in Pottawatomie County, Oklahoma, near Earlsboro.^[1] When he was eight his family moved to Okemah for a year, before returning to Earlsboro. This had the effect of delaying McFarland's education for a year, for Okemah at that time had no schools.^[2] As a result, he graduated from Earlsburg High School in 1914.^[3]

After high school, McFarland enrolled at East Central State Normal School in Ada, Oklahoma.^[4] He completed the required work for a temporary teaching certificate after one quarter. In late 1914 and early 1915, McFarland taught in a one-room school in Schoolton, Oklahoma, to raise funds for his education.^[5] He then returned to East Central and taught mathematics at Ada High School to pay for his education.^[6] Meanwhile, he was active in his school's debating societies and began a friendship with Robert S. Kerr, who was a member of the same debate club.^[6] McFarland completed his studies at East Central in mid-1915, and left the school with a lifetime teaching certificate.^[7]

After East Central, McFarland enrolled at the University of Oklahoma.^[3] Working various part-time jobs, he initially studied mathematics with the intention of having a career in education. After a year he changed majors to pre-law. Studying at an accelerated rate, McFarland graduated with a bachelor's degree on June 5, 1917.^[7]

Following his graduation, McFarland enlisted in the U.S. Navy soon after the US entered World War I.^[8] He entered the military on December 11, 1917, as a seaman second class and was assigned to the Great Lakes Naval Training Station. The climate on the shore of Lake Michigan did not agree with him, and he was admitted to a naval hospital on March 3, 1918, as suffering from pneumonia.^[9] McFarland spent the next several months in the hospital dealing with a variety of problems, including pericarditis, emphysema, and pleurisy.^[10] It was not until early 1919 that he had recovered enough for a navy medical board to recommend he receive an honorable discharge, which became effective on January 31, 1919.^[11]

Early career

After leaving the navy, McFarland returned to Oklahoma for a short time before he decided to move to Arizona.^[12] He arrived in Phoenix on May 10, 1919, and after several days found employment at a local bank.^[8][13] Seeing little opportunity for advancement at the bank, he applied to the Stanford University Law School. Before leaving to begin classes, he filed for a 160 acres (65 ha) homestead near Casa Grande.^[14] McFarland would later refer to the land as his "jackrabbit farm".^[15]

McFarland attended law school for four quarters before he took a break. His parents and younger brother had moved to Arizona.^[16] At the time, Stanford recommended all law students to spend a quarter interning at a legal office. Feeling homesick after a year in California, McFarland worked at the Phoenix office of Phillips, Cox, and Phillips.^[17] He was legal clerk for future Arizona Governor John Calhoun Phillips.^[8]

McFarland was also introduced to a variety of figures within the Arizona political establishment.^[17] At the completion of his internship, he returned to Stanford. McFarland completed work on his Juris Doctor in the summer quarter in 1922.^[18] In addition, he had completed the class work for a Masters of Arts degree in political science.^[17] McFarland was admitted to the Arizona Bar later that year.^[4]

Upon graduation from law school, McFarland moved to Casa Grande to "prove up" his homestead claim and open his first legal practice.^[19] The Arizona economy was doing poorly, and he found little legal work.^[18] He dealt with the lack of work by becoming involved in politics.^[19] McFarland worked for George W. P. Hunt's campaign during the 1922 governor's race.^[20] After Hunt won the election, McFarland received an appointment as assistant attorney general.^[21]

In mid-1924, he returned to Stanford to complete work on his master's degree.^[22] Later that year he was elected county attorney for Pinal County. As state law required the county attorney to reside in the county seat, McFarland moved to Florence. He served three two-year terms in that position.^[8]

McFarland married Clair Collins on January 1, 1926.^[23] The couple had initially met at a Christmas party at Stanford in 1919.^[14] They had corresponded after their initial meeting, and by the time McFarland was elected, Collins was working at a teacher at Florence's high school. The couple had a son, William Ernest, in 1927 and a daughter, Jean Clair, in February 1929. William became ill and died several days before his sister's birth, and Jean died two days after her birth.^[23]

McFarland's wife suffered from depression following the loss of their two children.^[8] She showed signs of improvement in 1930 as the couple expected a third child. The third child, Juliette, was stillborn, and Clare McFarland developed postpartum complications, which led to her death on December 12, 1930.^[24]

By February 1930, McFarland represented the state during Eva Dugan's final appeal before her execution, a task that he found very unpleasant.^[23][25] Shortly afterwards, he decided that he was tired of being a prosecutor.^[25] Instead, McFarland ran for a seat on the Superior Court in Pinal County but lost the race to the incumbent, Judge E. L. Green, by 1464 to 1358.^[24]

Upon leaving office as county attorney, McFarland joined with his chief assistant, Tom Fulbright, to found the law office of McFarland and Fulbright.^[8] The practice gained public recognition when McFarland won an appeal that determined Winnie Ruth Judd to be insane, but its primary area of effort was water law.^[26]

Despite the success of his legal practice, McFarland still wished to become a judge.^[27] He ran a second time in 1934, defeated E. L. Green 2543 to 1542 in the primary, and was unopposed in the general election.^[28] In 1935, McFarland was sworn in, and he sat on the bench for the next six years.^[8][4]

As his workload in Pinal County was light, he accepted cases from other parts of the state, which allowed him to sit on the bench in every county in the state and to gain experience in issues in all parts of the state.^[28] As a judge, his rulings were well respected, and he was overturned on appeal only three times.^[28]

While on the bench, McFarland became romantically involved with a widow, Edna Eveland Smith, who had a young daughter, Jewell.^[29] She taught history and mathematics at Florence High School until the couple married^[30] in Tucson on June 1, 1939.^[31] McFarland also adopted his wife's daughter.^[32]

US Senator

McFarland considered a run for a seat in the US House of Representatives following the resignation of Isabella Greenway and was repeatedly encouraged to run for Arizona Attorney General. Realizing that he lacked the resources for a statewide campaign, he did not run for those offices.^[33]

During the Senate election of 1940, McFarland counted on voters in Phoenix and Tucson to oppose any candidate from the other city.^[30] He toured the state and reacquainted himself to various political leaders he had met during his time on the bench, but he waited to announce his intentions to run.^[30] McFarland's late entry did not hurt him, for he won the primary by nearly two-to-one and defeated the incumbent, Henry F. Ashurst.^[30] He went on to win the general election and took office in January 1941.^[4]

His initial committee assignments were to Indian Affairs, Interstate Commerce, Irrigation and Reclamation, Judiciary, and Pensions.^[30] Shortly after arriving in the Senate, Senator Gerald Nye convinced the Senate to create a committee looking into use of propaganda by the radio and motion picture industries.^[30] Senator Burton K. Wheeler recommended McFarland be placed on Nye's committee under the assumption the freshman senator "would keep his mouth shut".^[30]

Instead of remaining silent, McFarland became an outspoken critic of the committee and pointed out many accusations against films were being made by individuals who had not seen any of the films in question. McFarland gained national attention for his actions on the committee, with most of the nation viewing him favorably.^[30]

As a member of the Communications subcommittee, McFarland was involved in hearings dealing with the impact of developments in airmail, radio, telephones, and teletypes to the nation's telegraph services. The US telegraph market was dominated by Postal Telegraph and Western Union. Postal had been borrowing money from the Reconstruction Finance Corporation to maintain its infrastructure even though it was becoming obvious that Postal would be unable to pay back the loans. Those dealings with the FCC led McFarland to develop an interest in communications.^[30]

McFarland's experience in World War I led him to take an interest in the welfare of the troops during World War II.^[30] Arguing that many members of the military had left jobs, families, and schools to fight during the war, McFarland sponsored the G.I. Bill as a means to assisting soldiers and sailors as they transitioned back into civilian life.^[34]

McFarland was re-elected to the Senate in 1946^[4] and received an honorary L.L.D. from the University of Arizona in 1950.^[35]

In 1950, the Democratic membership of the Senate formed a 12-person team to ensure that at least one member of their party was on the floor of the Senate whenever the Senate was in session. That was done to ensure that the Democratic membership could be called to the floor if ever a vote was to be taken. McFarland was selected leader of the team and found it easier to remain on the floor himself than to find others to take the duty.^[36]

During the 1950 election, the two leading candidates for Democratic majority leader lost their re-election bids. With other members of his party appreciative of his efforts, McFarland was encouraged to run for a leadership position in January 1951.^[36]

McFarland was selected to be Senate Majority Leader for the 82nd Congress.^[37] As majority leader, McFarland hosted a monthly lunch meeting to which he invited all committee chairmen and all freshmen senators. He used the informal setting as a forum to conduct a variety of Senate business.^[36]

For two years, McFarland had sat next to Harry Truman while they were both in the Senate. Both men then friends during this time, a situation that made it easy for the Senate Majority Leader to work with Truman after he became president.^[36] McFarland believed it was part of his duty as majority leader to inform the president of an accurate view of what his fellow senators felt:^[36] "I never hesitated to present views contrary to those of the President in our conferences. As I've said before, I think that too frequently, the President is only told things people think he wants to hear. I would like to emphasize that it is not pleasant to present a view contrary to that of the President in such conferences."^[36] He felt that his duties as majority leader were separate from those of representing the interests of his constituents.^[36]

He spoke before Appropriations Committee to ask for funds to bring water from the Colorado River to central Arizona.^[36] He became an expert on water law because of his efforts on Irrigation and Reclamation Committee.^[36] He lost to Republican Barry Goldwater in the 1952 Senate elections. (This was the last time a Senate party leader lost a bid for reelection until 2004, when John Thune defeated Tom Daschle in South Dakota.)

Governor

McFarland as governor

McFarland was elected governor of Arizona in 1954 and re-elected in 1956. He worked with members of the Bureau of Reclamation to pick a location for the Glen Canyon Dam, and he emphasized education during his two terms in office.

Television venture

Shortly after he returned from the Senate, he bought a 40 percent stake in the Arizona Television Company, a group seeking to build the last VHF commercial television station in Phoenix. McFarland had long been intrigued by the still-new medium.

In 1955, shortly after he had become governor, McFarland and his group opened KTVK, Phoenix's fourth television station. He chose the call letters "because TV would be our middle name." He bought full control of the station in 1977. KTVK was the ABC affiliate for much of Arizona until 1995 and then became one of the nation's most successful independent stations. It remained in the hands of McFarland's family until 1999.

Return to law

McFarland tried unsuccessfully to unseat Goldwater in the Senate elections of 1958. After serving as governor, he returned to his law practice and was elected justice of the Arizona Supreme Court in 1964. He took part in Miranda v. Arizona and served as chief justice in 1968, thus completing a political "grand slam".

Later life

Crypt of Ernest William McFarland

In his mid-1970s, McFarland served as director of the Federal Home Loan Bank of San Francisco and president of the Arizona Television Company. He died in Phoenix and is buried in that city's Greenwood/Memory Lawn Mortuary & Cemetery.

Legacy

There is now a monument at the Arizona State Capitol honoring him as the "Father of the G.I. Bill." Also, the McFarland State Historic Park in Florence, Arizona, contains a preserved courthouse and other buildings from when Arizona was just a territory in 1878. McFarland purchased and donated them to the Arizona State Parks Board.

References

1. McMillan 2006, pp. 3, 6.
2. McMillan 2006, p. 11.
3. Kroman 1989, p. 99.
4. Goff 1983, p. 66.
5. McMillan 2006, p. 13.
6. McMillan 2006, p. 14.
7. McMillan 2006, p. 15.
8. Kroman 1989, p. 101.
9. McMillan 2006, p. 16.
10. McMillan 2006, pp. 16–7.
11. McMillan 2006, p. 17.
12. McFarland 1979, p. 18.
13. McMillan 2006, p. 20.
14. McMillan 2006, p. 22.
15. McFarland 1979, p. 27.
16. McMillan 2006, p. 23.
17. McMillan 2006, p. 24.
18. McMillan 2006, p. 25.
19. McFarland 1979, p. 28.
20. McMillan 2006, p. 26.
21. McMillan 2006, p. 27.
22. McMillan 2006, p. 28.
23. McMillan 2006, p. 33.
24. McMillan 2006, p. 37.
25. McFarland 1979, p. 33.
26. McMillan 2006, p. 46.
27. McFarland 1979, p. 37.
28. McMillan 2006, p. 49.
29. McMillan 2006, pp. 50–1.
30. Kroman 1989, p. 102.
31. McMillan 2006, p. 51.
32. McMillan 2006, p. 52.
33. McFarland 1979, p. 42.
34. Kroman 1989, pp. 102, 4.
35. McFarland 1979, pp. 23–4.
36. Kroman 1989, p. 104.
37. "McFarland Gets Top Senate Post In New Congress". The Spartanburg Herald. Spartanburg, SC. January 3, 1951. p. 1.

• Goff, John S. (1983). Arizona Biographical Dictionary. Cave Creek, AZ: Black Mountain Press. OCLC 10740532.
• Kroman, Karen K. (1989). "Ernest W. McFarland". In Myers, John L. (ed.). The Arizona governors, 1912–1990. Phoenix, AZ: Heritage Publishers. pp. 99–108. ISBN 0-929690-05-2.
• McFarland, Ernest W. (1979). Mac: The Autobiography of Ernest W. McFarland. OCLC 6195020.
• McMillan, James E. (Winter 1994). "Father of the GI Bill: Ernest W. McFarland and Veterans' Legislation". The Journal of Arizona History. 35 (4). Arizona Historical Society: 357–376. JSTOR 41696204.
• McMillan, James E. (2006). Ernest W McFarland: Majority Leader of the United States Senate and Governor and Chief Justice of the State of Arizona. Prescott, AZ: Sharlot Hall Museum Press. ISBN 0-927579-23-5.
• "Ernest W. McFarland". Stanford Law Review. 29 (5): 891–892. May 1977. doi:10.2307/1228138. JSTOR 1228138.

External links

• McFarland State Historic Park
• McFarland Collection of historic documents Archived February 9, 2019, at the Wayback Machine
• Arizona State Capitol Monument Archived September 5, 2019, at the Wayback Machine
• Congress Biography
• Biography from the Senate

Party political offices
Preceded by Henry F. Ashurst	Democratic nominee for U.S. Senator from Arizona (Class 1) 1940, 1946, 1952, 1958	Succeeded by Roy Elson
Preceded by Joe Haldiman	Democratic nominee for Governor of Arizona 1954, 1956	Succeeded by Robert Morrison
Preceded by Scott W. Lucas	Senate Democratic Leader 1951–1953	Succeeded by Lyndon B. Johnson
U.S. Senate
Preceded by Henry F. Ashurst	U.S. Senator (Class 1) from Arizona 1941–1953 Served alongside: Carl Hayden	Succeeded by Barry Goldwater
New office	Chair of the Joint Navaho-Hopi Committee 1950–1953	Succeeded by Arthur Vivian Watkins
Preceded by Scott W. Lucas	Senate Majority Leader 1951–1953	Succeeded by Robert A. Taft
Political offices
Preceded by John Howard Pyle	Governor of Arizona 1955–1959	Succeeded by Paul Fannin
Legal offices
Preceded by Edward W. Scruggs	Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court 1965–1971	Succeeded by James Duke Cameron
Preceded by Charles C. Bernstein	Chief Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court 1968	Succeeded by Jesse Addison Udall