Elephant (2003 film)

Elephant
Theatrical release poster
Directed by	Gus Van Sant
Written by	Gus Van Sant
Produced by	Dany Wolf
Starring	Alex Frost Eric Deulen John Robinson
Cinematography	Harris Savides
Edited by	Gus Van Sant
Production company	Meno Film Company
Distributed by	Fine Line Features HBO Films
Release dates	May 2003 (2003-05) (Cannes) October 24, 2003 (2003-10-24) (United States)
Running time	81 minutes
Country	United States
Language	English
Budget	$3 million[1]
Box office	$10 million[2]

Elephant is a 2003 American psychological drama film written, directed and edited by Gus Van Sant. It takes place in Watt High School, in the suburbs of Portland, Oregon, and chronicles the events surrounding a school shooting, based in part on the 1999 Columbine High School massacre. The film begins a short time before the shooting occurs, following the lives of several characters both in and out of school, who are unaware of what is about to unfold. The film stars mostly new actors, including John Robinson, Alex Frost, and Eric Deulen.

Elephant is the second film in Van Sant's "Death Trilogy"—the first is Gerry (2002) and the third Last Days (2005)—all three of which are based on actual events.

Although Elephant was controversial for its subject matter and allegations of influence on the Red Lake shootings, it was generally praised by critics and received the Palme d'Or at the 2003 Cannes Film Festival.^[3]

Plot

At the start of the film, John McFarland is driven to school by his father, who is driving erratically down the road. Noticing the damage done to the car, John realizes that his father is drunk and makes him move to the passenger seat so he can drive. When John arrives at school late, he is reprimanded by the principal, Mr. Luce.

The majority of the film is spent following several high school students going about their daily lives just before a school shooting. In addition to John, who struggles with controlling his alcoholic father, photography student Elias builds a portfolio of other students. Outcast Michelle struggles with her body issues and assists in the library. Bulimics Nicole, Brittany, and Jordan gripe about their parents and squabble while popular athlete and lifeguard Nathan meets with his girlfriend, Carrie. Acadia, a close friend of John's, attends a Gay-Straight Alliance meeting.

Unknown to anyone, two other students, Alex and Eric, are preparing to carry out a bomb/shooting attack on their school. Flashbacks throughout the film show them preparing for the massacre by ordering weapons online and formulating an attack plan. The two have a brief sexual encounter in the shower after they both admit that they've never kissed anyone before. Their motives for the shooting appear vague; the film provides evidence suggesting bullying, neglect, violent video games, and Nazism.

On the day of the shooting, the pair makes their way to school in Alex's car. Alex is armed with a Carbon-15 and a shotgun while Eric has a TEC-9. As they enter the school, they encounter John, and Alex tells him to leave. Realizing what is about to happen, John tries to warn students and teachers outside not to go into the school, but few people listen. He then notices his dad is missing after they arrived earlier and goes looking for him.

Alex and Eric plant propane bombs in the cafeteria, hoping to blow it up and shoot people as they try to escape the fire. When the bombs fail, they decide to start shooting indiscriminately. The pair heads into the library, where Elias photographs them right before they open fire on students. Michelle is killed, while Elias' fate is left unclear. Other students quickly realize that the gunfire is real and begin to panic, and teachers begin evacuating students.

Alex and Eric split up to opposing ends of the school to continue their shooting. Alex enters the girls' bathroom where he surprises Jordan, Nicole, and Brittany, presumably shooting all three. A student attending the Gay-Straight Alliance meeting enters the hallway investigating the gunfire and is shot dead. The alliance members evacuate through a window save for Acadia, who freezes at the sight of her dead classmate. Benny, an African-American student-athlete, finds her and helps her out the window before deciding to find the shooters.

Outside the school, John finds his now sobered-up father, who tries to comfort his son as the shooting continues. While helping students escape, Mr. Luce is cornered and threatened by Eric, prompting Mr. Luce to try and reason with him. Benny walks up behind Eric, and Eric abruptly turns around and shoots Benny dead. Eric tells Mr. Luce not to treat kids like him and Alex poorly. He then lets Mr. Luce go, only to gun him down seconds later.

Alex enters the cafeteria, which is strewn with overturned chairs, backpacks, several dead bodies, and numerous abandoned half-eaten lunches, and sits down. Alex picks up a cup from an abandoned lunch and casually drinks from it. Eric meets up with him, and they have a brief conversation about who they've shot, which ends when Alex shoots Eric mid-sentence. Alex leaves the cafeteria, showing no emotion over killing Eric, and discovers Carrie and Nathan hiding in a freezer. He tauntingly recites "Eeny, meeny, miny, moe" to them to decide whom he should kill first. The film then cuts to the credits, leaving the ending ambiguous.

Cast

• Alex Frost as Alex, the more intelligent of the two killers, implied to be the one in charge. He is an accomplished but frustrated pianist and sketch artist.
• Eric Deulen as Eric, a slacker, Alex's friend, and the other killer. He is less intelligent than Alex, and Alex is obviously aware of this. He is shot in the chest by Alex near the end of the film, while talking about whom he had killed earlier.
• John Robinson as John McFarland, Alex's friend who has trouble at school while managing his alcoholic father. Alex warns him and a few other people to stay away from the massacre.
• Timothy Bottoms as Mr. McFarland, John's alcoholic father.
• Matt Malloy as Mr. Luce, the principal of the school. Cornered by Eric, who briefly spares him, he is presumed dead after being shot several times.
• Elias McConnell as Elias, a photography student building his portfolio with portraits of other students.
• Nathan Tyson and Carrie Finklea as Nathan and Carrie, a popular lifeguard/football player and his girlfriend. Alex taunts them with Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.
• Kristen Hicks as Michelle, a nerdy girl ashamed of her body. The film follows her through the locker room and into the library where she assists, and it is there that she is the first to die in the massacre.
• Brittany Mountain, Jordan Taylor, and Nicole George as Brittany, Jordan, and Nicole, three bulimic girls who talk incessantly, gripe about parents, and squabble with one another.
• Bennie Dixon as Benny, an athletic student who helps Acadia escape out of a window before approaching Eric. He is shot and presumed dead.
• Alicia Miles as Acadia, a close friend of John and a member of the Gay-Straight Alliance. During the shooting, Benny discovers her standing still in a classroom and helps her escape from the school and the shooters.

Production

The title was inspired by the parable of the blind men and an elephant.

The film began as a documentary that Van Sant had intended to make about the Columbine High School massacre; eventually, the idea of a factual account was dropped.^[4]

Elephant was filmed in Van Sant's hometown, Portland, Oregon, in late 2002, on the former campus of Whitaker Middle School (previously Adams High School).

There was no initial script before the filming started. The script was "written" to its final form during shooting, with cast members improvising freely and collaborating in the direction of scenes. It was shot over 20 days.^[4]

JT LeRoy (a pen name for author Laura Albert) is credited as an associate producer for the film.

Title

The title Elephant is a tribute to the 1989 BBC short film of the same name, directed by Alan Clarke.^[4] Van Sant originally believed Clarke's title referred to the parable of the blind men and an elephant, in which several blind men try to describe an elephant, and each draws different conclusions based on which body part they touched, and Van Sant's film uses that interpretation, as the same general timeline is shown multiple times from multiple viewpoints.^[5] Later, Van Sant discovered Clarke's film referred to the phrase "elephant in the room" (the collective denial of some obvious problem).^[6] Also, Gus Van Sant named Chantal Akerman's film Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975) as an inspiration.^[7]

Clarke's film Elephant reflects on sectarian violence in Northern Ireland. Van Sant's minimalist style and use of tracking shots mirrors Clarke's film.^[8]

Reception and legacy

Elephant received mainly positive reviews from critics and has a score of 74% on Rotten Tomatoes based on 164 reviews with an average rating of 7.10/10. The critical consensus states "The movie's spare and unconventional style will divide viewers."^[9] The film also has a score of 70 out of 100 on Metacritic based on 37 critics indicating "generally favourable reviews".^[10]

Roger Ebert praised the film and gave it 4 out of 4 stars writing "Gus Van Sant's Elephant is a violent movie in the sense that many innocent people are shot dead. But it isn't violent in the way it presents those deaths. There is no pumped-up style, no lingering, no release, no climax. Just implacable, poker-faced, flat, uninflected death. Truffaut said it was hard to make an anti-war film because war was exciting even if you were against it. Van Sant has made an anti-violence film by draining violence of energy, purpose, glamor, reward and social context. It just happens. I doubt that Elephant will ever inspire anyone to copy what they see on the screen. Much more than the insipid message movies shown in social studies classes, it might inspire useful discussion and soul-searching among high school students."^[11]

Accolades

Award	Date of ceremony	Category	Recipient(s)	Result	Ref(s)
Bodil Awards	27 February 2005	Best American Film	Gus Van Sant	Nominated	[12]
Cannes Film Festival	14 – 25 May 2003	Palme d'Or		Won	[13]
		Best Director		Won
		Cinema Prize of the French National Education System		Won	[14]
César Awards	21 February 2004	Best Foreign Film		Nominated	[15]
French Syndicate of Cinema Critics	15 January 2004	Best Foreign Film		Won	[16]
Independent Spirit Awards	28 February 2004	Best Director		Nominated	[17]
		Best Cinematography	Harris Savides	Nominated
Los Angeles Film Critics Association	7 January 2004	Best Cinematography		Runner-up	[18]
National Society of Film Critics	3 January 2004	Best Cinematography		3rd place	[19]
New York Film Critics Circle	15 December 2003	Best Cinematography		Won	[20]

Shooting controversies

Rafael Solich, the perpetrator of the 2004 Carmen de Patagones school shooting had watched the film days prior to the shooting.^[21]

The Red Lake shootings that occurred in 2005 were briefly blamed on the film, as it was viewed by gunman Jeff Weise 17 days prior to the event.^[22] A friend of Weise said that he brought the film over to a friend's house and skipped ahead to parts that showed two students planning and carrying out a school massacre. Although they talked about the film afterwards, Weise said and did nothing to make anyone suspect what he was planning.^[23]

During the Suzano school shooting that occurred in 2019, both perpetrators were seen wearing clothing that resembled that of the main characters of Elephant.^[24]

See also

• Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, the students behind the Columbine High School massacre
• Bowling for Columbine, a documentary about gun violence in America with emphasis on the Columbine massacre
• Duck! The Carbine High Massacre, a film made in 1999 inspired by the Columbine High School massacre
• Heart of America, yet another film revolving around a fictionalized school massacre
• Zero Day, another film inspired by the Columbine High School massacre made in 2003
• The Only Way, a 2004 independent film inspired by the Columbine High School massacre
• 2:37, a 2006 film set in Australia that follows the same style
• Run Hide Fight, a 2020 film follows a high school sieged by a quartet of school shooters.
• Mass, a 2021 film involving grieving parents who meet to discuss the aftermath of a school shooting

References

1. "Elephant". The Numbers. Retrieved 10 October 2022.
2. "Elephant". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
3. The Indie Filmmaking Genius of Gus Van Sant | The VICE Guide To Film - VICE on YouTube.
4. Crean, Ellen (21 May 2003). "2003: Shades Of Columbine". cbsnews.com. Retrieved 9 December 2018.
5. Caroline Bassett, The arc and the machine, 2007, p.180
6. Caroline Bassett, The arc and the machine, 2007, p.181
7. "Chantal Akerman : retour sur la carrière d'une cinéaste influente - Elle". elle.fr (in French). October 7, 2015.
8. Lim, Dennis. "Scanners". The Village Voice. Archived from the original on October 17, 2006.
9. "Elephant (2003)". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved 8 July 2020.
10. "Elephant". Metacritic. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
11. Ebert, Roger (7 November 2003). "Elephant". Chicago Sun-Times – via Rogerebert.com.
12. "Bodil og Oscar inviterer til filmfest på DR" (in Danish). DR. 14 February 2005. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
13. "ELEPHANT". festival-cannes.com. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
14. Gregg Goldstein (21 May 2007). "Dialogue: Gus Van Sant". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
15. Alison James (23 January 2004). "'Bon' showing for Rappeneau". Variety. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
16. G. Krishnakumar (22 August 2005). "Feast for movie buffs". The Hindu. Archived from the original on 21 June 2017. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
17. "Monster, Elephant among Independent Spirit nominees (10655)". Advocate. 4 December 2003. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
18. Susan King (9 January 2004). "'Splendor' is L.A. critics' best film". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
19. David Rooney (4 January 2004). "'Splendor' in awards mix". Variety. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
20. Steve Chagollan (11 October 2012). "Cinematographer Harris Savides dies". Variety. Retrieved 21 June 2017.
21. Palacios, Por Rodolfo (2019-09-28). "A 15 años de la masacre de Carmen de Patagones: un adolescente a los tiros, muerte en el aula y el estremecedor relato de los sobrevivientes". infobae (in European Spanish). Retrieved 2024-08-17.
22. Hancock, David. "Red Lake Shooting Conspiracy?", CBS/Associated Press, 30 March 2005.
23. ""Suspected Red Lake shooter watched movie about a school attack"". Archived from the original on May 3, 2007. Retrieved 2007-04-25.. KTVO-TV.
24. Romano, Giovanna (2021-03-26). "Suicídio, roupa preta, arma branca: semelhanças entre Columbine e Suzano". VEJA (in Portuguese). Archived from the original on 2024-07-15.

External links

• Elephant at IMDb 
• Elephant at Box Office Mojo
• Elephant at Rotten Tomatoes