East Broad Top Railroad Mikado locomotives

Restored East Broad Top Railroad 16 with an excursion train in 2023

The East Broad Top Railroad owns six three-foot gauge Mikado locomotives built by the Baldwin Locomotive Works. These engines original to the railroad have survived from their construction to the present day, with various members of the fleet having run in steam for excursion train service on the preserved route.

History

East Broad Top Railroad doubleheader with two Mikado locomotives, October 1987

Mikado locomotives provided the primary motive power of the East Broad Top's narrow gauge mainline from their initial delivery in the early 1910s until the railroad's abandonment in the 1950s. Predating the purchase of any Mikado engines, the East Broad Top had purchased a 2-6-2 Prairie engine (#11) in 1908 whose success encouraged the railroad to go larger with the following Mikado locomotives.^[1] The Mikado locomotives share several features to ensure smooth handling of heavy coal traffic, including double air brake pumps and two sand domes.^[2] The railroad began installing airbrakes on their equipment in 1913 along with new steel cars to operate alongside the growing Mikado fleet.^[3] Although the East Broad Top did briefly consider replacing the Mikado fleet with diesels, the line's abandonment and sale to Nick Kovalchick saved the historic steam locomotives with all six locomotives still preserved at the original East Broad Top's Rockhill Furnace shops.^[4][5][6]

Four of the engines would run in steam on and off again from the 1960s to 2011 during the East Broad Top's era of preservation under the Kovalchick family, with three of them (#12, #14, #15) already back in service by the early 1960s to haul excursion trains.^[7] The fourth engine to run in the Kovalchick era, #17 would return to steam in 1968.^[8] The locomotives provided the star attractions of the East Broad Top's Winter Spectaculars, until the Winter Spectacular runs were terminated in the 1980s due to the stress being placed on the locomotives and rolling stock.^[9] The explosion of Canadian Pacific 1278 at the Gettysburg Railroad in 1995 and the subsequent passage of stricter boiler safety laws caused financial strain for the East Broad Top to maintain their locomotive fleet. Only one locomotive would often be kept available for steam at a time from 1995 onto 2010, with #14 and then #15 being the primary locomotives to operate during this era (with #12 being retired in 2000 and #17 in the following year).^[10]

When the railroad shut down at the end of 2011, all of the engines were placed in storage from then until 2020 when the newly founded EBT Foundation Inc. bought the moribund railroad and began restoration work on locomotive #16. #16 returned to service in early 2023.^[11] The railroad has also begun preliminary work to potentially restore both #14 and #15 at a future date and inspected the other locomotives for restoration potential as well. The EBT Foundation Inc. has stated they desire to see all six locomotives someday restored to steam.^[12]

12-281⁄4 E-1

Source:^[13]

12-281⁄4 E-1[14]
No. 12 pulling a Railfan Special excursion in February 1969
Type and origin Power type Steam Builder Baldwin Locomotive Works Serial number 37325[15] Model 12-281⁄4 E-1[16] Build date December 1911 Total produced 1
Specifications Configuration: ​  • Whyte 2-8-2 Gauge 36 inches Driver dia. 48 inches (1.22 m)[17] Wheelbase 13 ft (3.96 m) ​  • Engine 26.17 ft (7.98 m) Adhesive weight 88,000 lbs (391.4 kN) Total weight 172,000 lbs (765.1 kN) Fuel type Coal Fuel capacity 6 tons (6 MT) Water cap. 3000 gals (11.36 ML) Boiler pressure 180 psi (1240 kPa) Heating surface 1686 sq ft (156.63 sq m) Cylinders 2 Cylinder size 17" diameter (0.432 m) Valve gear Walschaerts
Performance figures Tractive effort 22,100 lbf (98.3 kN)[13]
Career Official name Millie Current owner EBT Foundation Inc. Disposition Stored

East Broad Top #12 is the first Mikado locomotive built for the railroad in 1911. The new Mikado began the process of modernizing the East Broad Top locomotive fleet, replacing the aging mixed roster of various locomotive types which ran on the railroad prior. The locomotive was designed to haul 15 loaded coal hoppers on the railroad. The locomotive derailed on its maiden trip on the railroad at Siding Hill Tunnel.^[18] Despite these teething issues, the engine proved successful and served as the template for the following five Mikados to come. The locomotive operated on a sporadic as needed basis from the late 1940s into the 1950s due to its light weight and lower power compared to its five larger successors.

The locomotive was named "Millie" in 1960 after then EBT owner Nick Kovalchick's daughter and was the first steam locomotive returned to service to operate the excursion line in 1960.^[19] The locomotive proved popular in the preservation era due to its smaller size and lighter weight which was believed to be easier on the track.^[1] #12 last operated in preservation in 2000 and has been stored since.^[20]

To celebrate the reopening of the railroad in the 2020s on August 13, 2020 Millie Kovalchick Glinsky (the namesake of #12); ceremonially smashed a bottle of grape juice over the pilot of the locomotive.^[21] #12 due to its heavy use in the early preservation era is considered to be mechanically worn, and requires heavy work to return to steam someday.^[22]

12-321⁄4 E-12

Source:^[13]

12-321⁄4 E-12 [14]
No. 15 pulling an excursion in June 2006
Type and origin Power type Steam Builder Baldwin Locomotive Works Serial number 14: 38625[15] 15: 41196 Model 12-321⁄4 E-12[16] Build date 14: 1912 15: 1914 Total produced 2
Specifications Configuration: ​  • Whyte 2-8-2 Gauge 36 inches Driver dia. 48 inches (1.22 m)[23] Fuel type Coal Fuel capacity 7 tons (6 MT) Water cap. 124,000 gals (56,246 ML) Boiler pressure 180 psi (1240 kPa) Heating surface 2228 sq ft (206.99 sq m) Cylinders 2 Cylinder size 19" diameter (0.483 m) Valve gear Walschaerts
Performance figures Tractive effort 14: 27,800 lbf (124 kN) 15: 29,400 lbf (131 kN) [13]
Career Current owner EBT Foundation Inc. Disposition One under restoration, one stored

Built in 1912 and following up on the design of #12, #14 had increased tractive effort compared to its predecessor with the estimated ability of hauling 18 loaded hoppers from the coal mines along the East Broad Top. Despite #14 sequentially following #12, The East Broad Top skipped over the potential #13 roster spot and never owned a locomotive with that number. #15 would arrive two years later as a response to increased passenger demands while also sharing the same basic design as #14.^[24]

Locomotive #14 last operated in 2005. #15 ran in preservation from 2005 until 2011 when the East Broad Top was shut down, making #15 the last steam locomotive to run in the Kovalchick era. Both #15 and #14 have been inspected and partially disassembled after the railroad's revival in 2020 and are potential candidates for a full restoration after #16 is completed.^[25]

As of 2024, #15 is seen as the prime candidate to return to steam after the completion of #16, and is currently under restoration.^[26] #15 retains its boiler certification paperwork from the Federal Railroad Administration, however the engine requires extensive running gear repair before returning to service.^[22] #14 was considered for an early return to steam, but it was determined it would require more work to replace failing cast iron driving wheels on the locomotive with upgraded steel parts and the engine is as of 2024, planned to be third in line for restoration.^[22]

12-5341⁄4 E Series

Source:^[13]

12-5341⁄4 E-#[14]
No. 17 getting steamed up at the Rockhill roundhouse in 1986
Type and origin Power type Steam Builder Baldwin Locomotive Works Serial number 16: 43562 17: 48075 18: 53541 [15] Model 16: 12-5341⁄4 E-41[27] 17: 12-5341⁄4 E-47[28] 18: 12-5341⁄4 E-57[29] Build date 16: 1916 17: 1918 18: 1920 Total produced 3
Specifications Configuration: ​  • Whyte 2-8-2 Gauge 36 inches Driver dia. 48 inches (1.22 m)[30] Fuel type Coal Fuel capacity 7 tons (6 MT) Water cap. 124,000 gals (56,246 ML) Boiler pressure 180 psi (1240 kPa) 16 after 2023 rebuild: 200 psi (1380 kPa)[31] Heating surface 2485 sq ft (230.86 sq m) Superheater: ​  • Heating area 465 sq ft (43.2 sq m) Cylinders 2 Cylinder size 20" diameter (0.508 m) Valve gear Southern[20]
Performance figures Tractive effort 16: 34,000 lbf (151 kN)^α 17: 33,000 lbf (147 kN) 18: 34,500 lbf (153 kN)[13]
Career Official name Nick (16) Current owner EBT Foundation Inc. Disposition One operational, two stored[32][11]

The final three Mikados were the largest locomotives on the East Broad Top roster. Unlike the previous EBT Mikados, these three locomotives used Southern valve gear and had boilers equipped with superheaters.^[33] The first of these Baldwin 12-341⁄4-E's (#16) arrived in 1916 with the final class member #18 delivered in 1920. It was estimated that these locomotives could handle 22 loaded hoppers, with reports of #16 once pulling a train of 60 empty hoppers.

At the time the East Broad Top shut down in 1956, #16 was undergoing an overhaul.^[34] During the first preservation era on the East Broad Top from the 1960s #16 and #18 were stored on property. #16 was considered for early restoration by the preserved railroad, but it is believed its boiler paperwork was destroyed by water damage from a leaking roof and the railroad chose to restore #14 instead.^[33] Locomotive #17 ran in excursion service on the preserved line from 1968 until 2001 as the only example of the class to steam in the Kovalchick era. General Manager of the railroad in the early 2020s Brad Esposito, has claimed regarding #17 and #18 that the original EBT "beat the snot out of them", due to being favored locomotives by the line during the latter years of freight traffic prior to preservation.^[22] In addition the boiler of #18 requires extensive repairs before it can be returned to service.^[22]

After reopening of the East Broad Top was announced in 2020, #16 was chosen as the first engine to be restored for steam service. The engine was found to require some boiler repair, new flues, repairs to the suspension, and the installation of a new mud ring.^[22] EBT restoration crews have relied heavily on partnerships with other experienced steam restoration crews such as the Strasburg Railroad and the contractor FMW Solutions to expedite the restoration of #16. Curry Rail Services was contracted to build a new welded tender tank for the locomotive. Appliances were swapped from the other stored EBT locomotives onto #16 to speed up the restoration process.^[22]

A FRA mandated hydrostatic test was conducted in May 2022 on #16's boiler.^[31] A steam test on the boiler was conducted in June 2022.^[35] After the steam test, work remained on the superheater, cab and boiler jacketing before the engine could return to service.^[32] By October 2022, boiler jacketing and paint work on the cab were completed for public display during the annual Friends of the East Broad Top Reunion.^[22]

In late January 2023, the East Broad Top Railroad began posting a series of teasers for the return of #16 to service on their Facebook page, including a video showing the shadow cast by the locomotive under steam on February 1, 2023.^[36] A second video posted later on the same day showed the locomotive in motion moving out onto the railroad's turntable, christened with the name "Nick" on the cab.^[11] Shortly after the locomotive's return to service plans were announced for the engine to headline the year's Winter Steam event and work as the primary excursion locomotive in the line's immediate future.^[37] The locomotive first ran for the public on excursions on February 18 later that year.^[34]

#16 would be taken out of service in early 2024, after discovering a cracked driver center during a regular inspection.^[38] At the end of August, #16 was returned to regular service after repairs and test runs were completed.^[39]

References

1. Iverson, Lucas (December 14, 2022). "East Broad Top Railroad locomotives in the 21st century". trains.com. Kalmbach Media. Retrieved December 15, 2022.
2. McHugh, J. Fiske (June 7, 1950). "Diamond Jubilee of Rockhill Coal Company Opens". Altoona Mirror. Altoona, Pennsylvania. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
3. "Narrow Gauge Steel Car". Altoona Mirror. Altoona, Pennsylvania. January 28, 1913. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
4. "G. E. Report on Dieselization and Profile Map". ebtarchives.com. General Electric. January 1955. Retrieved May 17, 2023. The following is designed to determine the number and size of locomotives necessary to meet the motive power requirements of the East Broadtop Railroad under production rates experienced in 1954 and as are anticipated in 1955. It is also the purpose of this report to determine the economics picture by comparing a proposed diesel-electric operation to actual expenditure from the records of the East Broadtop Railroad in 1954 and of anticipated savings suggested by the Railroad personnel.
5. Tayler, Arthur (1996). Recreational Railroads. Edison, New Jersey: Chartwell Books, Inc. p. 60 & 61. ISBN 0-7858-0654-7.
6. Van Horn, John (2016). East Broad Top Railroad A Personal Photographic Study. Honesdale, Pennsylvania: Moosic Mountain Wild Co. ISBN 978-1537079998.
7. Ziel, Ron (1963). The Twilight of Steam Locomotives. New York City: Grosset & Dunlap Publishers. p. 149. ISBN 0-448-13162-5.
8. Coleman, Christopher. "EBT Locomotive Roster 17". oldeastie.com. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
9. Keller, Vagel (2008). "Review Reviewed Work(s): East Broad Top Railroad by Kenneth C. Springirth". Railroad History. 199: 103. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
10. Cupper, Dan (Spring 2023). "A Half Century of Tourist Trains". Trains Magazine: East Broad Top Steam Treasure of the East Special 2023. Kalmbach Media.
11. "Steam Returns to East Broad Top". railfan.com. White River Productions. February 1, 2023. Retrieved February 1, 2023.
12. Cupper, Dan (20 July 2022). "First new coach arrives at East Broad Top". Trains.com. Kalmbach Media. Retrieved 21 July 2022.
13. "EBTF.2022.7.6". ebtarchives.catalogaccess.com. East Broad Top Railroad. March 18, 1921. Retrieved September 4, 2023.
14. "East Broad Top 2-8-2 "Mikado" Locomotives in the USA". steamlocomotive.com. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
15. Young, William. "East Broad Top Motive Power". hawkinsrails.net. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
16. "Baldwin Locomotive Works engine specifications, 1869-1938". digitalcollections.smu.edu. Southern Methodist University Library. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
17. Bailey, Doug. "East Broad Top RR 2-8-2 No. 12". steamlocomotive.info. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
18. Coleman, Christopher. "EBT locomotive roster 12". oldeastie.com. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
19. "Steam Engine Fans Delight Located at Rock Hill Furnace". Altoona Mirror. Altoona Pennsylvania. July 2, 1960. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
20. "Steam Locomotives". eastbroadtop.com. EBT Foundation Inc. 2022. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
21. Cupper, Dan (Spring 2023). "Restarting a Legend". Trains Magazine: East Broad Top Steam Treasure of the East Special 2023. Kalmbach Media.
22. Cupper, Dan (Spring 2023). "Mikados, Motor Cars, and Diesels". Trains Magazine: East Broad Top Steam Treasure of the East Special 2023. Kalmbach Media.
23. Bailey, Doug. "East Broad Top RR 2-8-2 No. 14". steamlocomotive.info. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
24. "Our Steam Locomotives". ebttr.com. East Broad Top Railroad. Archived from the original on June 8, 2011.
25. Coleman, Christopher. "EBT locomotive roster 14". oldeastie.com. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
26. Franz, Justin (March 8, 2023). "After Successful Winter Spectacular, EBT Eyes Next 2-8-2 to Restore". railfan.com. White RiverProductions. Retrieved March 8, 2023.
27. "Baldwin Locomotive Works specifications, Vol. 53 (p. 405)" (PDF). DeGolyer Library, Southern Methodist University. Retrieved 13 April 2024.
28. "Baldwin Locomotive Works specifications, Vol. 62 (p. 41)" (PDF). DeGolyer Library, Southern Methodist University. Retrieved 13 April 2024.
29. "Baldwin Locomotive Works specifications, Vol. 65 (p. 101)" (PDF). DeGolyer Library, Southern Methodist University. Retrieved 13 April 2024.
30. Bailey, Doug. "East Broad Top RR 2-8-2 No. 16". steamlocomotive.info. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
31. Cupper, Dan (May 31, 2022). "Work on East Broad Top 2-8-2 No. 16 nearing completion". trains.com. Kalmbach Media. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
32. Burkhart, M.T. (June 24, 2022). "East Broad Top 2-8-2 Fired Up For First Time Since 1956". railfan.com. White River Productions. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
33. Coleman, Christopher. "EBT locomotive roster 16". oldeastie.com. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
34. Clade, Maria (February 9, 2023). "East Broad Top Railroad sets return date for historic steam engine". WTAJ-TV. Archived from the original on February 10, 2023. Retrieved February 10, 2023.
35. Watson, Adam (July 5, 2022). "Historic EBT locomotive put under steam". bedfordgazette.com. Bedford Gazette. Retrieved November 26, 2022.
36. "Good morning from Rockhill Furnace!". facebook.com. East Broad Top Railroad. February 1, 2023. Retrieved February 1, 2023.
37. "East Broad Top No. 16 set to operate at Winter Spectacular (updated)". trains.com. Kalmbach Media. February 2, 2023. Retrieved February 2, 2023.
38. Cupper, Dan (April 11, 2024). "East Broad Top 2-8-2 No. 16 out of service through summer". trains.com. Kalmbach Media. Retrieved April 12, 2024.
39. Cupper, Dan (2024-08-29). "East Broad Top 2-8-2 No. 16 is back in service". Trains. Retrieved 2024-08-30.

Notes

^α Historical tractive effort value prior to boiler up pressuring to 200 PSI during 2023 restoration.