The Los Angeles Times called the album a return to "a classic punk sound full of high-octane, slashing guitars."[1]AllMusic wrote that "the album may be titled Disappear, but TSOL have in reality reappeared in all its former glory."[2]Trouser Press called the band "as stylistically ravenous as ever," but wrote that the album contained "too much filler from a band that’s had so long to prepare."[7]