Death of Tina Fontaine

Tina Fontaine
September 2013 school photograph of Fontaine
Born	Tina Michelle Fontaine (1999-01-01)1 January 1999 Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Disappeared	8 August 2014 (aged 15) Downtown Winnipeg
Died	c. 10 August 2014(2014-08-10) (aged 15)
Body discovered	Red River, Winnipeg
Resting place	Sagkeeng First Nation, Manitoba, Canada

Tina Michelle Fontaine (1 January 1999 – c. 10 August 2014)^[1] was a First Nations teenage girl who was reported missing and died in August 2014.^[2] Her case is considered among the high number of missing and murdered Indigenous women of Canada, and her death renewed calls by activists for the government to conduct a national inquiry into the issue.

In December 2015, a suspect was charged with second-degree murder in her case.^[3][4] However, no forensic evidence or eyewitnesses that could directly link him to her death was presented and the cause of her death was never established. He was acquitted by a jury in February 2018.^[5] The case of Tina Fontaine helped prompt the Canadian government to commit to creating an independent national inquiry into the issue of murders and violence against Indigenous women, which was started in 2017.

Fontaine was buried on Sagkeeng First Nation next to her father.^[6]

Background

Fontaine's paternal grandfather was a residential school survivor, and his experiences as a child led to years of severe alcoholism and violence. At the age of 12, her father Eugene Fontaine left his home in Sagkeeng First Nation, 121 kilometres (75 mi) northeast of Winnipeg, to move to Winnipeg, where he fended for himself on the streets. In Winnipeg, he developed an addiction to alcohol.^[7]

Fontaine's mother, Valentina (Tina) Duck, was raised in Bloodvein First Nation, 250 km (160 mi) north of Winnipeg.^[8] Starting at the age of six, Duck was removed from and returned to her mother several times by Manitoba Child and Family Services. Duck experienced a number of significant traumas as a young child, which the Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth said in a 2019 report "were not appropriately addressed." At the age of 10, Duck was taken from her family permanently. After that, she was moved repeatedly, began to be sexually exploited by adults, and started to use alcohol and drugs. The Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth says little was done to intervene and protect her.^[7]

When Fontaine's parents met, her mother was a 12-year-old child in care, and her father was 23. Child and Family Services records show that it knew their relationship was sexual and knew that Fontaine's father had a past that involved violence and severe addictions. Files noted that her mother would frequently run away from her foster placements to stay with Fontaine's father. In 1994, Duck described to her caseworker feeling "depressed," "suicidal," "isolated, alone, and unloved."^[7]

In the spring of 1996, at the age of 14, Duck gave birth to her first child, who was immediately and permanently taken from her by Child and Family Services.^[7]

Early life

Tina Fontaine was born on 1 January 1999 in Winnipeg, Manitoba. She was her mother's second child; in June 2000, her mother gave birth to a third.^[7]

When she was one year old, Tina was removed from her family's care for the first time by Child and Family Services. It happened again when she was two, after which she was returned to the care of her father. When Fontaine was five years old, her father placed her and her younger sibling with her great-aunt and -uncle, Thelma and Joseph Favel, through a private guardianship arrangement.^[7][8][9]

Fontaine lived with her great-aunt and -uncle for nearly a decade in Powerview-Pine Falls, Manitoba (next to Sagkeeng First Nation), except for a brief stay in Selkirk.^[8]

In 2011, when she was 12, her father (age 41) was beaten to death; his two assailants were convicted of manslaughter.^[8][10] Fontaine's aunt recalled that her father's violent death deeply affected the girl: "She was very hurt, very lost. That's when she drifted away."^[10] Despite being eligible, she did not receive grief counseling following her father's death. In a 2019 report, the Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth noted that Child and Family Services was clearly aware that she was struggling in the period between her father's death and her own. Records from the time document Fontaine being increasingly absent from school, missing assignments and being suspended from school, getting into verbal confrontations and physical fights that resulted in police being called, getting medical treatment for self-harm, and being reported missing three times. During this period, her family repeatedly asked for help from child and family services.^[7]

Disappearances and discovery

In early 2014, at the age of 15, Tina Fontaine went to Winnipeg to visit her mother. By that time, Duck had lost custody of her children as a result of her involvement in sex work and her struggling with alcoholism.^[7][8] On 17 and 18 July, Fontaine was under Child and Family Services (CFS) care in Winnipeg, housed at a downtown hotel.^[8]

On 31 July 2014, Fontaine was reported missing to Winnipeg Police Service (WPS).^[11][12] Her aunt Lana later said that Fontaine had stayed with her during the August long weekend (1–3 August).^[11] On 5 August, Fontaine telephoned her CFS worker and was subsequently picked up by members of CFS and WPS.^[11] What happened to Fontaine between 5 and 8 August is unclear, but she remained a missing youth.^[11] She presented at a youth shelter in the early morning hours of 8 August, but left shortly thereafter. At 5:15 am on 8 August,^[9] two police officers encountered her in a truck with an allegedly drunk driver as part of a traffic stop, but did not take her into custody, even though she was known to be missing.^[11][13] The two constables were suspended for their actions and left the police force.^[14]

At 10 am, she was found passed out in an alleyway near the University of Winnipeg.^[8][9] She was escorted to the Health Sciences Centre for treatment. While at the hospital, Fontaine mentioned to her CFS worker that she had been associating with a 62-year-old man named Raymond Cormier.^[8] After being medically cleared for discharge, Fontaine was checked into a downtown hotel placement, which she soon left.^[9]

An 18-year-old girl who claimed to have been with Fontaine shortly before she disappeared told CBC News of events that she said happened in the hours leading up to Fontaine's disappearance. Identified by CBC News as "Katrina", she said that after she met Fontaine between 10 and 11 pm on 7 August, they went to eat at the Macdonald Youth Services emergency shelter at around 2:30 am.^[15] Katrina said she believed Fontaine was drunk, and requested the shelter staff keep her overnight, but that Fontaine refused to stay and refused to give her name.^[15] She said that after seeing Fontaine get into the truck and the encounter with the police, she lost contact with Fontaine until around 8 pm, after Fontaine left the hotel where she was staying.^[15] At around 3 am the following morning, she said the two were approached on Ellice Avenue by a man who offered Fontaine money to perform a sex act.^[15] Katrina said Fontaine accepted and left with the man, and that Katrina followed them but lost sight of the two in the dark.^[15] Fontaine was reported missing again on 9 August.^[16]

At around 1:30 pm on 17 August, a body was found wrapped in plastic and a duvet cover and weighed down with rocks in the Red River.^{[17][16][18][19]} The body was identified as that of Fontaine's the following day.^[20] Police believe she had died on or around 10 August.^[21] An autopsy was unable to conclusively determine a cause of death.^[7]

Trial

Raymond Joseph Cormier (aged 53) was charged with second-degree murder in December 2015.^[16][22] He pleaded not guilty.^[8]

The trial began 29 January 2018.^[23][24] A witness testified that the last time that he saw Fontaine, she was arguing with Cormier because he had sold her bicycle frame for drugs.^[8] The Crown did not introduce any forensic evidence or eyewitnesses to directly link Cormier to Fontaine's death, and the cause of her death remained undetermined.^[25] The largely circumstantial case relied on the suspect's statements that were secretly recorded during a police sting operation. Cormier's lawyers argued that, without a determination on the cause of death, it could not be known for certain that she died as a result of an unlawful act, and that Cormier should be acquitted "on that [argument] alone." Cormier was found not guilty on 22 February 2018.^[5]

On 13 March 2018, Crown prosecutors announced that they would not appeal the case.^[8]

Aftermath and legacy

Fontaine was buried on Sagkeeng First Nation next to her father. A memorial was placed at the site on the first anniversary of the discovery of her body at the Red River.^[6]

In response to Fontaine's death, the Canadian Human Rights Commission requested an inquiry into the number of missing and murdered Indigenous women (MMIW) in Canada. The RCMP already had such a study underway, which was completed in 2014. Acting Chief Commissioner David Langtry wrote, "Once again our hearts are filled with grief and sadness as we mourn the brutal and senseless murder of an Aboriginal girl. Tina must not disappear into the oblivion of statistics."^[26] With the change in government, in December 2015, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced that a national inquiry titled "Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls" would be undertaken. Five independent commissioners were appointed, and commissioners and staff began to consult with families, activist organizations, and others about how to structure the inquiry.

Also in response to the death, a volunteer group known as Drag the Red was formed. They have begun to regularly drag portions of the Red River to find bodies or evidence in missing persons or homicide cases.^[27] Tina's death also led to the creation of the Bear Clan Patrol, which promotes safety and crime prevention in Winnipeg's North End.^[8] Additionally, a local Inuit woman, Holly Jarrett, has started social media campaigns: the #AmINext hashtag and a Change.org petition in response to Fontaine's death. The hashtag campaign called for a national inquiry and allowed Indigenous women to express their feelings about the issue of MMIW.^[28]

Manitoba's Child and Family Services (CFS) announced that, as of 1 June 2015, it would no longer place children in hotels.^[8] The Strong Hearted Buffalo Women Crisis Stabilization Unit, a semi-secure crisis intervention program for Indigenous girls considered to be at risk of sexual exploitation, was created in the fall of 2015 in response to Fontaine's case.^[9] Through federal funding, the Ndinawe Youth Resource Centre renamed itself "Tina's Safe Haven" and launched a 24/7 safe space for youth in November 2018.^[9]

After Cormier's acquittal, Indigenous leaders in Manitoba criticized governmental systems for not protecting Fontaine: "We as a nation need to do better for our young people," said Grand Chief Sheila North, of Keewatinowi Okimakanak. Carolyn Bennett, federal Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations, tweeted: "Tina's is a tragic story that demonstrates the failures of all the systems for Indigenous children and youth on every level... we need to fix this." A day after the end of the trial, over a thousand people marched in Winnipeg to honour Fontaine and support her family.^[8]

On 28 February 2018, the Justice for our Stolen Children Camp was set up on Wascana Park in Regina in response to the death of Fontaine and Colten Boushie.^[29] The next month, political activist Indygo Arscott held a rally outside Toronto City Hall to voice outrage in memory of Fontaine due to Cormier being found not guilty of the crime.^[30][31] In March 2019, Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth's Daphne Penrose released a report documenting Fontaine's life and the shortcomings of the agencies that were meant to protect her.^[9]

See also

• List of solved missing person cases
• List of unsolved murders

References

1. Blaze Baum, Kathryn (22 August 2014). "How many more women will it take, asks family of slain teen Tina Fontaine". The Globe and Mail. Archived from the original on 25 August 2016.
2. MacLean, Cameron (17 February 2018). "How Tina Fontaine died remains a mystery following Raymond Cormier's acquittal". CBC. Archived from the original on 2 January 2019.
3. Renata D'Aliesio, Joe Friesen and Stephanie Chambers (11 December 2015). "Alleged murderer was a prime suspect not long after Tina Fontaine's death". The Globe and Mail. Archived from the original on 5 April 2017.
4. Steele, Heather (11 December 2015). "What we know about Tina Fontaine's accused killer, Raymond Cormier". Global News. Archived from the original on 14 December 2015.
5. "Jury finds Raymond Cormier not guilty in death of Tina Fontaine". CBC News. 22 February 2018. Archived from the original on 22 February 2018.
6. Miljure, Ben (17 August 2015). "Memorial for Tina Fontaine unveiled one year after teen's body pulled from Red River". CTV Winnipeg. Archived from the original on 21 August 2016.
7. Penrose, Daphne (March 2019). "A Place Where it Feels Like Home: The Story of Tina Fontaine" (PDF). Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. p. 15.
8. Conn, Heather (5 December 2019). "Tina Fontaine". The Canadian Encyclopedia.
9. May, Katie (12 March 2019). "'A shameful legacy': Scathing report on Tina Fontaine's troubled life, tragic death points to systemic failures rooted in colonialism". Winnipeg Free Press. Archived from the original on 17 March 2019.
10. Lambert, Stephen (16 October 2014). "After her father was beaten to death, Tina Fontaine went astray: 'She only lasted two months in Winnipeg'". National Post. Archived from the original on 22 December 2015.
11. Dawkins, Glen (11 December 2015). "Party-house acquaintance, 53, arrested in murder of Tina Fontaine". The Winnipeg Sun.
12. "Some events leading up to the arrest of a man in the death of Tina Fontaine". The Winnipeg Free Press. The Canadian Press. 11 December 2015. Archived from the original on 13 December 2015.
13. "Tina Fontaine died because police, CFS failed her, family says". CBC. 25 September 2014. Archived from the original on 13 September 2016.
14. "Security video of Tina Fontaine captured days before she was killed shown in court". 6 February 2018. Archived from the original on 7 February 2018.
15. "Tina Fontaine last seen leaving with man in West End, says friend". CBC. 25 September 2014. Archived from the original on 2 October 2016.
16. "Raymond Cormier, 53, charged with murder in Tina Fontaine death". CBC. 11 December 2015. Archived from the original on 11 December 2015.
17. Dangerfield, Katie (23 February 2018). "How the tragic death of Tina Fontaine helped spark the MMIWG inquiry". Global. Archived from the original on 3 March 2018.
18. "Tina Fontaine, 15, found in bag in Red River". The Globe and Mail. 17 August 2014. Archived from the original on 9 August 2016.
19. "Winnipeg police make arrest in case of Tina Fontaine". Toronto Star. 11 December 2015. Archived from the original on 10 July 2017.
20. Puxley, Chinta; Lambert, Steve (18 August 2014). "Body of 15-year-old girl found in Winnipeg's Red River". CTV News. Archived from the original on 28 August 2016.
21. "Accused in Tina Fontaine killing had violent history, documents reveal". The Globe and Mail. 14 December 2015. Archived from the original on 13 September 2016.
22. "Murder charge laid in death of Tina Fontaine". CTV. 11 December 2015. Archived from the original on 11 December 2015.
23. "Trial begins for Tina Fontaine's accused killer". Global News. 28 January 2018. Archived from the original on 1 February 2018.
24. "Tina Fontaine's cause of death remains undetermined: pathologist tells Cormier trial". CTV News. 31 January 2018. Archived from the original on 31 January 2018.
25. "No DNA evidence linking Raymond Cormier to Tina Fontaine, court hears". CBC News Manitoba. 31 January 2018. Archived from the original on 10 March 2018.
26. "Tina Fontaine's murder renews call for inquiry into missing, murdered Indigenous women". APTN. 19 August 2014. Archived from the original on 17 June 2016.
27. "Drag the Red". Vice Media. 2016. Archived from the original on 2016-10-02.
28. Burman, Jenny (2016-04-28). "Multicultural Feeling, Feminist Rage, Indigenous Refusal". Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies. 16 (4): 361–372. doi:10.1177/1532708616638693.
29. "After 108 days, Justice For Our Stolen Children camp comes down". Regina Leader-Post. 15 June 2018. Archived from the original on 23 June 2018.
30. Banares, Ilya (5 March 2018). ""Justice for Tina Fontaine" rally held at Nathan Phillips Square". Archived from the original on 27 July 2018.
31. Johnson, Rhiannon (3 March 2018). "Thousands gather in memory of Tina Fontaine in Toronto". Archived from the original on 23 June 2018.

Further reading

• Jolly, Joanna (2019). Red River Girl: The Life and Death of Tina Fontaine. Penguin Canada. ISBN 9780735233935.
• Lavell-Harvard, D. Memee; Brant, Jennifer, eds. (2016). Forever Loved: Exposing the Hidden Crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls in Canada. Demeter. ISBN 978-1-77258-020-4.

External links

• BBC Assignment: Canada's Red River Murders