Bank of the United States v. Deveaux

Bank of the United States v. Deveaux, 9 US 61 (1809) is an early US corporate law case decided by the US Supreme Court. It held that corporations have the capacity to sue in federal court on grounds of diversity under article three, section two of the United States Constitution.[1] It was the first Supreme Court case to examine corporate rights and, while it is rarely featured prominently in US legal history, it set an important precedent for the legal rights of corporations, particularly with regard to corporate personhood.[2]

The court ruled that corporations composed of citizens from one state may sue on behalf of those citizens in circuit court citizens from another state. The court specifies that while corporations may sue on behalf of citizens, corporations cannot be citizens.[3] In other words, the court ruled that while only citizens may sue in court, they may do so under a corporate name.[4]

Background

Georgian Jeffersonian politicians first provoked a court case when, in 1805, they imposed a tax on the Bank of the United States' locally held capital. Many Jeffersonian Democrats strongly opposed the chartering of a national bank as a violation of states rights and wanted to see it dissolved. However, because state governments lack the power to directly legislate federal institutions under the supremacy clause, Jeffersonian Democrats in Georgia chose another route to fight back against the Bank: taxes. The lawmakers hoped that heavy taxes on the bank would drive it out of Georgia.

The Bank decided to ignore the tax in an act of civil disobedience, hoping that a conflict with the state would bring the question of corporate rights in front of the Supreme Court.

After the Bank refused to pay the new taxes, a Georgian tax collector named Peter Deveaux decided to take matters into his own hands, forcibly confiscating two boxes of silver from the Savannah branch of the Bank. The Bank sued Deveaux in Federal court, circumventing the Georgia state court for fear of bias. The case came in front of the Supreme Court, headed by John Marshall, a Federalist and supporter of the bank.[2]

Syllabus

William Cranch, the Reporter of Decision of the Supreme Court, summarized the decision of the court.

A corporation aggregate composed of citizens of one state may sue a citizen of another state in the circuit court of the United States.

Where the jurisdiction of the courts of the United States depends not on the character of the parties, but upon the nature of the case, the circuit courts derive no jurisdiction from the Judiciary Act except in case of a controversy between citizens of the same state claiming lands under grants from different states.

No right is conferred on the bank by its act of incorporation to sue in the federal courts. A corporation aggregate cannot, in its corporate capacity, be a citizen.

The duties of this Court to exercise jurisdiction where it is conferred and not to usurp it where it is not conferred are of equal obligation. The Constitution therefore and the law are to be expounded without a leaning the one way or the other, according to those general principles which usually govern in the construction of fundamental or other laws.

A constitution, from its nature, deals in generals, not in detail. Its framers cannot perceive minute distinctions which arise in the progress of the nation, and therefore confine it to the establishment of broad and general principles.

The Judicial Department was introduced into the American Constitution under impressions and with views which are too apparent not to be perceived by all. However true the fact may be that the tribunals of the states will administer justice as impartially as those of the nation to parties of every description, it is not less true that the Constitution itself either entertains apprehensions on this subject or views with such indulgence the possible fears and apprehensions of suitors that it has established national tribunals for the decision of controversies between aliens and a citizen or between citizens of different states.[3]

Judgment

Chief Justice John Marshall gave the leading decision.

By the Judicial Act, the jurisdiction of the circuit courts is extended to cases where the constitutional right to plead and be impleaded in the courts of the union depends on the character of the parties; but where that right depends on the nature of the case, the circuit courts derive no jurisdiction from that act except in the single case of a controversy between citizens of the same state claiming lands under grants from different states.

Unless, then, jurisdiction over this cause has been given to the circuit court by some other than the Judicial Act, the Bank of the United States had not a right to sue in that court upon the principle that the case arises under a law of the United States...

...

As our ideas of a corporation, its privileges, and its disabilities, are derived entirely from the English books, we resort to them for aid in ascertaining its character. It is defined as a mere creature of the law, invisible, intangible, and incorporeal. Yet when we examine the subject further we find that corporations have been included within terms of description appropriated to real persons.

...

In the case of King v. Gardner, reported by Cowper, a corporation was decided, by the Court of King's Bench, to come within the description of "occupiers or inhabitants." In that case, the poor rates, to which the lands of the corporation were declared to be liable, were not assessed to the actual occupant, for there was none, but to the corporation. And the principle established by the case appears to be that the poor rates on vacant ground belonging to a corporation may be assessed to the corporation as being inhabitants or occupiers of that ground. In this case Lord Mansfield notices and overrules an inconsiderate dictum of Justice Yates that a corporation could not be an inhabitant or occupier.

These opinions are not precisely in point, but they serve to show that for the general purposes and objects of a law, this invisible, incorporeal creature of the law may be considered as having corporeal qualities.

...

There is a case, however, reported in 12 Mod., which is thought precisely in point. The Corporation of London brought a suit against Wood by its corporate name in the mayor's court. The suit was brought by the mayor and commonalty, and was tried before the mayor and aldermen. The judgment rendered in this cause was brought before the Court of King's bench and reversed because the court was deprived of its jurisdiction by the character of the individuals who were members of the corporation.

In that case, the objection, that a corporation was an invisible, intangible thing, a mere incorporeal legal entity in which the characters of the individuals who composed it were completely merged, was urged and was considered. The judges unanimously declared that they could look beyond the corporate name and notice the character of the individual. In the opinions, which were delivered seriatim, several cases are put which serve to illustrate the principle, and fortify the decision.

The case of Mayor and Commonalty v. Wood is the stronger, because it is on the point of jurisdiction. It appears to the Court to be a full authority for the case now under consideration. It seems not possible to distinguish them from each other.

If, then, the Congress of the United States had in terms enacted that incorporated aliens might sue a citizen or that the incorporated citizens of one state might sue a citizen of another state in the federal courts by its corporate name, this Court would not have felt itself justified in declaring that such a law transcended the Constitution.

...

If a corporation may sue in the courts of the union, the Court is of opinion that the averment in this case is sufficient.

Being authorized to sue in it corporate name, it could make the averment, and it must apply to the plaintiffs as individuals, because it could not be true as applied to the corporation.

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Winkler, Adam (2018). "Bank of the United States v. Deveaux and the Birth of Constitutional Rights for Corporations". Journal of Supreme Court History. 43 – via Hein Online.
  2. ^ a b Winkler, Adam (2018). We the Corporations: How American Businesses Won Their Civil Rights. W. W. Norton & Company. pp. 76–77. ISBN 978-0-87140-384-1.
  3. ^ a b "Bank of the United States v. Deveaux, 9 U.S. 61 (1809)". Justia Law. Retrieved June 17, 2021.
  4. ^ "Bank of United States v. Deveaux | Case Brief for Law School | LexisNexis". Community. Retrieved August 19, 2021.

Read other articles:

Auditorat Utama Keuangan Negara I Badan Pemeriksa KeuanganRepublik IndonesiaGambaran umumDasar hukumUndang-Undang Nomor 15 Tahun 2006Peratura BPK RI Tahun 2020Susunan organisasiAuditor UtamaDr. Akhsanul Khaq M.B.A., CMA., CFE., CA., Ak., CSFA., CPA., CFrA.Kepala SekretariatDr. Taufiq Supriadi S.E., M.T., CSFA., CertDA. KepalaAuditorat I.AEdy Witono S.E., M.M., Ak., CSFA.Auditorat I.BSarjono S.E., M.B.A., CSFA.Auditorat I.CIda Irawati S.E., M.Adm.Pemb., Ak., ACPA., CA., CSFA., CFrA.Auditorat I...

 

Ізраїльсько-південноафриканські відносини Ізраїль ПАР Ізраїльсько-південноафриканські відносини — двосторонні дипломатичні відносини між Ізраїлем та Південно-Африканською Республікою. Історія Південна Африка була серед 33 держав, що підтримали План поділу Палестин...

 

American actress (1905–1993) Not to be confused with Mina Loy. Myrna LoyMyrna Loy in 1941BornMyrna Adele Williams(1905-08-02)August 2, 1905Helena, Montana, U.S.DiedDecember 14, 1993(1993-12-14) (aged 88)New York City, U.S.Resting placeForestvale CemeteryHelena, Montana, U.S.46°39′22″N 112°02′11″W / 46.6562°N 112.0365°W / 46.6562; -112.0365Other namesThe Queen of HollywoodOccupationActressYears active1925–1982Political partyDemocrat[1&...

تاينكاسل باركمعلومات عامةالمنطقة الإدارية مدينة إدنبرة البلد  المملكة المتحدة التشييد والافتتاحالافتتاح الرسمي 1886 المهندس المعماري أرشيبالد ليتش الاستعمالالرياضة كرة القدم دوري الرغبي (1998 – 1998)دوري الرغبي (1999 – 1999) المستضيف هارت أوف ميدلوثيان London Broncos (en) (1998 – 1998)Newcast...

 

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع مسقط (توضيح). وِلاَيةُ مَسْقَط مدينة بوابة مَسْقَط  علم أسماء أخرى Masqaṭ الاسم الرسمي مسقط  الإحداثيات 23°36′N 58°35′E / 23.600°N 58.583°E / 23.600; 58.583 تقسيم إداري  البلد  سلطنة عمان  المحافظة وِلاَيةُ مَسْقَط عاصمة لـ سلطنة عمانسلطنة مسق...

 

2003 book by Charles Murray This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Human Accomplishment – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (April 2022)...

الكنيسة الرسولية الأرمنية كاتدرائية إتشميادزين في فاغارشاباد في أرمينيا من القرن الرابع الميلادي.كاتدرائية إتشميادزين في فاغارشاباد في أرمينيا من القرن الرابع الميلادي. المؤسس غريغوريوس المستنير  الأصل أرثوذكسية مشرقية  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   كاتدرائية كريكور لو...

 

Finnish religion redirects here. For ancient Finnish religion, see Finnish paganism. Religion by country Africa Algeria Angola Benin Botswana Burkina Faso Burundi Cameroon Cape Verde Central African Republic Chad Comoros Democratic Republic of the Congo Republic of the Congo Djibouti Egypt Equatorial Guinea Eritrea Eswatini Ethiopia Gabon Gambia Ghana Guinea Guinea-Bissau Ivory Coast Kenya Lesotho Liberia Libya Madagascar Malawi Mali Mauritania Mauritius Morocco Mozambique Namibia Niger Niger...

 

KMC MusicTypeDivisionIndustryMusical instrumentsPredecessorKaman Music CorporationFounded1966; 57 years ago (1966)HeadquartersBloomfield, Connecticut, United StatesKey peopleCharles KamanProductsString instruments Brass instruments Percussion instruments AmplifiersBrands Ampeg Daisy Rock Girl Hamer Remo Randall Washburn ParentExertis JAMWebsitekmcmusic.com KMC Music is an owner and distributor of several brands of musical instruments. The company is currently a subsidiary of...

For the Romanian daily, see Seara (newspaper). Municipality in South, BrazilSearaMunicipality FlagSealCountry BrazilRegionSouthStateSanta CatarinaMesoregionOeste CatarinensePopulation (2020 [1]) • Total17,576Time zoneUTC -3Websitewww.seara.sc.gov.br Seara is a municipality in the state of Santa Catarina in the South region of Brazil.[2][3][4][5] The Museu Entomológico Fritz Plaumann is located in the town. See also List of municip...

 

2004 song by Kelly Clarkson BreakawaySingle by Kelly Clarksonfrom the album The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement: Original Soundtrack and Breakaway ReleasedJuly 19, 2004 (2004-07-19)StudioHenson Recording (Hollywood)GenreFolk-popLength3:57LabelWalt DisneyRCASongwriter(s)Matthew GerrardBridget BenenateAvril LavigneProducer(s)John ShanksKelly Clarkson singles chronology The Trouble with Love Is (2003) Breakaway (2004) Since U Been Gone (2004) Alternative cover2006 Re-issue Mu...

 

Competition at the Olympic Snow Stadium in 1956. Stadio della neve was a temporary stadium located in Cortina d'Ampezzo, Italy. Located in the Campo di Sotto area, the venue hosted the cross-country skiing and the cross-country skiing part of the Nordic combined events for the 1956 Winter Olympics. Post Olympics the stands and scoreboard was removed with the site now a grass field. References 1956 Winter Olympics official report. pp. 155–63. (in English and Italian) 46°31′14″N 12...

2005 Singaporean filmA Wicked TaleA Wicked Tale poster, 2005Directed byTzang Merwyn TongWritten byTzang Merwyn TongStarring Evelyn Maria Ng Johan Ydstrand Wolf Danker Catherine Sng ProductioncompanyINRI studioRelease date 2005 (2005) Running time45 minutesCountrySingapore A Wicked Tale is a 2005 Singaporean experimental short film written and directed by Tzang Merwyn Tong. The film premiered to at the 34th Rotterdam International Film Festival. This low-budget film is a dark reimagining ...

 

British architect (1944–2022) Marco GoldschmiedBorn(1944-03-28)28 March 1944Harrogate, Yorkshire, EnglandDied7 July 2022(2022-07-07) (aged 78)Alma materArchitectural AssociationOccupationArchitectPracticeRichard Rogers Partnership Marco Lorenzo Sinnott Goldschmied PPRIBA (28 March 1944 – 7 July 2022) was a British architect best known as co-founder and managing director of Richard Rogers Partnership. He was latterly involved with running the Marco Goldschmied Foundation and was ...

 

1931 film The Texas RangerTheatrical release posterDirected byD. Ross LedermanWritten byForrest SheldonProductioncompanySol Lesser ProductionsDistributed byColumbia PicturesRelease date May 10, 1931 (1931-05-10) Running time61 minutesCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglish The Texas Ranger is a 1931 American pre-Code Western film directed by D. Ross Lederman.[1][2] Cast Buck Jones as Jim Logan, Texas Ranger Carmelita Geraghty as Helen Clayton Harry Woods as Matt Tay...

Indian public sector undertaking This article is about the Uranium powered PHWR and PWR operator. For the Plutonium and Thorium powered fast breeder nuclear reactor operator, see BHAVINI. Nuclear Power Corporation of India LimitedTypePublic Sector UndertakingISININE206D09194IndustryElectric utilityFoundedSeptember 1987; 36 years ago (1987-09)[1]HeadquartersWorld Trade Centre, Cuffe Parade, Colaba, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India[2]Area servedIndiaKey peopleB....

 

This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: PTT Exploration and Production – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) PTT Exploration and ProductionNative nameบริษัท ปตท. สำรวจและผลิตปิโตรเลียม จำกัด (มห...

 

Title character and the protagonist of the Kung Fu Panda franchise In this Chinese name, the family name is Ping. This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Po Kung Fu Panda – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2020) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Fictional ...

Questa voce sull'argomento piloti di Formula 1 è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Jimmy Stewart Nazionalità  Regno Unito Automobilismo Carriera Carriera in Formula 1 Stagioni 1953 GP disputati 1   Modifica dati su Wikidata · Manuale Jimmy Stewart (Milton, 6 marzo 1931 – Helensburgh, 3 gennaio 2008) è stato un pilota automobilistico britannico. Partecipò al Gran Premio di Gran Bretagna 1953 a bordo di una Cooper T20 del...

 

コディ・ゼラーCody Zeller 2019年のゼラーニューオーリンズ・ペリカンズポジション C / PF所属リーグ NBA基本情報愛称 Big Handsome国籍 アメリカ合衆国生年月日 (1992-10-05) 1992年10月5日(31歳)出身地 インディアナ州ワシントン(英語版)身長 211cm (6 ft 11 in)体重 109kg (240 lb)ウィングスパン 216cm  (7 ft 1 in)シューズ エア・ジョーダン[1]キ...

 

Strategi Solo vs Squad di Free Fire: Cara Menang Mudah!