Walton composed the cycle at his home in Ischia in the first half of 1962. He was not a pianist, and found writing for the instrument irksome. He told his publisher that the first song in particular needed an orchestra.[1] The soloist at the first performance was Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, whose voice Walton had in mind when composing the music for Cressida in his opera. She was an accomplished linguist and according to Gerald Moore, who played the piano at the premiere, she sang the songs "as if she were an Englishwoman".[2]
The verse is by the 18th–19th century English poet Thomas Jordan, praising London's wealth and luxury. The opening stanza is:
Let all the Nine Muses lay by their abuses,
Their railing and drolling on tricks of the Strand,
To pen us a ditty in praise of the City,
Their treasure, and pleasure, their pow'r and command.
The music critic and biographer Michael Kennedy writes "Walton excelled in ceremonial works of this kind ... the Walton of the Coronation marches is not far away in this description of a Lord Mayor's banquet, with corks popping in thirds.[2]
2. Glide gently
The second song is a setting of an early poem by Wordsworth, "Remembrance of Collins" (1789). It opens:
Glide gently, thus for ever, ever glide,
O Thames! that other bards may see
As lovely visions by thy side
As now, fair river! come to me.
The critic Stanley Sadie described Walton's setting as "suave and lyrical music, full of Brittenish tonal side-slips".[5] Kennedy considers it "the gem of the cycle, a beautiful and imaginative evocation of the Thames".[2]
3. Wapping Old Stairs
The lyric for this song is by an unknown writer, although it is sometimes erroneously attributed to Thackeray.[n 1] It is a wry complaint from a not-too-heartbroken young woman about being jilted by a sailor. It begins:
Your Molly has never been false, she declares,
Since last time we parted at Wapping Old Stairs,
When I swore that I still would continue the same,
And gave you the 'bacco box, marked with your name.
In this song, Sadie finds the piano version with its "simple monochrome accompaniment" (with a time signature of one minim per bar) preferable to the orchestral.[4]
Twas on a holy Thursday, their innocent faces clean,
The children walking two and two, in red and blue and green:
Grey-headed beadles walked before, with wands as white as snow,
Till into the high dome of St Paul's they like Thames waters flow.
Kennedy comments that in this song Walton uses a different figuration for each of the three stanzas. Sadie remarked on the music's "grey and grave sonorities".[5] He was not certain that the orchestral version of this song was an improvement on "concentration and intimacy" of the piano original.[4]
5. The Contrast
Morris's poem, dating from 1798, is a humorous complaint by a confirmed city-dweller about the slow pace of life in the countryside. It begins
In London I never knew what I'd be at,
Enraptured with this, and enchanted by that,
I'm wild with the sweets of variety's plan,
And life seems a blessing too happy for man.
But the country, Lord help me!, sets all matters right,
So calm and composing from morning to night;
Oh! it settles the spirit when nothing is seen
But an ass on a common, a goose on a green.
Kennedy comments on Walton's staccato accompaniment to patter in this song and the contrasting "sustained chords and sheepbells of rural peace".[2]
6. Rhyme
The cycle ends with the children's song "Oranges and Lemons" in an 18th-century version that has, as Sadie observes, "several verses unknown in most nurseries".[5] Kennedy describes the song as "a merry cadenza of bell chimes, beginning at St Clement's".[2]
^The misunderstanding probably arises because the anonymous verse was included in George Saintsbury's much-reprinted edition of Thackeray's verse to accompany Thackeray's two parodies of it.[6]