The top two seeds, Liberty and Longwood, had byes to the second round. Teams were seeded by record within the conference, with a tiebreaker system to seed teams with identical conference records.
Seed
School
Conference
Overall
Tiebreaker
1
Liberty‡
18–3
44–12
2
Longwood
17–4
37–14
3
Radford
13–8
33–17
4
Campbell
12–9
26–25
5
Gardner–Webb
8–13
28–27
6
Winthrop
7–14
17–30
2–1 vs Charleston Southern
‡ – Big South regular season champions. Overall records are as of the end of the regular season.