Highlights of the season included a 45–0 victory over Boston College in the season opener and a narrow 12–10 victory over No. 8 Notre Dame. The Wildcats were 4–2 after six games, but then lost three consecutive games at the end of the season.
Senior center and middle linebacker Larry Onesti was the team captain and received first-team All-Big Ten honors. Senior tackle Boyd "Bud" Melvin was selected as the team's most valuable player.
The team gained an average of 200.1 rushing yards and 80.6 passing yards per game. On defense, the Wildcats gave up an average of 155.6 rushing yards and 106.2 passing yards per game.[11]
Though he did not become a starter until the sixth game of the season,[6] sophomore quarterback Tom O'Grady led the team in total offense, tallying 322 passing yards and 283 rushing yards for a total of 605 yards.[11] In his first start, he tallied 101 rushing yards and completed seven of 13 passes for 113 passing yards.[6] For the entire season, he completed 28 of 59 passes (47.5%) with one touchdown pass and seven interceptions for a quarterback rating of 75.2.[11]
Sophomore fullback Bill Swingle led Northwestern to a 45-0 victory over Boston College in the season opener, rushing for three touchdowns (including a school-record 95-yard touchdown run) and also passed for a touchdown.[1] He later missed two games due to a cist on the back of his knee.[12] He finished the season as the team's leading rusher with 476 rushing yards on 79 carries for an average of 6.0 yards per carry.[11]
The team's leading receivers were Willie Stinson (10 receptions, 158 yards, 15.8-yard average), Chuck Logan (13 receptions, 130 yards, 10.0-yard average), and Dave Cox (9 receptions, 100 yards, 11.1-yard average).[11]
Awards and honors
Senior tackle Boyd "Bud" Melvin was selected as the most valuable player on the 1961 Northwestern team. He was a regular for Northwestern on offense in 1959 and 1960 as well and became a two-way player in 1961, playing on both offense and defense. Coach Ara Parseghian rated Melvin as the best blocker he had ever coached and added: "Melvin was like another coach on the field. He knew every player's assignment . . . I've never seen a more dedicated football player than Melvin."[13]